Politics / Hiding in Plain Sight / June 13, 2025

Trump Is Weaponizing the Justice System in Plain Sight

Kilmar Abrego Garcia is just the latest example of cases in which the administration is finding the flimsiest of reasons to label undocumented immigrants as “criminals.”

Sasha Abramsky
Signs are left on the ground including two that read “This was a kidnapping” and “Bring Kilmar home now!” as protesters break outside the US District Court for the District of Maryland on May 16, 2025, in Greenbelt, Maryland. Protesters rallied outside the court during a hearing for a Maryland resident from El Salvador, Kilmar Abrego Garcia, who was detained in a notoriously violent maximum-security prison in El Salvador.
Signs are left on the ground including two that read “This was a kidnapping” and “Bring Kilmar home now!” as protesters break outside the US District Court for the District of Maryland on May 16, 2025, in Greenbelt, Maryland. Protesters rallied outside the court during a hearing for a Maryland resident from El Salvador, Kilmar Abrego Garcia, who was detained in a notoriously violent maximum-security prison in El Salvador.(Andrew Harnik / Getty Images)

Last Friday, the Trump administration suddenly announced that Kilmar Abrego Garcia had been brought back to the United States from the mega-prison in El Salvador, CECOT, two months after the US Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the administration must facilitate his return.

It ought to have been cause for celebration. But it wasn’t. Instead of returning Garcia to his family in Maryland, officials sent him to a jail in Tennessee, where he is now facing an array of human trafficking charges that could result in his spending the rest of his life behind bars.

I guess it’s possible that Garcia is indeed a master of deception; that all the years he spent as a construction worker in Maryland since his arrival in 2011 were nothing but a smokescreen. But it’s also possible that the government has gone on a fishing expedition, dredging up an old traffic stop in Tennessee, during which the officers who stopped him alleged that he was driving a car full of undocumented immigrants rather than the construction workers Garcia claimed they were, in an apparent attempt to give an after-the-fact justification for Garcia’s entirely unjustified deportation to CECOT in March. It seems entirely likely that they are making Garcia out to be a high-level criminal operative because that’s more palatable to them than admitting that they screwed up with his initial deportation.

From the get-go, the administration has refused to back down gracefully in the Garcia case. After government officials acknowledged that he was deported because of an “administrative error”—along with a couple hundred other Venezuelan and El Salvadoran men who were quite deliberately, and in cold blood, deported to indefinite detention in CECOT—the administration fired the Justice Department lawyer who let it be known in court that he was uncomfortable with what had gone down for not being loyal enough to Trump’s agenda. When US district judge Paula Xinis ordered the administration to provide additional information on the case, Secretary of State Marco Rubio and other officials invoked manifestly bogus national security arguments as a rationale for not complying. And when the courts, including the US Supreme Court, ordered them to “facilitate” the return of Garcia, the administration simply pretended that it had no sway over El Salvador President Nayib Bukele and couldn’t compel Garcia’s return (a fiction that was promptly undermined by Trump’s admitting that he could easily secure Garcia’s release if he wanted to, but that he chose not to).

Now, the administration is further weaponizing the justice system to legitimize their actions against Garcia. So blatant is this that a veteran DOJ prosecutor in Nashville, Tennessee, Ben Schrader, resigned over concerns that Garcia was being prosecuted as a vindictive political reprisal rather than on anything approaching a bulletproof case.

It’s part of a pattern of going after any and all undocumented immigrants, and then finding the flimsiest of reasons to label them “criminals” or “terrorists,” and those who support and provide services to them as aiders and abetters of criminals.

Witness what has been happening in Los Angeles over the past months. In mid-April, plainclothes DHS agents attempted to gain access to first graders in two elementary schools in the city, fraudulently claiming that both the children’s guardians had given their permission for the interviews, and that they were only doing wellness checks to make sure the kids weren’t being abused by criminally minded undocumented guardians.

And this past week garment workers and day laborers have been dragged, handcuffed, from their jobs, warehoused in makeshift detention centers, and pressured to sign papers agreeing to be deported. Some of them have then been summarily dumped at the border crossings and made to walk into Mexico.

Those who have hit the streets to oppose these tactics are being labeled “insurrectionists,” to justify the federalizing of national guard troops and US marines against protesters. Among those caught in this vise was SEIU California president David Huerta, who was arrested at the protests last week, and who spent two days in jail before posting bond. He is being charged with conspiracy to impede an officer and could, if convicted, spend years in a federal prison.

Astoundingly, on Thursday, when US Senator Alex Padilla, who was in LA to receive a briefing with Gen. Gregory Guillot about conditions on the ground, attempted to ask DHS Secretary Kristi Noem questions at an event she was holding in the federal building in West Los Angeles, he was violently manhandled out of the building by buzz-cut FBI agents.

The Nation Weekly

Fridays. A weekly digest of the best of our coverage.
By signing up, you confirm that you are over the age of 16 and agree to receive occasional promotional offers for programs that support The Nation’s journalism. You may unsubscribe or adjust your preferences at any time. You can read our Privacy Policy here.

