Society / November 17, 2026

What Gavin Newsom’s Commutations Mean for the Future of the Death Penalty

Officials in some states continue to seek the death penalty while others, like Newsom, have vowed to bring the sentences to a halt.

Victoria Law

A corrections officer checks a cell at San Quentin State Prison in California, on August 15, 2016.

(David Paul Morris / Bloomberg)

June Oceans was returning to her dorm from a tutoring session when she learned she was no longer sentenced to execution.

“Congrats, did you hear?” the other woman asked. Oceans had no idea what she was talking about.

Her friend had been listening to the news at her prison job and heard that California Governor Gavin Newsom had commuted the sentences of every single person sentenced to death in the state.

“I was shocked,” Oceans, who had been sentenced to death in 1994, told The Nation. Watching the news later, she was filled with excitement. But it was a cautious excitement. “I needed to know some details before I could feel relief,” she added.

On November 5, two days after Election Day, Newsom commuted the sentences of the 548 people on death row to life without parole. Newsom’s action is the largest death sentence commutation in recent US history.

California has more people on death row than any other state. Its last execution was in 2006. In 2019, Newsom issued a moratorium on executions, stating that the death penalty is “unfair, unjust, wasteful, protracted and does not make our state safer.”

“I will not oversee execution of any person while Governor,” he stated in that executive order.

“Newsom’s decision is huge,” Sandra Babcock, founder of the Cornell Center on the Death Penalty Worldwide, told The Nation. “California was the behemoth of the death penalty because of the sheer number of people on death row.”

Under California law, the governor can unilaterally grant clemency to people with one felony conviction, which is 166 people on death row. The only requirement is notifying prosecutors and victims’ families.

For the other 382 people, who have a felony conviction unrelated to their death penalty case, they must wait for the California Supreme Court to rule on the governor’s mass clemency. “The court is not reviewing cases one by one,” clarified Natasha Minsker, director of the California Anti-Death Penalty Coalition, which had called on Newsom to grant this mass commutation. “The issue has been presented to the court as: Can the governor commute all death sentences because they are death sentences? Can he choose life over death in all cases at once? And that’s the question they’re going to answer.”

If the court does not approve the commutations before Newsom leaves office in January, they would expire, leaving the death sentences in place. But, notes Minsker, final briefs are due December 4, signaling that the court intends to resolve the issue before Newsom leaves office.

Before Newsom, the largest mass commutation happened in 2003 when the then–governor of Illinois, George Ryan, nullified death sentences for 167 people shortly before leaving office.

Newsom’s action doesn’t abolish the death penalty in the state. Only voters can do that via a ballot referendum, and they failed to do so in 2012 and again in 2016. Incoming Governor Xavier Becerra has vowed to continue the moratorium on executions.

Nonetheless, some prosecutors have pledged to continue seeking the death penalty. “I’m going to continue to seek it when appropriate,” Michael Hestrin, the Riverside County district attorney, told The New York Times. His county has sent more people to death row than any other in recent years, and its prosecutors are currently seeking capital punishment in 20 cases. In Kern County, 179 miles north, prosecutors are seeking the death penalty in 13 cases.

They are in the minority. Across California’s 58 counties, only 12 continue to pursue death sentences. “In California, the death penalty is dying on the vine,” said Minsker. “The vast majority of prosecutors understand this is a false promise and a waste of public safety resources.”

It seems to be dying nationwide as well. In 1991, a Gallup poll found that 76 percent of US adults were in favor of the death penalty. The next year, Bill Clinton made a point of leaving the presidential campaign trail to attend the execution of Ricky Rector, a man with mental disabilities so pronounced that he saved the dessert from his last meal “for later.” Two years later, in 1994, approval of the death penalty rose to 80 percent. Support has been waning ever since thanks to decades of organizing against the death penalty by advocates and family members of those behind bars. This past October, a Gallup poll conducted in the weeks after Christa Pike’s horrifically botched execution in Tennessee found that 49 percent of US adults were in favor, the first time approval has dipped below 50 percent since 1971.

Still, on the same day as Newsom’s announcement, Florida, Alabama and Indiana each executed a person via lethal injection. But, noted Babcock, only a small percentage of jurisdictions within death penalty states still seek executions. In Texas, for instance, only two of its 254 counties pursued a new death sentence in 2025.

“Newsom’s decision to commute death sentences is an incredibly important act of moral courage and leadership,” said Minsker. “He is showing leaders that we can have safety without sacrificing our shared humanity.”

