The Score / June 14, 2024

Raising the Minimum Wage Comes Cheap

Studies overwhelmingly show that the effect of increasing the minimum wage on employment rates is basically zero.

Bryce Covert
(Infographic: Tracy Matsue Loeffelholz)

California fast food workers now have one of the highest minimum wages in the country. In 2022, the state Legislature passed the FAST Recovery Act, which established a fast food council made up of workers and corporate representatives that would set standards for wages, hours, and working conditions. A year later, after a well-funded attack on the law at the ballot box, Governor Gavin Newsom signed legislation enacting a $20 minimum wage for fast food workers, which took effect in April, and set the council up to develop further recommendations for raising pay.

The new wage is a hefty increase; the state’s minimum wage for all workers is $16 an hour, and in 2022, the average wage for California’s fast food workers was $16.21. Nationally, median pay for fast food workers is just $14.20 an hour. But consider that a $20 wage still amounts to just a bit over $40,000 a year—and that’s if someone works full-time for 52 weeks a year. In California, nearly 40 percent of fast food employees work less than 35 hours a week, even though half the workforce wants more hours. Researchers at MIT estimate that a living wage in California is $27.32 an hour for a childless single person; someone in a family with another working adult and two children needs to earn at least $33.26 an hour.

In anticipation of the higher-wage mandate, fast food chains have claimed that they’ll be forced to fire workers, and some people have already lost their jobs. But studies overwhelmingly indicate that, in the end, California’s fast food workers will be better off.

Companies tend to handle a higher minimum wage not by laying people off but by raising prices. A number of chains, from McDonald’s to Chipotle, have already warned that they may start to charge more, although it’s unclear whether the $20 wage is to blame, since they were already hiking prices in California at a faster clip than anywhere else in the country. Still, McDonald’s has responded to past minimum-wage increases not by bringing in robots to replace workers but by raising the price of a Big Mac. It’s not likely to be an astronomical change: One review of studies found that increasing wages by 10 percent raised prices by, at most, 0.4 percent.

Some restaurants may be forced to close. But according to a March 2024 study, the ones that disappear are more or less the ones that can’t hack it—the least productive small companies. That lines up with another study finding that the lower-rated restaurants are the ones that exit. The successful ones, meanwhile, end up more profitable.

Employment can be affected, but it’s not typically through mass layoffs. The same March study found that companies react to a higher minimum wage by slowing down hiring and holding on to their existing workers. Even in “highly exposed industries,” such as the restaurant sector, companies “do not substantially reduce employment,” the authors found. Both young people and low-wage workers are likely to stay employed and make more money.

That finding lines up with many, many others. A study that looked at 138 minimum-wage increases between 1979 and 2016 found that the impact on jobs was “mostly close to zero and not statistically significant,” but that pay increased not just for those making the new minimum wage but for those earning slightly more, too. A different study of 172 minimum-­wage increases from 1979 to 2019 similarly found “little evidence” of jobs lost despite “a very clear” increase in overall pay. The same for a study that compared counties that raised their minimum wage to neighboring counties that didn’t over a period of 16 years. One study from 1994 that looked specifically at the impact of higher minimum wages on the fast food industry found no evidence of reduced employment and actually found that the number of jobs increased, as did a different study in 2023.

A 2009 survey of 64 studies found the same thing: Across all of the findings, the average impact on employment was close to zero.

California’s $20 fast food wage floor is new, but what ends up happening there could hold national significance. Legislators in New York and Massachusetts have considered raising their states’ minimum wages for all workers at least that high. Lawmakers who want to meet the growing call for a $20 wage can rest assured that, more likely than not, the workers meant to be helped by it will hold on to their jobs and reap higher pay.

Bryce Covert

Bryce Covert is a contributing writer at The Nation and was a 2023 Reporter in Residence at Omidyar Network.

More from The Nation

Jeff Bezos attends Global Champions Arabians Tour Miami Beach Presented by Qatar Airways on April 17, 2025 in Miami Beach, Florida.

Why Jeff Bezos Loves Trump’s Big, Ugly Bill Why Jeff Bezos Loves Trump’s Big, Ugly Bill

The legislation contains massive giveaways to the oligarch class.

Sarah Anderson and Lauren Jacobs

A tornado leveled the Harlem Tap Room, which has been in operation since 1946, on Dr. Martin Luther King Drive in St. Louis.

In St. Louis, a Tornado Rips Across an Economic Disaster Area In St. Louis, a Tornado Rips Across an Economic Disaster Area

St. Louis can either use the disaster as an opportunity to commit to the safety of all its residents, or it can continue a barbaric cycle of neglect.

Devin Thomas O’Shea

Elon Musk walks to the White House after landing in Marine One on the South Lawn on March 9, 2025, in Washington, DC.

The Road to DOGE Was Paved With Pyramid Schemes The Road to DOGE Was Paved With Pyramid Schemes

The second Trump administration has been compared to the Mafia, feudal empires, and the petro-states of the Persian Gulf—but an even more relevant analogy may be Nutrilite.

Bridget Read

Never Mind the Stock Market, the Economy Is Blinking a Big Warning

Never Mind the Stock Market, the Economy Is Blinking a Big Warning Never Mind the Stock Market, the Economy Is Blinking a Big Warning

Tariff-induced higher prices and supply chain problems are just the start of the pain Trumponomics will inflict.

Dean Baker for The Nation

More than 55,000 striking members of SEIU Local 721 march on Tuesday, April 29, 2025, in Los Angeles.

Is It Time for Unions to Rethink Everything? Is It Time for Unions to Rethink Everything?

As union membership declines and regulators turn against workers, maybe we need to start talking about some radical change to the way the labor movement works.

Jacqui Germain

President Donald Trump speaks to members of the media on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, DC, on Sunday, May 4, 2025.

Rationing Dolls and Pencils: Trump’s Ramblings Preview the Economy He’s Wrecking Rationing Dolls and Pencils: Trump’s Ramblings Preview the Economy He’s Wrecking

The president spewed absolute nonsense on Sunday. It should spark speculation about his mental capacity.

Joan Walsh