World / November 10, 2023

Gaza — Where Is the Law?

For decades, justice has been absent from the conflict. Will that change now?

Reed Brody
pro-Palestine protest outside International criminal court, demanding action from the ICC during ongoing bombing, genocide in Gaza
Pro-Palestine demonstrators demand action from the International Criminal Court outside its headquarters on October 18, 2023, in The Hague, Netherlands.(Roger Anis / Getty)

As Israel mounted its air campaign in Gaza last month, bombs destroyed the home of my dear friend Raji Sourani, director of the Palestinian Center for Human Rights. Three days earlier, Sourani had told Democracy Now!, “I am here like an olive tree. We will never leave our homeland.” But when the bombs rained down, he wondered if he had made a mistake by refusing to leave. He hadn’t wanted “be part of new Nakba,” as he wrote to his friends after surviving.

What makes the attack on Sourani’s home particularly disturbing among all the wanton killings of the past month is that Raji, winner of the Robert F. Kennedy Human Rights Award, has for 40 years symbolized the attempt to use the law to redress Israeli crimes against Palestinian civilians, including war crimes, collective punishments, illegal settlements, and apartheid.

I remember sitting next to Sourani in The Hague in December 2020 when he looked the International Criminal Court prosecutor Fatou Bensouda in the eye and pleaded with her to tell Palestinians that they could trust in the ICC to heed their plight, that the court could assure them international law still had meaning for them and violence was not the only weapon they had at their disposal.

The fact is, however, that every attempt to use the ICC and other institutions to hold Israeli officials legally accountable has been sidelined or delegitimized as “lawfare.” Complaints filed in Europe against Israeli leaders on the basis of “universal jurisdiction”—the so-called “Pinochet principle” of pursuing justice in courts abroad—were not only thrown out; in some instances, the laws in question were curtailed so that such cases could not be brought again in the future.

Palestinian efforts to invoke the ICC have gotten the slow walk for the almost 15 years since the Palestinian Authority (PA) submitted a declaration accepting the court’s jurisdiction in January 2009, following Israel’s “Cast Lead” operation, which left more than 1,400 Gazans dead. Prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo, under strong pressure from the United States (not itself even a party to the ICC), spent three years considering whether he had jurisdiction before punting the issue to other UN bodies. After the UN General Assembly recognized Palestine as an observer state, and Palestine in 2015 ratified the ICC’s governing Rome Statute, prosecutor Bensouda conducted, in her own words, “a painstaking preliminary examination…that lasted close to five years” before opening a formal investigation in March 2021 just as her nine-year term was about to expire. By then, the Trump administration had imposed sanctions on Bensouda for her probe into alleged US crimes in Afghanistan and to deter further ICC action on Palestine. Even in 2021, when the Biden administration lifted those sanctions, Secretary of State Anthony Blinken maintained the United States’ “longstanding objection to the Court’s efforts to assert jurisdiction over personnel of non-States Parties such as the United States and Israel.”

By contrast, when Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022, the new ICC prosecutor, the astute Briton Karim Khan, elected with strong UK and American support, made multiple visits to a country he called a “crime scene,” opened the largest investigation in the ICC’s history, and raised unprecedented amounts of extrabudgetary money and temporary staff from Western countries. Even the United States expressed its support, although the ICC was exerting jurisdiction over nationals of a country—Russia—that, like Israel and the United States, was not a party to the ICC. By March 2023, Khan had issued an arrest warrant for Vladimir Putin over the deportation of thousands of children from Ukraine.

Current Issue

Cover of July 2024 Issue

Sourani supported the Ukraine probe but lamented at the time that the prosecutor had made no similar attempt to raise outside money to fund the Palestine investigation, never spoke about a “crime scene,” and had not apparently sought to visit Palestine. Khan announced at the ICC Assembly in December 2022 that he hoped to go to Palestine in 2023, but Israel is known to have rejected his request. The fact is that, as of today, no Israeli official has had to face international charges for crimes committed over several decades of conflict, creating a sense of impunity. After surviving the bombing of his house, Sourani told Democracy Now! he considered Khan “complicit” through his inactivity in the crimes now unfolding in Gaza. (As I write, Sourani is still in Gaza City, very close to Israeli bombs, and unable now to get out.)