“He tried to ask the Secretary a question, and was forcibly removed by federal agents, forced to the ground and handcuffed. He is not currently detained, and we are working to get additional information,” his press office said.

Lest anyone think this isn’t a full-court effort to intimidate allies of immigrants into submission, House and Senate committees have over the past few days sent letters to 200 NGOs, including CHIRLA, the leading immigrants-rights organization in Los Angeles, accusing them of illegally assisting undocumented immigrants during the Biden years and of illegal actions this week against federal officers looking to arrest migrants.

In San Diego, a neighborhood trattoria was raided, all of the workers were handcuffed, and—in the face of neighborhood opposition and protest—several were bundled into vans and driven off to a detention facility.

In California’s farm belt, raids have been occurring this week against farm laborers—which, if they continue, could ultimately result in fruit and vegetable shortages across the country as harvest go unpicked. Elsewhere in the state, car washes are being raided.

Such raids are going on nationwide, from West Coast cities through to Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket, in Massachusetts, with snatch-and-grab ICE operations shamefully marketed to the MAGA base with names such as Operation Patriot.

Let’s be absolutely clear: There’s literally nothing patriotic in sending masked, armed, agents in unmarked vehicles to kidnap hardworking family men and women, to ship them off to unidentified detention sites, and to deny them access to phones and to attorneys, as is currently happening all over the country.

Stephen Miller, avatar of all things awful when it comes to immigration enforcement, has demanded at least 3,000 arrests per day. To get there, ICE agents are abandoning all but the flimsiest pretenses that they are only focusing on dangerous criminals. They are, quite simply, going after any and all undocumented residents, from elementary school kids through to factory workers, casually labeling them as “criminal” and seeking to bypass the due process protections that are constitutionally guaranteed.

There is a word for this—it’s an overused word, these days, but it is entirely apropos—fascism. When men, women, and children are terrorized by armed agents, when US senators are brutalized by federal agents for peacefully asking questions of cabinet secretaries, when the US military is called out against protesters—that is, plain and simple, fascism.

Saturday is No Kings Day. May Americans, in the tens of millions, pour onto the streets against this foul assault on American democracy.

Sasha Abramsky

Sasha Abramsky is The Nation's Western correspondent. He is the author of several books, including The American Way of Poverty, The House of Twenty Thousand Books, Little Wonder: The Fabulous Story of Lottie Dod, the World's First Female Sports Superstar, and most recently Chaos Comes Calling: The Battle Against the Far-Right Takeover of Small-Town America. Follow him on Bluesky at @sashaabramsky.bsky.social.

More from The Nation

Virginia Roberts Giuffre holds up a photo of herself as a teen.

Jeffrey Epstein’s Victims Are Again Being Wronged by Donald Trump’s Circus Jeffrey Epstein’s Victims Are Again Being Wronged by Donald Trump’s Circus

Partisan politics is making a travesty of justice.

Jeet Heer

Lina Khan, chair of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), testifies before the House Appropriations Subcommittee at the Rayburn House Office Building on May 15, 2024, in Washington, DC.

HHS Doesn’t Need an RFK Jr. It Needs a Lina Khan. HHS Doesn’t Need an RFK Jr. It Needs a Lina Khan.

Forget Kennedy’s faux-populist, anti-science approach. The former FTC chair provides the real model of an ideal HHS secretary.

Abdullah Shihipar

Community and immigrant rights organizations rally in Oakland’s Latino Fruitvale district protesting immigration raids. One sign says “For my father, who was deported. Watch me from Heaven, Papa. This is Our War!”

Why Did This Farmworker Die in an Immigration Raid? Why Did This Farmworker Die in an Immigration Raid?

With Trump and Stephen Miller cheering on ICE’s terror tactics, Jaime Alanis Garcia’s fatal fall in the raid on Glass House Farms was the most recent example of a death foretold.

David Bacon

“We’re Creating Miscarriages With Medicine”: Abortion Lessons From Sweden

“We’re Creating Miscarriages With Medicine”: Abortion Lessons From Sweden “We’re Creating Miscarriages With Medicine”: Abortion Lessons From Sweden

In Sweden, abortion pills are used to terminate pregnancies through 22 weeks gestation, compared to just 10 weeks in the United States.

Cecilia Nowell

Andréa Becker on the Politics of Hysterectomy

Andréa Becker on the Politics of Hysterectomy Andréa Becker on the Politics of Hysterectomy

A conversation with the medical sociologist about her new book, Get It Out, and the perils of considering abortion, hysterectomy, and gender-affirming care as separate issues.

Q&A / Sara Franklin

Former Columbia Univrsity student Mahmoud Khalil speaks to the press as he arrives at Newark airport on June 21, 2025.

Will the Government Ever Do Right by Mahmoud Khalil? Will the Government Ever Do Right by Mahmoud Khalil?

Khalil is suing the government for false imprisonment and other harms. He should win—but will the courts let him?

Elie Mystal