Why Did Indiana University Axe Its Award-Winning Print Newspaper?
If the administration can censor the Indiana Daily Student—one of the most acclaimed student publications in the nation—then student journalism everywhere is at risk.
Pedestrians on the campus of Indiana University–Bloomington in Bloomington, Indiana.
(Chet Strange / Getty)
On street corners across Bloomington, Indiana, newspaper boxes sit empty. Nearly two weeks ago, on October 14, Indiana University cut the award-winning print version of the Indiana Daily Student—just hours after firing the paper’s adviser—ending 158 years of print journalism two days before the next edition was set to publish.
These decisions came after weeks of discussions with IDS adviser and student media director Jim Rodenbush, during which Media School administrators told him that they expected the IDS’s printed newspapers to refrain from reporting any news.
The IDS editors in chief called it censorship. The Student Press Law Center and the Foundation for Institutional Rights and Expression have agreed. Mike Hiestand, senior legal counsel at the Student Press Law Center, told ABC News it was a “bizarre” decision from the university: “This is coming out of a place that absolutely should know better,” Hiestand said.
I work on the news desk at the IDS as the climate beat reporter (as a student fellow for The Nation, I’m writing this as an independent reporter and not on the IDS’s behalf). This isn’t the first time IU has cut the paper’s print edition. In 2024, the Media School put together a plan they said would solve the paper’s ongoing financial problems, which have put the paper at a deficit since 2021. The Media School’s plan, released in October 2024 without final input from journalism faculty or student editors, eliminated the weekly print edition of the IDS. Instead the paper would print just its special editions, which typically run regular content alongside a sleeve of articles following a theme on campus life and events, such as the university visitor’s guide or the housing and living guide.
Students continued printing those special editions in the spring. But in the fall semester, Rodenbush said that he learned the university provost was frustrated about seeing newspapers in the stands. Those concerns accelerated after that semester’s second edition, which featured a front-page story covering local Labor Day protests against Trump and IU.
Rodenbush said administrators told him they wanted the IDS to publish special editions containing no news, only content following the special themes on university life: the upcoming homecoming guide, for example, was to contain only information about the university’s homecoming. An assistant dean at the Media School asked in a September 25 meeting: “How do we frame that, you know, in a way that’s not seen as censorship?”
In meetings spaced over several weeks, Jim Rodenbush said he repeatedly told Media School administrators that under the First Amendment and the IDS’s charter, which established editorial freedom, he couldn’t tell students what to publish in the paper. “If I had done that, I would have failed my journalism education, the mentors that I’ve had along the way, and like, at this point, the literally thousands of students that I’ve had over my years,” Rodenbush said.
On October 14, after both Rodenbush and IDS co–editors in chief Andrew Miller and Mia Hilkowitz argued that restricting the content in the print edition to a theme on campus life would amount to censorship, the Media School fired Rodenbush effective immediately. They completely eliminated the IDS’s print edition, including the special editions, a few hours later. IU did not respond to a request for comment.
Chancellor David Reingold told NBC that IU was committed to the paper’s editorial independence. He said cutting the IDS’s print edition was a business decision: The IDS has run on a financial deficit since 2021, and IU has forgiven nearly a million in debt. In 2024, the Media School planned to keep the special editions for their “high revenue.” But Reingold said that cutting print entirely would further address the paper’s financial deficit.
The three print editions this year have run almost $11,000 in profit, according to the IDS’s editors. An online copy of the unprinted October 16 paper—shared to Instagram with the caption “The paper you weren’t supposed to see”—lists the lost ad revenue on large black squares where the advertisements would have been.
Rodenbush said the paper was already following the financial plans laid out by the Media School in 2024. “We were following that business decision,” Rodenbush said. “We were continuing to publish special sections, and they were continuing to be revenue generators, so the business part of that had already been taken care of.”
In an interview for Indiana Public Media’s Noon Edition, IDS co–editor in chief Mia Hilkowitz said that the Media School’s actions weren’t really about print: “They can argue all they want this is a business decision, but this is really about content,” Hilkowitz said.
According to reporting by IndyStar, IU administrators had previously obstructed Rodenbush from using over $400,000 from the paper’s donation fund, more than the newspaper’s current deficit. A lot of that money came from Mark Cuban, IU’s richest alum, who responded to the print edition’s being cut on Wednesday. “Not happy,” Cuban posted to X: “Censorship isn’t the way.”
IU was recently ranked the nation’s third-worst college for free speech by the Foundation for Institutional Rights and Expression, and in May, a judge issued a preliminary injunction blocking a campus policy restricting “expressive activity” between 11 pm and 6 am, on the grounds that it may have violated the First Amendment.
Rodenbush said he doesn’t know why the Media School made the call to cut news from the IDS’s print edition, but he wonders if IU felt pressured to keep negative news off campus in order to avoid attention at the state level.
