The People Are Resisting While the Elites Are Surrendering
The Ivy League is silently complicit in Trump’s war on international students.
As Donald Trump rapidly turns America into an autocracy, a striking class divide has emerged. A popular resistance movement is coalescing against Trump made up of ordinary people—even as those with the most wealth and power in society are the quickest to bend the knee to the aspiring despot. As the political scientist Jodi Dean noted in a recent editorial in The Nation, “The institutions of civil society, the organizations and practices that give democracy its substance, are crumbling. The word of the day is capitulation.”
Strikingly, the most abject submission has come from the commanding heights of society. Dean’s list of the acquiescent includes Columbia University (meekly caving in to Trump’s demand of a purge of pro-Palestinian students), the tony law firm Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison (which pledged $40 million in pro bono work after Trump threatened to take away their security clearance), and Senate minority leader Chuck Schumer (who has adopted a strategy of buckling to Trump’s demands, including on occasions when Democrats had the ability to filibuster, as in the budget crisis). Since Dean wrote, the pattern she described has gotten worse, with even more top-tier universities and big law firms bowing and scraping to Trump as if he were an absolute monarch.
Against this pattern of elite yielding, there’s plenty of evidence that ordinary people are ready to fight. Lawmakers of both parties—but especially Republicans—are terrified to go to town halls lest they be confronted by angry voters asking why they are allowing Donald Trump and Elon Musk to run roughshod over government programs. Earlier this month, massive “hands-off” protests surged through the streets of American cities.
The difference between the fighting spirit of ordinary Americans and the demoralized complicity of the elite is most visible in the field of education. When ICE agents go after students in elementary and high schools, they often meet a wall of opposition from staff and local residents.
Last Monday, The Guardian reported on one such case:
A mother and her three children who were taken into custody by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (Ice) agents as part of a sweep in the tiny hometown of the Trump administration’s “border czar”, Tom Homan, have been released following days of outcry from community figures, advocates, and protesters calling for their freedom.
Over the weekend, about a thousand protesters marched outside Homan’s home in a small New York village, calling for the release of the family after they were detained last month….
Jaime Cook, principal of the Sackets Harbor school district where the children reportedly attended class, wrote a letter to the community pleading for the students’ safe return.
On Wednesday, the Los Angeles Times reported:
Federal agents were denied entrance to two elementary schools in the Los Angeles Unified School District this week after they showed up unannounced and sought to get in touch with five students who the agents alleged had entered the country without documentation.
Contrast the behavior of these schools with that of Harvard. On Friday, The New York Times reported on the maddening case of Kseniia Petrova, a researcher at Harvard Medical School who has been held in detention by immigration authorities for two months. A Russian citizen, Petrova works in the US on a visa. In February she went to France. Returning to the United States, she brought back, at the request of her supervisor, lab samples of frog embryos. Immigration officials at the airport felt she had not filled out the proper forms and moved to deport her. Because there is a genuine risk of harm if she is returned to Russia, due to her past actions protesting Russian autocrat Vladimir Putin, she was detained rather than immediately deported. She is currently in a Louisiana detention center as her case is being reviewed.
The New York Times reports, “Harvard has made little comment about Ms. Petrova’s detention.” A spokesperson for Harvard told the newspaper the university “is closely following the rapidly shifting immigration policy landscape and the implications for its international scholars and students,” and is “engaged with Ms. Petrova’s attorney on this matter.”
When Petrova’s supervisor asked “colleagues to send letters of support for her to ICE, many of them confessed that they were afraid to put their names on paper—because they were in the country on temporary visas as well.”
The New York Times also reports that “Marina Sakharov-Liberman, the granddaughter of the Soviet physicist and dissident Andrei Sakharov, has been following the case from her home in London. She said it was ‘extraordinary’ that Harvard had not more publicly protested Ms. Petrova’s detention and demanded her release.”
The Petrova case is not rare. While the most egregious assaults on civil liberties involve pro-Palestinian protesters such as former Columbia student Mahmoud Khalil, who is a political prisoner, there are many more international students who are at risk of deportation for minor offenses, including speeding tickets.
As Sam Stein of The Bulwark writes:
The Trump administration has revoked hundreds of international student visas in recent weeks, causing fear and havoc at universities and colleges across the country. One of the latest examples quietly took place this past week at the University of Georgia, where six non-U.S. citizen graduate students, all studying in the STEM disciplines, received notices that their visas were being revoked. According to a source familiar with the situation, more visa terminations are expected.
