The Profound Shame of JD Vance
Trump’s lapdog defends racist Young Republicans as “boys,” while some are almost his age—as they slur Indian women, like his wife, Usha, as “dirty.” How much did he get for his soul?
Vice President JD Vance at the White House.
(Alex Wong / Getty Images)
At first I saw it as a “dog bites man” story. A posse of “young” Republicans (as old as 40) got caught by Politico on a 28,000-post text thread praising Hitler, threatening their (fellow Republican) enemies with “gas chambers” and “rape,” slurring Black people as monkeys and “watermelon people,” denouncing LGBTQ people as “fags” and worse, and also insulting Indian women as “dirty.” Are we really supposed to be surprised?
Politico reported the exchange “is part of a trove of Telegram chats…spanning more than seven months of messages among Young Republican leaders in New York, Kansas, Arizona and Vermont.”
Surprisingly to me, a fair number of Republicans found it in their withered souls to denounce these ugly fools. A few of the guilty actually got fired. But someone who stuck up for them? Vice President JD Vance.
“The reality is that kids do stupid things, especially young boys,” Vance said on The Charlie Kirk Show. “They tell edgy, offensive jokes. That’s what kids do. And I really don’t want us to grow up in a country where a kid telling a stupid joke—telling a very offensive, stupid joke—is cause to ruin their lives.” Earlier he posted on X: “I refuse to join the pearl clutching.”
A couple of things, JD. They are not all, or even mostly, “kids.” You’re 41; the creepy Peter Giunta, who started the group chat to gin up support for his doomed bid to head the Young Republicans, is 31. An aide to New York Assemblyman Mike Reilly, Giunta got fired today. Giunta’s bid to run the Young Republicans was backed by Representative Elise Stefanik, MAGA weathervane, who is likely to challenge New York Governor Kathy Hochul, as well as the original Young Republican “ratfucker” Roger Stone. Other members of the chat are elected officials, or elevated staffers of elected officials.
Politico reports 251 of the texts in the group contained racial, ethnic, antisemitic, or gendered slurs, and/or threats of violence. These are not boys in the back of the schoolyard; these are men in positions of Republican Party power.
Politico, which will never be confused with The Nation, concluded: “Together, the messages reveal a culture where racist, antisemitic and violent rhetoric circulate freely—and where the Trump-era loosening of political norms has made such talk feel less taboo among those positioning themselves as the party’s next leaders.” Indeed.
And Vance’s pardoning these angry, even violent slurs, as “jokes” goes as far as Trump himself ever has. He’s also ignoring an insult to Indian women, though that’s his wife, Usha’s identity.
Specifically, one of the creeps complained that a colleague was dating “a very obese Indian woman for a period of time.”
Giunta responded that the woman “was not Indian.”
“She just didn’t bathe often,” Samuel Douglass, Vermont state senator and the head of the state’s Young Republicans, interjected.
How are you, JD Vance, married to an Indian woman, insisting that’s just kid talk?
Because it’s not kid talk. It’s everyday talk in today’s Republican Party. Trump surfed this wave of bilge into the White House, twice. We’re soaking in it. Vance, desperately trying to inherit the MAGA mantle, doesn’t know he’s already drowned.
More from The Nation
Elizabeth Warren’s Plan for a Revived Democratic Party Elizabeth Warren’s Plan for a Revived Democratic Party
The Massachusetts senator argues that, in order to prevail in the midterms, the party needs to recover its populist roots—and fighting spirit.
Renee Good’s Killing Has Unleashed MAGA’s Misogyny Renee Good’s Killing Has Unleashed MAGA’s Misogyny
To defend the indefensible, the right is going after white women as race traitors.
Despite Themselves, Democrats Look Well Positioned for the Midterms Despite Themselves, Democrats Look Well Positioned for the Midterms
An otherwise inert opposition party may well clean up on Donald Trump's destructive and hubristic governing record.
Abolish ICE or GTFO Abolish ICE or GTFO
In this week’s Elie v. U.S., our justice correspondent makes the case to get rid of ICE, explores George Conway’s congressional campaign—and shares his New Year’s resolution.