In November 2024, after the IDS published a front page featuring an illustration of then-President-elect Donald Trump surrounded by critical quotes from former political allies, Indiana Lieutenant Governor Micah Beckwith criticized the cover on X. “This type of elitist leftist propaganda needs to stop or we will be happy to stop it for them,” Beckwith wrote.
State and local media outlets have noticed that IU leadership appears to avoid engaging with the press. As the state legislature recently passed laws reducing faculty’s role in major decisions, closing university degree programs, and enabling the state governor to fire and replace university trustees, WFYI Indianapolis reported that the IU administration kept quiet.
Popular
“swipe left below to view more authors”Swipe →Meanwhile, WFYI reporters found that the Board of Trustees has repeatedly made important votes suddenly and with little transparency, including the choice to reelect controversial IU President Pamela Whitten. Amid allegations that Whitten plagiarized her dissertation, IU announced that it had commissioned an independent review that found the allegations to be without merit. But in September, the IDS reported that IU had refused to release further information or details from that review, including identifying the law firm that completed the report.
Former trustee Vivian Winston, who was removed from the board by Governor Mike Braun in May, has been vocal with her concerns about administrative transparency and accountability. Winston publicly criticized Whitten in the months leading up to her removal, and the IDS reported that she told attendees at a Bloomington Press Club meeting she’d seen changes at IU install a “culture of fear.”
IU’s decision to eliminate the IDS’s print edition falls in with a larger trend. Student journalists have increasingly seen federal policies or attitudes towards the free press mirrored at the local level, where they have acute consequences for college papers and reporters. Earlier this year, IU’s in-state rival Purdue University cut ties with its student paper, citing “institutional neutrality.” Similar changes have been happening across the country: More than half of student news outlets receive funding from their universities, but a rising number of universities have been slashing that support.
Rodenbush said that if censorship can happen at the IDS, one of the most acclaimed student newspapers in the nation, that spells bad news for student journalism everywhere. “This should be a warning that all bets are off in terms of overreach and oversight of a university,” Rodenbush said. “I think it’s one where everyone should be paying attention.”
Support independent journalism that does not fall in line
Even before February 28, the reasons for Donald Trump’s imploding approval rating were abundantly clear: untrammeled corruption and personal enrichment to the tune of billions of dollars during an affordability crisis, a foreign policy guided only by his own derelict sense of morality, and the deployment of a murderous campaign of occupation, detention, and deportation on American streets.
Now an undeclared, unauthorized, unpopular, and unconstitutional war of aggression against Iran has spread like wildfire through the region and into Europe. A new “forever war”—with an ever-increasing likelihood of American troops on the ground—may very well be upon us.
As we’ve seen over and over, this administration uses lies, misdirection, and attempts to flood the zone to justify its abuses of power at home and abroad. Just as Trump, Marco Rubio, and Pete Hegseth offer erratic and contradictory rationales for the attacks on Iran, the administration is also spreading the lie that the upcoming midterm elections are under threat from noncitizens on voter rolls. When these lies go unchecked, they become the basis for further authoritarian encroachment and war.
In these dark times, independent journalism is uniquely able to uncover the falsehoods that threaten our republic—and civilians around the world—and shine a bright light on the truth.
The Nation’s experienced team of writers, editors, and fact-checkers understands the scale of what we’re up against and the urgency with which we have to act. That’s why we’re publishing critical reporting and analysis of the war on Iran, ICE violence at home, new forms of voter suppression emerging in the courts, and much more.
But this journalism is possible only with your support.
This March, The Nation needs to raise $50,000 to ensure that we have the resources for reporting and analysis that sets the record straight and empowers people of conscience to organize. Will you donate today?
More from The Nation
The Overlooked Crisis Facing Immigrants With Disabilites The Overlooked Crisis Facing Immigrants With Disabilites
Gregory Javier Laguna, who has Down syndrome, and his brother have been detained for almost five months. Under Trump, "it feels like we have no recourse," said one advocate.
Assisted Outpatient Treatment Doesn’t Work. Mamdani Could Stop It. Assisted Outpatient Treatment Doesn’t Work. Mamdani Could Stop It.
Claims that coercive mental health care is a necessary evil are not supported by evidence.
Do the Owners of MLB Teams Even Like Baseball? Do the Owners of MLB Teams Even Like Baseball?
The failsons and finance brokers who own MLB franchises seem ready to destroy the league to make themselves a little richer—and too many fans may take their side.
The Radical Texas War Against the “Devil’s Rope” The Radical Texas War Against the “Devil’s Rope”
An excerpt from the new book The Myth of Red Texas.
2 FIFA Rulings on Israel, 1 Familiar Deference to MAGA 2 FIFA Rulings on Israel, 1 Familiar Deference to MAGA
The world’s soccer governing body reminded fans what its theoretical commitment to “neutrality” means in practice: siding with the genocidaire.
Marc Andreessen’s Dangerously Unexamined Life Marc Andreessen’s Dangerously Unexamined Life
The tech mogul has declared himself an enemy of introspection, and that conveniently erases considerations of conscience from his amoral investment empire.