The Nation Weekly

Fridays. A weekly digest of the best of our coverage.
By signing up, you confirm that you are over the age of 16 and agree to receive occasional promotional offers for programs that support The Nation’s journalism. You may unsubscribe or adjust your preferences at any time. You can read our Privacy Policy here.

Noting that California holds one-quarter of all death sentences in the country, she added, “For Governor Newsom to commute one-quarter of the death sentences, the largest death row in the Western Hemisphere, it’s the most significant blow to the death penalty in decades.”

She hopes that his action will push other governors to follow suit, such as Ohio’s Mike Dewine, who has publicly called for an end to the death penalty, or incoming Governor Amy Acton, who has vowed to continue Dewine’s moratorium.

Not only does Newsom’s action clear the way for them to do the same, but the sheer size of California’s death row means that mass commutations elsewhere will seem less extreme. For Ohio, that would mean 112 sentences, or for Pennsylvania that would mean 103 sentences, said Babcock, noting that any other mass commutation would be much smaller.

Oceans turns 58 next month. She was 25 years old when she was sentenced to death. During her years on death row, she was incarcerated in a men’s prison before her transition. There, she watched some of her peers, including those who mentored her, be taken away for execution.

“Shakespeare wrote, ‘When sorrows come, they come not by single spies, but in battalions,’” Oceans, now at the Central California Women’s Facility, reflected. “It’s a difficult situation to be isolated and realize that every good inspiration [including the men who befriended and mentored her] you ever had is no longer here. And then you have to wrestle with the reality that that is the exact process they [the state] intend[s] to exercise on me.”

For over a decade, Oceans was left in legal limbo after voters passed Proposition 66 in 2016. Intended to speed up legal proceedings before execution, it did the opposite: The new law required that state habeas cases (in which people who are incarcerated can challenge their sentence of execution) begin at the lower courts but did not provide a method to pay for counsel, leaving Oceans and many others without representation.

“Now everything seems bright,” she said.

Victoria Law

Victoria Law is a freelance journalist who focuses on the intersections of incarceration, gender, and resistance. Her books include Resistance Behind Bars: The Struggles of Incarcerated Women, Prison by Any Other Name: The Harmful Consequences of Popular Reforms (coauthored with Maya Schenwar), and the forthcoming “Prisons Make Us Safer” and 20 Other Myths About Mass Incarceration.

More from The Nation

A Rogue DA in No-Man’s Land

A Rogue DA in No-Man’s Land A Rogue DA in No-Man’s Land

A strange case of prosecutorial misconduct during a murder investigation in the Oklahoma panhandle.

Feature / J.C. Hallman

Representative Ayanna Pressley (D-MA) has joined 59 other Democrats in demanding that the Justice Department and FBI undertake “comprehensive federal investigation into every hanging death of a Black individual.”

Black People Have Every Reason to Doubt Official Narratives About a Recent Spate of Hangings Black People Have Every Reason to Doubt Official Narratives About a Recent Spate of Hangings

Prematurely ascribing deaths to suicide does away with questions that deserve real answers.

Column / Kali Holloway

Alexa Internet cofounders Brewster Kahle (left) and Bruce Gilliat amid the hardware their firm uses to archive the entire World Wide Web and provide a searchable database. The archive contains every web page since 1996.

My Journey Through San Francisco’s Internet Archive My Journey Through San Francisco’s Internet Archive

To most people, the archive is just a portal on their computer. But it’s also a physical space made by a person who has never cared more about the preservation of digital history....

Kim Hew-Low

Russell Brand outside Southwark Crown Court in London for his trial on charges of rape, sexual assault, and attempted indecent assault.

The End of Russell Brand's Rape Shtick The End of Russell Brand's Rape Shtick

The British celebrity kept reinventing his image to try to cloak his predations.

Laurie Penny

Mississippi Senator-elect Scott Colom (D-MS) gestures to the crowd after his victory speech at Tougaloo College on November 11, 2026 in Tougaloo, Mississippi.

Scott Colom’s Historic Victory Scott Colom’s Historic Victory

The Mississippi Democrat’s win is more than a joyous occasion—it’s redemption.

Michele Goodwin

Donald Trump speaks to reporters after arriving on Air Force One at President Donald J. Trump International Airport on November 6, 2026, in West Palm Beach, Florida.

Never Let Trump’s Elite Enablers Forget What They’ve Done Never Let Trump’s Elite Enablers Forget What They’ve Done

Universities, scientists, law firms, and many other powerful institutions are about to start pretending they never rolled over for the president. But we know better.

Gregg Gonsalves