Chuck Schumer Is Yesterday’s Man
The Senate Democratic leader just keeps showing why he needs to be replaced.

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) speaks at a press conference with other members of the Senate Democratic caucus following a policy luncheon at the US Capitol in Washington, DC on November 10, 2026.
(Nathan Posner / Anadolu via Getty Images)
If you want to ruin a boisterous celebration, just hand over a microphone to Chuck Schumer. The Senate Democratic leader is the ultimate buzzkill, adept at deploying a droning voice that can turn giddy jubilation into existential dread.
November 3 was one of the happiest nights Democrats have known in decades, as the sheer size of the party’s victory in the midterm elections became apparent. After a decade of Trump dominating public life as standard bearer of the Republican Party, here at last was proof that the public, even in red states such as Texas and South Carolina, were fed up. Beaten down as they were by frustration at the GOP pushing a hard-right agenda, Democrats could finally entertain the hopes of a better future.
But the brief remarks Schumer delivered that night were a reminder that Trump and the Republicans were only part of the problem the country faces. There’s also the disheartening fact that the Democrats are led by political dinosaurs who have no understanding of the urgency of the current moment.
Schumer is now facing a challenge for the post of Senate Majority Leader from Maryland’sChris Van Hollen. Schumer’s election night speech offers clear evidence as to why Van Hollen deserves to win.
Schumer started with a question: “How did he win?” His answer: “First and foremost, we focused on American families and their pain and their needs, their suffering. They are not having a good life, and they are worried about the future for themselves and their children.” Schumer summed up the election as being about three issues: costs, chaos, and corruption.
What’s notable among this vague litany of complaints are all the issues left out that produced heated debate and no shortage of voter anger: the Iran War and its role in destabilizing the world economy, US support of Israel as a factor in the war, the rise of AI and data centers, and the outsized roles of tech plutocrats like Elon Musk in corrupting the political system.
Schumer expressed surprise that the Republicans “embraced Trump” and “followed Trump over the cliff as some of the time he talked about extraneous things that were ridiculous but much of the time he implemented things that raised their costs.” For most people, talking about “extraneous things” would not make the list of Trump’s thousand worst offenses, so it was puzzling why Schumer felt it necessary to highlight in a short victory speech.
Schumer ended his peroration with a puzzling metaphor: “The American people reduced the red brick wall to a pile of bricks.” As commentators such as Jon Stewart and Sam Seder pointed out, these words were more likely to generate confusion than inspiration. What exactly is the “red brick wall”? Further, walls are usually reduced to rubble, not a pile of bricks. If the bricks still exist, then the red wall can be rebuilt.
Seder rightly noted the absurdity of Schumer’s amazement at congressional Republicans’ loyalty to Trump, given that anyone who has been sentient for the last decade should have noticed that Trump easily won the GOP presidential nomination three times in a row and turned the party into his personal cult. There are few facts more obvious in American public life than that the Republican Party is completely subservient to Trump. But it’s a fact that Schumer still has a hard time accepting or acknowledging.
Partly, this is because Schumer is deeply committed to ancien régime restoration. He still seems to see Trump as a regrettable anomaly who will one day disappear and allow those most mythical creatures, the “reasonable Republicans,” to return. In this worldview, Democrats such as Schumer have to keep signaling they are ready to work with Republicans in order to hasten the return of normal politics. This is why Schumer can only talk about politics in the most abstract of terms (costs, chaos and corruption) rather than specifying real areas of disagreement.
Schumer has been quite candid about this strategy. In March 2025, he caved in to Republicans during budget negotiations, making concessions that angered his fellow Democrats. Explaining his thinking in an interview with The New York Times, Schumer said his goal was to wait till Trump’s approval ratings have dropped below 40 per cent:
And when he went below 40 percent in the polls, the Republican legislators started working with us. He was at 51. He’s now at 48. We’re gonna keep at it until he goes below 40. Look, I talk to a lot of these Republican legislators. I’ve worked with them. Some of them are Trump devotees. But many of them don’t like him, don’t respect him and worry about what he’s doing to our country. Right now he’s so popular they can’t resist him. I mean, so many of them came to me and said: “I don’t think Hegseth should be defense secretary or R.F.K. should be H.H.S. But Trump wants him. He won.” The Republicans would like to have some freedom from Trump, but they won’t until we bring him down in popularity. That happened with Bush in 2005. It happened with Trump in 2017. When it happens, I am hopeful that our Republican colleagues will resume working with us. And I talk to them. One of the places is in the gym. When you’re on that bike in your shorts, panting away next to a Republican, a lot of the inhibitions come off.
This theory of latent Republican moderation rests on nothing more than locker room conviviality—hardly the basis for a meaningful political agenda. We will now have an empirical test to see if Schumer’s theory is correct. Trump’s approval ratings went below 40 per cent in April and have generally stayed well under that threshold. The Republicans suffered a wipeout in the midterms. Yet there is no evidence that the GOP is moderating. In the wake of the midterm trouncing, House Republicans picked Jim Jordan, a hard-right Trump loyalist, as their new leader. The House held a vote to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. Thomas Massie of Kentucky, who brought the motion to the floor, was the only Republican to vote for it. That near-total GOP opposition, and the fact 11 Democrats failed to show up for the vote, was enough to kill the effort. Massie himself had been defeated earlier this year in the Republican primary and is leaving Congress.
Popular
“swipe left below to view more authors”Swipe →Like many centrists, Schumer fashions himself as a realist. In truth, he’s a fantasist whose theory of politics rests on a world that no longer exists, if it ever did.
Beyond his fetishization of bipartisanship, Schumer’s substantive political commitments are also out of tune with the current urgent moment in politics. In an interview with The Nation, Senator Bernie Sanders listed three areas where Schumer is out of touch: Israel/Palestine, taxing the wealthy, and AI. Sanders described Schumer as someone who “a guy who wants to tinker around the edges” rather than fight for systematic change. In other words, Schumer is yesterday’s man, which is reason enough to support Chris Van Hollen as a replacement.
More from The Nation
Democrats Should Not Give an Inch to the Lame-Duck Congress Democrats Should Not Give an Inch to the Lame-Duck Congress
In this week’s Elie v. U.S., our justice correspondent makes the case for Democrats to block Trump’s attempt at judiciary-stuffing. Plus, boycott Harry Potter!
Why Progressives Are Backing Chris Van Hollen Why Progressives Are Backing Chris Van Hollen
The senator netted key endorsements from progressives, activists, and unions in his quest to oust Chuck Schumer. But he still faces an uphill battle.
The Midterms Were a Revolt Against ICE. Democrats Need to Remember That. The Midterms Were a Revolt Against ICE. Democrats Need to Remember That.
Voters made their disgust with Trump’s war on immigrants clear. Now, with the fanatical Stephen Miller given even more power, Democrats must take on the administration.
Trump and Vance Are Using War to Enrich Their Cronies Trump and Vance Are Using War to Enrich Their Cronies
A new report shows how the pair is robbing Venezuela blind on behalf of one of their donors.
A Kingdom of Animals Enslaved A Kingdom of Animals Enslaved
An industry built on torture.