In the face of the mounting atrocities and growing criticism of the ICC’s failure to comment, Khan broke his silence, however, visiting the Rafah crossing between Egypt and Gaza on October 29 and following that up with an unusually strong, emotive speech in Cairo that harked back to his soaring rhetoric following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. He spoke in detail about Hamas’s cruel attacks and hostage-takings on October 7, which he labeled as crimes, and about the Israeli response. He made a point of warning the Israeli government that any attack liable to kill civilians must comply with principles under international law of “distinction, precaution and of proportionality.” In other words, any time the Israelis hit a house, a school, a hospital, a church, or a mosque, they needed to remember that such places enjoyed protected status—“unless the protective status has been lost…[and] the burden of proving that the protective status is lost rests with those who fire the gun, the missile, or the rocket in question.”

No prosecutor has ever spoken to Israel so bluntly. The question now is whether Khan will take action to follow up on his strong words. Will he move on the charges of apartheid and war crimes, including illegal settlements, which have been on his desk for years? Will Israel allow him to investigate on the ground? Will the United States drop its long-standing objection to the ICC’s role? Will there, finally, be room for accountability in the Israel-Palestine conflict?

Thank you for reading The Nation

We hope you enjoyed the story you just read, just one of the many incisive, deeply-reported articles we publish daily. Now more than ever, we need fearless journalism that shifts the needle on important issues, uncovers malfeasance and corruption, and uplifts voices and perspectives that often go unheard in mainstream media.

Throughout this critical election year and a time of media austerity and renewed campus activism and rising labor organizing, independent journalism that gets to the heart of the matter is more critical than ever before. Donate right now and help us hold the powerful accountable, shine a light on issues that would otherwise be swept under the rug, and build a more just and equitable future.

For nearly 160 years, The Nation has stood for truth, justice, and moral clarity. As a reader-supported publication, we are not beholden to the whims of advertisers or a corporate owner. But it does take financial resources to report on stories that may take weeks or months to properly investigate, thoroughly edit and fact-check articles, and get our stories into the hands of readers.

Donate today and stand with us for a better future. Thank you for being a supporter of independent journalism.

Reed Brody

Reed Brody is a veteran war crimes prosecutor. His latest book is To Catch a Dictator: The Pursuit and Trial of Hissène Habré (Columbia University Press).

More from The Nation

Five people (four in suits, one woman in traditional Palestinian dress) stand behind Olympic rings. The middle two hold a certificate.

Palestinian Olympians Are Competing as Their World Burns Palestinian Olympians Are Competing as Their World Burns

Palestinian Olympians will make history in Paris, despite unfathomable conditions of genocide.

Dave Zirin

International Solidarity With Palestine

International Solidarity With Palestine International Solidarity With Palestine

Street mural, Barcelona, Catalunya, Spain.

OppArt / Andrea Arroyo

Palestinian children watch as an Israeli bulldozer works in the West Bank hamlet of Khan al-Ahmar, Thursday, July 5, 2018.

The Horror in Israel and Palestine Began Half a Century Ago The Horror in Israel and Palestine Began Half a Century Ago

From the very start, Jewish violence has accompanied the proliferation of settlements.

Ellen Cantarow

Wayne Smith, former top US diplomat to Havana during former President Jimmy Carter's administration, is seen on May 2, 2002, in Havana, Cuba during a meeting with the media.

Wayne Smith Devoted His Career to Dialogue and Diplomacy Wayne Smith Devoted His Career to Dialogue and Diplomacy

The former Foreign Service officer liked to say “Cuba seems to have the same effect on American administrations as the full moon has on werewolves.”

Obituary / Peter Kornbluh and William M. LeoGrande

How Microfinance Became the ‘It’ Development Program

How Microfinance Became the ‘It’ Development Program How Microfinance Became the ‘It’ Development Program

Microfinance has been touted as a miracle cure for poverty in the global south. The reality has been a lot messier.

Feature / Mara Kardas-Nelson

People are seen celebrating on the statue of Marianne on the Place de la République to celebrate after the Nouveau Front populaire, an alliance of left-wing parties including La France Insoumise came in first on July 7, 2024, in Paris, France.

The Risky Politics of France’s Hung Parliament The Risky Politics of France’s Hung Parliament

In the days since the New Popular Front won the largest number of seats, political gravity has again exerted itself.

Harrison Stetler