Culture / Books & the Arts / February 19, 2024

The Unanswered Questions of True Detective

The Unanswered Questions of “True Detective”

Like a Raymond Chandler detective story, Night Country ultimately wants to turn its audience’s attention away from the mysteries of the dead toward those of the living.

Jorge Cotte
A scene from True Detective: Night Country.
A scene from True Detective: Night Country. (Photograph by Michele K. Short / HBO)

When the first season of True Detective appeared in 2014, we were living in a different era of television—before auteur series and anthologies were commonplace, when seeing movie stars on the small screen still meant something, when a writer’s or a director’s vision could be so novel as to draw millions to their proverbial water coolers. It wasn’t just a buttoned-up Woody Harrelson and a gaunt and philosophical Matthew McConaughey that lured us in, but the layered timelines, the potentially cosmic intrigue, Nic Pizzolatto’s indulgent verbosity, and Cary Joji Fukunaga’s absorbing camera.

Now, a decade later, with the appearance of True Detective’s fourth season—its first without Pizzolatto at the helm and its first with a subtitle, Night Country—movie stars and auteurist directors are no longer novel. Since True Detective’s debut in 2014, we’ve had Clive Owen and Steven Soderbergh (The Knick), Jude Law and Paolo Sorrentino (The Young Pope), Alicia Vikander and Olivier Assayas (Irma Vep). Spike Lee, Baz Luhrmann, Lana and Lilly Wachowski, Barry Jenkins, Park Chan-wook, and Steve McQueen have all directed television series; Nicole Kidman and Reese Witherspoon have starred in several. High-production values have become a cliché. The fourth season’s first puzzle, then, is how to make itself anew: Can Night Country’s creator, director, and primary writer, Issa López, give us something bracing and different that still feels like True Detective?

From the start, there are clear commonalities between Night Country and the original season of True Detective. Both have high-wattage Hollywood actors and a story anchored by its atmosphere and sense of place. Both are invested in unresolved cosmic conspiracies and the fine line between losing your mind and “mainlining the secret truth of the universe.” Night Country crystallizes this connection in a recurring symbol from the first season, a crooked spiral, expanding on associations from one temporal and geographical space to the other. If time is a flat circle, then so are television shows.

Current Issue

Cover of April 2024 Issue

But in other ways, Night Country serves as a negative image of the first season: It begins with missing men rather than a woman dead and displayed. Its protagonists are female detectives instead of male ones. It trades the sprawling swamps and twisted trees of Louisiana for the blank, withholding darkness of the Arctic. Instead of the sticky, suppurating landscape of the first season, we get a petrified tundra on the other end of the continent.

Night Country also has its own unique mysteries. There is the horrifying “corpsicle,” an unexplained disappearance, and an earlier unsolved murder. But López is interested in uncertainty of a different kind: She uses the landscape and darkness to develop an eerie, frigid atmosphere. Beyond the arrant philosophizing of the first season—most memorably McConaughey’s self-serious and unintentionally humorous nihilism—the rabbit holes in Night Country are more profound. Murder is the gravitational force that draws the story forward, but it sucks both the living and the dead into an endless turmoil. Cases go unsolved for years and often seem adjacent to deeper questions about the cosmos that haunt those attempting to close them. The show’s real questions, it turns out, are ones without answers: mysteries about belief, metaphysics, and identity that no detective can truly resolve.

Set in a fictional mining town in Alaska so far north that the sun does not rise for weeks in the winter, True Detective: Night Country introduces us to this deadly, darkened landscape before we meet any of its heroes or villains. Watching as the last sunset fades over the horizon of Ennis, we are trapped in the town’s sunless season, in which the distinction between day and night loses all meaning. Ennis’s remoteness makes it difficult to track where and when things occur. Lab results could take days to arrive, and the mining that sustains the local economy has also undermined the town’s water quality. It is so cold that venturing outdoors is a life-risking proposition.

Although this might sound like an inhospitable place, people do live here: woo-woo white people, environmentalist organizers and agitators, rough men hardened by work in the mines, and the Iñupiat trying to maintain a connection to their land and heritage. Cooped up in this small town, people also create their own life-risking situations: Miners and environmental organizers frequent the same bar, after all. Everyone knows everyone. Moments after a drunk driver rams into a pole in the first episode, a neighbor calls out, “Is that fucking Stacy Chalmers again?”

The Nation Weekly

Fridays. A weekly digest of the best of our coverage.
By signing up, you confirm that you are over the age of 16 and agree to receive occasional promotional offers for programs that support The Nation’s journalism. You may unsubscribe or adjust your preferences at any time. You can read our Privacy Policy here.

Even greater dangers lurk outside the town—especially at the Tsalal Arctic Research Station, an outpost even more remote than Ennis. There, a diverse group of scientists have spent years penetrating the permafrost in search of the origins of life, in the hopes of finding a primordial panacea that could hold the key to curing cancer, autoimmune diseases, and genetic disorders. But then, after the last sunset of the year, the scientists disappear suddenly and without a trace. The only thing left behind is a human tongue.

