September 18, 2025

Trump Is No “President of Peace”

He’s spoiling for war.

William D. Hartung
Trump signing executive orders
Donald Trump signs executive orders, including the renaming of the Department of Defense to the Department of War, during a press availability in the Oval Office of the White House on September 5, 2025 in Washington, DC.(Kevin Dietsch / Getty Images)

President Trump’s recent decision to rename the Pentagon the War Department was applauded by at least some analysts across the political system. Experts and spokespersons on the left praised the change as truth in advertising. Probably so, but it is cold comfort when the author of that decision seems to want to wage war on us—and in fact is already doing so.

Despite Trump’s actual record, every once in a while, some pundit or think-tank analyst suggests that if Donald Trump’s true instincts were to kick in, he could become our unlikeliest “President of Peace.” Some suggest that it is the case because, after all, he desperately wants to get the Nobel Peace Prize.

Others say Trump will change course and get on the path to peace because he has no fixed ideology, unlike the neocon faction among the Never Trumpers—the men and women who brought you the war in Iraq, which Trump trashed relentlessly in his 2016 presidential campaign.

Furthermore, Trump is transactional. He likes to make deals, and he is willing to talk to the only people who can deliver a deal in many cases—US adversaries like Vladimir Putin and Kim Jong Un. Recent Democratic presidents have refused to do this, and as a result they were flying blind in any efforts to resolve a conflict, simply because they didn’t know enough about the other side’s concerns or red lines.

But Trump the potential conciliator and master dealmaker has done many things that suggest that he has no real interest in pursuing peace. His interest in helping end the war in Ukraine has more to do with freeing up resources for arms racing with China and further militarizing the US-Mexico border. And his administration’s new National Defense Strategy talks as much about combating the enemy within as it does about the risks posed by China’s economic and military rise.

Add to that the bombing of Iran, the killing of alleged Venezuelan drug dealers without due process or congressional approval, the continuation of the Biden policy of funding and enabling Israel’s brutal attacks on Gaza, which many experts consider to be genocide. And don’t forget the routine practice of masked ICE agents grabbing people off the streets, or even in their homes, and sending them to detention centers in the US or horrific prisons in El Salvador.

Alongside all the above, President Trump’s claims that his administration is somehow pursuing “deep cuts” in Pentagon spending in the name of “efficiency.” Yet the proposed budget for next year—bolstered by additions contained in the misnamed Big Beautiful Bill, will exceed $1 trillion for the first time. It is well above levels reached at the height of the Cold War or the peak of the Vietnam conflict once they are adjusted for inflation.

The pushback against the militarization of our society and the massive transfer of funds to the war machine has not been strong enough to make a difference—yet. But if the victims of the flurry of executive orders emanating from the White House get together and fight back—joined by people whose lives and livelihoods are threatened by the big ugly bill—an effective resistance movement can be built.

So we have a lot of work to do—on ourselves, among our organizations, and by some of the institutions that have so far bent the knee to the Trump administration. But we have no choice but to fight back, and whatever the odds, I think we can turn back the tide of hatred and division.

William D. Hartung

William D. Hartung is a senior research fellow at the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft.

More from The Nation

Trump’s Predatory Danger to Latin America

Trump’s Predatory Danger to Latin America Trump’s Predatory Danger to Latin America

The United States is now a superpower predator on the prowl in its “backyard.”

Peter Kornbluh

A migrant worker at a Riyadh construction site.

The Line, a Saudi Megaproject, Is Dead The Line, a Saudi Megaproject, Is Dead

It was always doomed to unravel, but the firms who lent their name to this folly should be held accountable.

Column / Kate Wagner

President Donald Trump

Donald Trump’s Nuclear Delusions Donald Trump’s Nuclear Delusions

The president wants to resume nuclear testing. 
Is he a warmonger or just an idiot?

Edward Markey

Taipei, June 2025.

How Taiwan Became the Chipmaker for the World How Taiwan Became the Chipmaker for the World

A new book tells the story of the island-nation’s transformation into a central hub for technological development and manufacturing.

Books & the Arts / Yangyang Cheng

How a French City Kept Its Soccer Team Working Class

How a French City Kept Its Soccer Team Working Class How a French City Kept Its Soccer Team Working Class

Olympique de Marseille shows that if fans organize, a team can fight racism, keep its matches affordable, and maintain a deep connection to the city.

Feature / Cole Stangler