Inside Higher Education, which is maintaining a database on these threatened deportations and visa revocations, has recorded nearly 1,000 such cases.
Trump’s war on international students poses an existential threat to American higher education. For centuries, immigrant scholars have enriched America. As Forbes notes, “Immigrants have been awarded 40%, or 45 of 112, of the Nobel Prizes won by Americans in chemistry, medicine and physics since 2000.” In a world where scholars no longer felt the United States was a safe haven, many of these scholars might take their talent elsewhere. Politico reports that European countries are developing programs to poach scholars from America. It’s easy to imagine other parts of the world, like Canada, Latin America, and Asia, doing the same. Just as Trump’s tariff policy is leading to de-dollarization, his immigration policy is leading to de-scholarization: a willful dumbing down of society.
Popular
“swipe left below to view more authors”Swipe →Trump’s immigration purge is also an affront to basic principles of free speech, which are at the core of the very mission of universities. Yet the administrators of top schools such as Columbia and Harvard have been notably silent on this issue. There are a few rare exceptions to this rule, notably Princeton president Christopher L. Eisgruber, a vocal defender of free speech. Moreover, academic organizations such as the American Association of University Professors have taken up the legal battles that university administrators are too cowardly to wage.
But overall, this is a dismal time for American higher education, as it is for the American elite in general. Once Trump is defeated, America will need a reckoning with this elite failure. After all, if the ruling class can’t even defend the basic norms of liberal democracy, why should they be allowed to rule at all?
Support independent journalism that does not fall in line
Even before February 28, the reasons for Donald Trump’s imploding approval rating were abundantly clear: untrammeled corruption and personal enrichment to the tune of billions of dollars during an affordability crisis, a foreign policy guided only by his own derelict sense of morality, and the deployment of a murderous campaign of occupation, detention, and deportation on American streets.
Now an undeclared, unauthorized, unpopular, and unconstitutional war of aggression against Iran has spread like wildfire through the region and into Europe. A new “forever war”—with an ever-increasing likelihood of American troops on the ground—may very well be upon us.
As we’ve seen over and over, this administration uses lies, misdirection, and attempts to flood the zone to justify its abuses of power at home and abroad. Just as Trump, Marco Rubio, and Pete Hegseth offer erratic and contradictory rationales for the attacks on Iran, the administration is also spreading the lie that the upcoming midterm elections are under threat from noncitizens on voter rolls. When these lies go unchecked, they become the basis for further authoritarian encroachment and war.
In these dark times, independent journalism is uniquely able to uncover the falsehoods that threaten our republic—and civilians around the world—and shine a bright light on the truth.
The Nation’s experienced team of writers, editors, and fact-checkers understands the scale of what we’re up against and the urgency with which we have to act. That’s why we’re publishing critical reporting and analysis of the war on Iran, ICE violence at home, new forms of voter suppression emerging in the courts, and much more.
But this journalism is possible only with your support.
This March, The Nation needs to raise $50,000 to ensure that we have the resources for reporting and analysis that sets the record straight and empowers people of conscience to organize. Will you donate today?
More from
Jeet Heer 
Robert Mueller Never Should Have Been a Liberal Hero Robert Mueller Never Should Have Been a Liberal Hero
The cult of Mueller foolishly prioritized legal prosecution over political organizing.
Will the Iran War Destroy MAGA? Will the Iran War Destroy MAGA?
Trump’s coalition is splintering over nationalism and Israel.
Canada’s Left Is in Crisis. Can Avi Lewis Revive It? Canada’s Left Is in Crisis. Can Avi Lewis Revive It?
As Mark Carney’s deceptive centrism pushes the country to the right, Avi Lewis offers a compelling alternative.
The Iran War Is Spurring Global Anger at America The Iran War Is Spurring Global Anger at America
Trump’s reckless and unnecessary conflict is hurting allies as well as foes.
Is AIPAC Doomed? Is AIPAC Doomed?
The hard-line pro-Israel lobby is facing more opposition than ever before. But fully defanging it won’t be easy.
The Man Who Would Be the Face of the Anti-Trump West The Man Who Would Be the Face of the Anti-Trump West
Mark Carney has put himself forward as one of the sharpest Western critics of Trump’s neo-imperial order. What’s less clear is what he’s offering in its stead.