Enter Ennis’s police chief, Liz Danvers, played with a world-weary gravitas by Jodie Foster. This is Foster not as Clarice Starling, the FBI Academy student in The Silence of the Lambs, but as Jack Crawford, Clarice’s wise but flawed mentor, who doesn’t shy away from exploiting his underlings in pursuit of the truth. Danvers is clearly good at her job, and her skills of deduction are on full display from the outset, when she schools her second-in-command, Hank (John Hawkes), as they navigate the crime scene. Like many of TV’s brilliant but difficult sleuths, Danvers is a curmudgeon, a philanderer, and always on the clock. She’s good police but bad company.

Considering the staff she has to rely on, it’s hard to blame her: The rest of the Ennis police force bumble around damaging the crime scene and taking selfies instead of making themselves useful. That is, except for Pete (Finn Bennett), who is Hank’s son but, more importantly, Danvers’s protégé. He serves as her sounding board, her assistant, her student, and through him we see how all of these could be a mixed blessing. Danvers demands too much—of herself and others. The case, for her, is all-consuming, and as they get deeper and deeper into it, Pete follows her lead. He forsakes his wife’s affections, stops tucking their son into bed, and skips Christmas Eve.

The show’s counterweight to Danvers is not Hank but a former acolyte who is no longer in awe of the police chief: Evangeline Navarro, played by the skillful Kali Reis. She used to work with Danvers, but following complications with a messy case she has moved on to the state troopers. Now, despite her removed role, she gets roped into working with Danvers again, though neither relishes the opportunity.

Once the two are drawn together, the show really takes off. The series now has moved solidly into True Detective territory: Like Rust and Marty in season one, Navarro and Danvers are an odd couple, one a believer and the other a skeptic, one committed to justice and the other a cynic. They annoy and know too much about each other, but there’s a grudging respect too. Navarro is no longer swayed by Danvers’s brilliance and charisma, but she is not unlike her in many ways: Standoffish, she embraces her cases wholeheartedly; she’s quick to use men for sex; and her family is a headache rather than a comfort.

Yet what the two really share is something else. As the story of detection unfolds in Night Country, we realize that Danvers and Navarro are searching for something more than just a killer; they are both searching for answers to their own unresolved pasts. Danvers is trying to forget a loss that has closed her off from others, while Navarro is trying to understand and embrace her own Iñupiaq heritage on her mother’s side. When Navarro meets an Iñupiaq person, she’s often asked, “What’s your name?”—as in, “What’s your Iñupiat name, your real name?” And Navarro has no answer. Though the pair might get far asking the wrong questions, they will eventually have to listen for the answers that are calling to them.

After the remains of the Tsalal scientists are discovered, Night Country shifts from a missing-persons story to a murder mystery. One day, a woman living on the town’s outskirts finds the bodies frozen together, gaping in horror, like an ice sculpture modeled from Francisco Goya’s Black Paintings. Their clothes are neatly folded nearby. Navarro spots a crooked spiral on the forehead of one of the victims: It’s the same crooked spiral that Rust sees everywhere as he and Marty try to solve the Dora Lange murder in season one. Something primordial is at work. “It’s old, missy,” the woman who found the scientists’ bodies tells Navarro. “Older than Ennis. It’s older than the ice, probably.”

Soon, both Navarro and Danvers begin to see the connections all around them. They find evidence that a cold case involving a murdered Iñupiat activist is tangled up with the Tsalal deaths: The victim, Annie Kowtok, had a spiral tattoo on her back that not only matches the spiral on the dead scientist’s forehead, but also a tattoo that one of the other Tsalal researchers, Raymond Clark (the only one still missing, and who was apparently involved in a secret relationship with Annie), got in the days immediately after her death. The spiral is a warning, but as the story lines of Night Country continue to unfurl, we realize that it embodies the show’s structure, too: We are caught in a spiral that moves outward from one perspective and, from another, curls ever inward toward a single point.

The spiral is symbolic of something else as well: the unexplainable forces that lurk in the mining town and Alaska’s bitter and dark tundra. Navarro can’t deny the spiritual connections it awakens in her. She comes face to face with a one-eyed polar bear; she hears voices; the frozen ocean calls out to her. Danvers, though, is forceful and close-minded: “You talk to God?” she asks incredulously. “No,” Navarro replies. “I listen.” But others in town share Navarro’s mysticism. “This is Ennis, man,” a driver tells Pete, the young deputy. “You see people who are gone sometimes. It’s a long fuckin’ night. Even the dead get bored.”

