World / November 29, 2023

Chuck Schumer Is Antisemitism’s Great Enabler

A personal reply to the senator’s personal attack.

Dave Zirin
Chuck Schumer march for israel/ israel-palestine/ gaza
Senate majority leader Chuck Schumer speaks during the March For Israel at the National Mall on November 14, 2023, in Washington, D.C. (Noam Galai / Getty)

At first, I was shocked that Senator Chuck Schumer, standing in the well of the US Senate, called an article I wrote “antisemitic.” I was told that his problem was that I described last month’s massive “Stand With Israel” march, where Schumer spoke, as “a hate rally.” I was gratified that he had seen the piece, and I was ready to argue that the anti-Palestinian hate on display that day as well as the platforming of anti-Jewish Christian Zionists gave more than enough validity to my description.

But then I read Schumer’s full remarks—and was horrified. As a proud Jew, I was distressed that Schumer would use my article as an example, along with synagogue vandalization and Nazi hate crimes, as part of a “rising tide of antisemitism.” (In his litany of antisemitic examples, Elon Musk’s recent actions curiously did not merit a mention.)

Schumer is weaponizing the incendiary charge of antisemitism against me and The Nation as cover to slander the left generally—specifically the movement of a new generation of Jews marching and getting arrested in the name of a permanent cease-fire. He is also obfuscating his own craven efforts to ally with actual antisemites and genocidal Israeli politicians in the name of this war on Gaza.

Too harsh? Well, I attended the Stand with Israel rally, and I know what I saw. I saw Chuck Schumer join hands with Christian Zionist Speaker of the House Mike Johnson and share a stage with a notorious anti-Jewish bigot, the Rev. John Hagee. I also saw a rousing ovation for Israeli President Isaac Herzog, who has recently called for a total war on all Palestinians, saying, “It’s an entire nation out there that’s responsible.” In addition, I saw an over-his-head Van Jones call for peace only to be shouted down by the crowd.

Schumer either spent that day with his head in the sand or supports these kinds of alliances. My fear is that it’s the latter. Calling the march “a hate rally” was completely appropriate.

Let’s be clear: Antisemitism is not criticizing an intensely pro-war rally held in your home city just days after thousands marched for a cease-fire and lasting peace. Antisemitism is when people like Schumer bind Zionism (a 150-year-old political ideology) and Judaism (a 5,000-year-old religion) to such a degree that they want the world to believe that Israeli war crimes are being justly committed in our name as Jews.

Read the article Chuck Schumer called “anti-Semitic” and decide for yourself

In addition, Schumer’s desire to hand over billions in weapons to the Musk- and Christian Zionist–supporting government of Benjamin Netanyahu also aids antisemitism. He is providing cover for people who despise our faith, because they also support unconditionally Israel’s total war on Gazan civilians. Schumer, heal thyself, and stop supporting war crimes being committed in our name. By stoking even more antisemitism, it’s dangerous to Jews everywhere.

I am also disturbed that Schumer chose this week to engage in these attacks, a week when so many of us are still in shock over the shooting of three Palestinian US college students in Burlington, Vt. The war has come home, and Schumer’s instinct is to put out these fires with gasoline.

Dear reader,

I hope you enjoyed the article you just read. It’s just one of the many deeply-reported and boundary-pushing stories we publish everyday at The Nation. In a time of continued erosion of our fundamental rights and urgent global struggles for peace, independent journalism is now more vital than ever.

As a Nation reader, you are likely an engaged progressive who is passionate about bold ideas. I know I can count on you to help sustain our mission-driven journalism.

This month, we’re kicking off an ambitious Summer Fundraising Campaign with the goal of raising $15,000. With your support, we can continue to produce the hard-hitting journalism you rely on to cut through the noise of conservative, corporate media. Please, donate today.

A better world is out there—and we need your support to reach it.

Onwards,

Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editorial Director and Publisher, The Nation

Dave Zirin

Dave Zirin is the sports editor at The Nation. He is the author of 11 books on the politics of sports. He is also the coproducer and writer of the new documentary Behind the Shield: The Power and Politics of the NFL.

More from The Nation

This nuclear explosion was conducted at the Nevada Test Site in 1953.

Don’t Believe the Military. We Don’t “Need” More Nuclear Weapons. Don’t Believe the Military. We Don’t “Need” More Nuclear Weapons.

If we’re set on Armageddon, America’s existing force of nuclear submarines is more than enough.

William Astore

Activists from Jewish Voice for Peace occupy the pedestal of the Statue of Liberty on November 6, 2023.

Why the Establishment Loves Smearing Young People as Antisemites Why the Establishment Loves Smearing Young People as Antisemites

Pundits and politicians are elevating blatantly dishonest polls to shore up an indefensible war.

Jeet Heer

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu attends a cabinet meeting at the Bible Lands Museum in Jerusalem on June 5, 2024.

Inviting Netanyahu to Congress Is Like “a Bad Horror Movie” Inviting Netanyahu to Congress Is Like “a Bad Horror Movie”

After Republicans and Democrats joined forces to welcome the Israeli prime minister, progressives began vowing to boycott the speech.

John Nichols

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is GettyImages-2153819012-1.jpg Magistrates arrive at the International Court of Justice to hear South Africa’s request for a Gaza cease-fire, in The Hague, on May 24, 2024.

Israel’s Legal Reckoning and the Historical Shift in Justice for Palestinians Israel’s Legal Reckoning and the Historical Shift in Justice for Palestinians

Global courts challenge Israeli action in Gaza.

Reed Brody

Palestinians in a destroyed residential area try to collect usable items under the rubble.

It’s Never Been About Freeing the Hostages It’s Never Been About Freeing the Hostages

Israel’s scorched-earth campaign will cruelly shape the lives of many future generations of Palestinians—and that’s the point.

Joshua Frank

Relatives and friends of Palestinians imprisoned in Israel lift signs at a rally calling for their release and the return of the bodies of those who died during incarceration, in Hebron in the occupied West Bank on February 27, 2024.

The Israeli Injustice Complex The Israeli Injustice Complex

How the military courts serve as one of Israel’s most effective and secretive weapons.

Martin Garbus