Society / January 22, 2025

Why Won’t the Federal Government Reimburse People Whose Food Stamps Are Stolen?

The disastrous consequences for working-class families.

Devon Gray
A sign on the door of a Walgreens refrigerator in Queens, New York. (Lindsey Nicholson / UCG/Universal Images Group via Getty Images)

When Victoria, a mother of two who works as a medical assistant in Yolo County, California, found that food stamp benefits were stolen from her EBT card for the third time, she was at her wits’ end.

Since she couldn’t take paid leave to visit social services, she spent hours with them over the phone. After being transferred to multiple people, she was told she would receive the reimbursement in 10–15 business days. After three weeks, she called to check on the status and was informed she would not be reimbursed after all. It left her unable to pay her electricity bill or car payment, and she soon struggled to put food on the table for her two children.

Victoria’s experiences with EBT theft are not unique. In California, EBT thieves took an average of $15 million a month in 2024. Cuyahoga County, Ohio, saw a 62-fold increase in requests for food-stamp reimbursements from December 2023 to December 2024.

In the last two years, recipients of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP)—or food stamps—have had over $150 million in federal funds reimbursed after having their benefits stolen from their EBT cards.

However, as part of Congress’s short-term spending bill signed into law in December to avert a government shutdown, federal funds to reimburse SNAP theft victims are no longer available. This change will have disastrous consequences for working-class families and, over the long term, deeply damage the trust in government needed to support vital safety net programs.

“You think you’re going to get those resources by going to ask for the help,” Victoria said. “And then [you’re] not able to. It makes you very discouraged to even want to try to get the help that is needed.”

Current Issue

Cover of April 2025 Issue

SNAP theft is common because of outdated technology. Benefits are deposited on debit cards that are swiped at cash registers. But unlike most modern debit and credit cards, EBT cards do not have microchips that would be effective against “card skimming.” Thankfully, California will be the first state to include these microchips in early 2025, and Oklahoma is expected to follow suit in the summer. California is also one of the only states that will use its own funds to replace stolen SNAP benefits.

The second, and perhaps more pernicious, reason SNAP theft is common, is that the victims of these crimes live in low-income households and so they are treated as disposable.

Despite years of warning that EBT theft was common and rising, state governments have been, at best, slow to act. And the federal government has been unwilling to extend to SNAP beneficiaries the same kinds of consumer protections that other credit and debit card users receive, including being notified of suspicious charges. As a result, SNAP recipients are entering the new year with even less protection at a moment when scams and fraud have reached all-time highs.

The consequences of these actions are devastating for families already struggling to make ends meet. Further, if working-class households do not view government as having their back, then support for the very safety net meant to protect people will continue to weaken. A cycle emerges where the failure to protect people breeds distrust in both government and our communities, eroding the high levels of social trust needed to invest in social programs.

The Nation Weekly

Fridays. A weekly digest of the best of our coverage.
By signing up, you confirm that you are over the age of 16 and agree to receive occasional promotional offers for programs that support The Nation’s journalism. You may unsubscribe or adjust your preferences at any time. You can read our Privacy Policy here.

And that might entirely be the point.

It is well known that conservatives in Washington, DC, prefer making the safety net exceedingly difficult to access through what has become known as the “time tax.” But this new maneuver takes it a step further by saying that even if you jump through all the hoops and onerous requirements government creates, you’re still on your own if you get robbed.

For those who live in states that will neither reimburse nor invest in secure EBT card technology, we can hardly blame people if their trust in government and in their neighbors continues to decline. In the end, that might be exactly what those who abet the SNAP benefit thieves are hoping for.

Devon Gray

Devon Gray is the president of End Poverty in California (EPIC). He previously served as a special adviser in Governor Gavin Newsom’s administration.

More from The Nation

Governor Newsom, It's Time to Get Off the Sidelines

Governor Newsom, It's Time to Get Off the Sidelines Governor Newsom, It's Time to Get Off the Sidelines

The California governor was careful not to provoke Donald Trump after the election, but that didn't stop the president from launching a full assault against his state.

Sasha Abramsky

Billionaires Suck

Billionaires Suck Billionaires Suck

Public action, visibility brigade, Route 4, Paramus, New Jersey, January 2025.

OppArt / Karen Guancione

Katrina vanden Heuvel Resumes Editorship of “The Nation”

Katrina vanden Heuvel Resumes Editorship of “The Nation” Katrina vanden Heuvel Resumes Editorship of “The Nation”

D.D. Guttenplan, Nation editor from 2019 to 2025, returns to his reporting roots as special correspondent and host of a new Nation podcast.

Press Room

A protest in the Meatpacking District, Manhattan, New York, on Saturday, March 29, 2025.

You Don’t Get Trump Without Gaza You Don’t Get Trump Without Gaza

Fascism doesn’t just appear. It must be invited in—and the bipartisan repression of the anti-genocide movement did just that.

Ben Ehrenreich

Senator Cory Booker speaks on the Senate floor on April 1, 2025. The New Jersey senator broke the record for the longest Senate floor speech by holding the floor for more than 25 hours.

Cory Booker Makes History. Donald Trump Will Never Erase It. Cory Booker Makes History. Donald Trump Will Never Erase It.

The New Jersey senator broke Strom Thurmond’s record for speaking on the Senate floor. May Booker break the back of the neo-segregationism that Trump represents.

Joan Walsh

Danger!

Danger! Danger!

Activism for life.

OppArt / Alessandra Mondolfi