Raymond Chandler is one of the key figures in American detective fiction and inevitably an influence on True Detective. He’s there in the show’s pulpy roots and its hard-boiled antiheroes. But there is another element of Chandler that runs throughout the show. As Fredric Jameson once observed of Chandler’s work, at its core is the effort to demystify the story of a murder. Instead of a more classical detective story in which the central murder is “a kind of abstract point which is made to bear meaning and significance by the convergence of all lines upon it,” the hallmark of the Chandlerian narrative is that the murder is ultimately revealed to be a decoy or a diversion from the story’s true aim: bringing us face to face with death, with an “opening onto the not-World, onto its edge and its end, in the void, in non-human space, in death.”

Night Country, at its most potent, begins where Chandler ends. Ennis is a place close to death, already a neighbor to it; it is precarious, otherworldly, stygian. This isn’t just a metaphor for Night Country: How else to describe an Arctic zone of unending night at the edge and end of the world but as a “void” and an almost “non-human space”? The show revels in it and even romanticizes it. When one struggling character loses her life to suicide, the show frames her elegantly walking out onto the ice, seemingly without pain, just crossing over to the unseen territory of death. At other times, the force of this otherworldly landscape and terrain raises more questions than the show can ever answer. Danvers and Navarro visit locations and revisit them. They talk to informants who prove to be more exemplary than insightful. The turns they take in their investigation can feel perfunctory to the show’s central mystery. By the end, we know that Danvers and Navarro will need to go deeper into the ice, into a world even darker and lonelier than Ennis. But when you start at the edge of death, the journey to revelation is both too long and too short. The detectives might solve the case, yet the show’s true questions are about what haunts them and the town. Is it a higher force, a source of evil, or just the facts of life in the Arctic? They ignore that darkness; they fight it and pursue it. But in the end, maybe it’s just about making peace with the mystery.

Thank you for reading The Nation!

We hope you enjoyed the story you just read. It’s just one of many examples of incisive, deeply-reported journalism we publish—journalism that shifts the needle on important issues, uncovers malfeasance and corruption, and uplifts voices and perspectives that often go unheard in mainstream media. For nearly 160 years, The Nation has spoken truth to power and shone a light on issues that would otherwise be swept under the rug.

In a critical election year as well as a time of media austerity, independent journalism needs your continued support. The best way to do this is with a recurring donation. This month, we are asking readers like you who value truth and democracy to step up and support The Nation with a monthly contribution. We call these monthly donors Sustainers, a small but mighty group of supporters who ensure our team of writers, editors, and fact-checkers have the resources they need to report on breaking news, investigative feature stories that often take weeks or months to report, and much more.

There’s a lot to talk about in the coming months, from the presidential election and Supreme Court battles to the fight for bodily autonomy. We’ll cover all these issues and more, but this is only made possible with support from sustaining donors. Donate today—any amount you can spare each month is appreciated, even just the price of a cup of coffee.

The Nation does not bow to the interests of a corporate owner or advertisers—we answer only to readers like you who make our work possible. Set up a recurring donation today and ensure we can continue to hold the powerful accountable.

Thank you for your generosity.

Jorge Cotte

is a writer living in Chicago. His essays and reviews have appeared in The Los Angeles Review of Books and The New Inquiry.

More from The Nation

Transatlantic Tragedy: “Grenfell” Moves from Britain’s National Theatre to a Brooklyn Stage

Transatlantic Tragedy: “Grenfell” Moves from Britain’s National Theatre to a Brooklyn Stage Transatlantic Tragedy: “Grenfell” Moves from Britain’s National Theatre to a Brooklyn Stage

An interview with Gillian Slovo, whose new play about the survivors of the Grenfell Tower fire in London just opened in New York.

Feature / D.D. Guttenplan

Katy O’Brian and Kristen Stewart.

Blood, Guts, and Queer Bodybuilders Blood, Guts, and Queer Bodybuilders

The Kristen Stewart–helmed erotic thriller Love Lies Bleeding filters a study of sex, violence, and the limits of human will through a romance that begins in a New Mexico gym.

Books & the Arts / Beatrice Loayza

Heinrich Himmler inspecting the Galicia Division in May 1944. Otto Wächter is in the background.

Why Is the American Library Association Whitewashing the History of Ukrainian Nazis? Why Is the American Library Association Whitewashing the History of Ukrainian Nazis?

In honoring a book depicting Ukrainian volunteers in the Waffen SS as heroes and patriots, the group reveals historical ignorance—or indifference to antisemitism.

Lev Golinkin

Lauren Oyler and the Critic in the Internet Age

Lauren Oyler and the Critic in the Internet Age Lauren Oyler and the Critic in the Internet Age

In No Judgment, the novelist and critic explores the perilous activity of literary criticism in the era of social media.

Books & the Arts / Alana Pockros

Kid Cudi in Las Vegas, 2024.

The Many Evolutions of Kid Cudi The Many Evolutions of Kid Cudi

In Insano, the rapper and hip-hop artist comes back down to earth.

Books & the Arts / Bijan Stephen