This Is Not an Anniversary
Does remembering the date of October 7 make it easier to name?

A man carries away a Palestinian killed in an Israeli airstrike at the Erez crossing between Israel and the northern Gaza Strip, on October 7, 2023.
(Bashar Taleb / AFP via Getty Images)The world remembers Gaza again this week. Had Palestinians wanted remembrance after each date we experienced atrocity, a full, long year wouldn’t have enough days. We have been faithful victims, though, haven’t we? Since 2023, the world has applauded the resilience of our bare chests standing up to the tanks grinding us dead. Our blood must’ve shed beautifully. The women and children mourning everything and everyone they had ever known have cried in perfect tears for protests and, indeed, outraged slogans. Our homes, no longer recognizable, could have been spared if they had not borne witness to lifetimes of destruction. And if only our screams hadn’t been too loud. Three years in, forgive us for not making as many stories about our sons and daughters as the world can give standing ovations. I wish my late journalist colleagues were a bit more courageous to commit a crime and call it out. They would have been worthy of support. Probably they would’ve been deserving of protection.
My life has become a tale of a thousand anniversaries. So I dare ask: Does remembering the date of a tragedy make it easier to name? To live with? How is recalling our trauma—and dedicating an anniversary for it—going to help erase it? How is the mere reflection on something still happening and painful beyond any human’s language will bring it to an end? The notion of marking an anniversary that kicked off a rather inhumane and unimaginable memory in a long history of erasure points to the fact that the world has already moved on. It supposes that all we ever asked for was empathy. And that, frankly, is why we’re more at peace with a senseless world than we are with our tragedies. If the moral urge behind holding an anniversary is to hold space for the grief that the past few years have inflicted, by no means should this say that we’re past the grieving. If it was to end this grief, then we’re not even in any way close to doing so.
And although I’ve written constantly and with abundant detail about all the personal and collective agony I have endured over the last three years, I still haven’t been able to put into words the true feeling of realizing that with each anniversary of death we become one year closer to life. But here is what I am able to say.
A day on which entire bloodlines were erased from the civil registry should not be an anniversary.
A day our mothers were crushed beneath the concrete of their own kitchens should not be an anniversary.
A day newborns suffocated in dark, unpowered incubators should not be an anniversary.
A day flour sacks were soaked in the blood of men standing in line for bread should not be an anniversary.
A day children had their limbs amputated without anesthesia on blood-slicked hospital floors should not be an anniversary.
A day thousands of tons of explosives flattened every school, university, hospital, and library should not be an anniversary.
A day our grandparents were forced to relive their displacement under relentless bombardment should not be an anniversary.
A day white shroud shortages forced us to bury three generations in a single shallow trench should not be an anniversary.
A day parents carried what remained of their children in plastic bags should not be an anniversary.
A day entire cities were turned into a blinding wasteland of pulverized stone and bone should not be an anniversary.
A day refugee tents were set ablaze while families slept on the sand should not be an anniversary.
A day doctors, poets, teachers, civil defense crews, and journalists were targeted for bearing witness should not be an anniversary.
A day mothers dug through scorching rubble with bare hands until their fingernails ripped away should not be an anniversary.
A day drop-delivered aid crushed the starving people it was meant to feed should not be an anniversary.
Popular
“swipe left below to view more authors”Swipe →A day human beings were hunted through ruined alleyways by silent quadcopters should not be an anniversary.
A day ancient olive groves, centuries-old mosques and churches, and family photo albums were bulldozed into dirt should not be an anniversary.
A day an entire generation was orphaned, maimed, and stripped of a future should not be an anniversary.
A day hundreds of infants starved to death while their mothers did not have enough formula to feed them should not be an anniversary.
A day the sky turned into a screaming engine of death overhead should not be an anniversary.
A day our memories, our songs, and our homes were buried under mountains of gray ash should not be an anniversary.
A day the global audience watched a live-streamed genocide and called it defense should not be an anniversary.
Do not attempt to mark a date on a calendar that is not yours. If you do, keep your prayers—or celebrations—and let us keep what remains of your dignity.
More from The Nation
How the Serbian Student Movement Is a Victory for Organizing Power How the Serbian Student Movement Is a Victory for Organizing Power
In Serbia, the students may have discovered a formula for rescuing democracy through nonviolence and commitment to collectivism. Students everywhere should take note.
Dispatch From Post-Election Israel Dispatch From Post-Election Israel
The real story in this election is the extraordinary and uplifting strength of the vote of Arab citizens in Israel.
Ukraine: Time to End the War Ukraine: Time to End the War
For both Russia and Ukraine, the war has taken a staggering toll and poses an ever-greater danger of spreading.
“This Election Was a Defeat for Lies”: Read Lula’s Inspiring Victory Speech “This Election Was a Defeat for Lies”: Read Lula’s Inspiring Victory Speech
“I doubt that Russia, China, or the United States has an army as victorious as the army of democracy of this country,” the president told his supporters.
Lessons From Lula’s Historic Victory Lessons From Lula’s Historic Victory
The Brazilian left has stopped the right-wing wave in Latin America. Now it has four years to work out a succession plan.
France’s Permanent State of Emergency France’s Permanent State of Emergency
The bad habits Emmanuel Macron will pass on to his successor.
