World / November 15, 2023

Biden’s Foreign Aid Request Is Corporate Welfare for the Arms Industry

Military contractors would get an estimated $60 billion from the president’s spending request, according to an analysis of federal acquisition data.

Stephen Semler
Biden smiling, surrounded by military March 2023

President Joe Biden greets members of the military at North Island Naval Air Station in San Diego, Calif., on March 14, 2023.

(Evan Vucci / AP)

The Biden administration is on the offensive selling the president’s $106 billion foreign aid request, insisting that the enormous sum was proposed in the name of security. Secretary of State Antony Blinken described the proposal as an “investment” in US national security in a Washington Post opinion piece, mirroring Biden’s characterization from his recent Oval Office speech: “It’s a smart investment that’s going to pay dividends for American security.”

It’s better described as corporate welfare. Military contractors stand to gain an estimated $60 billion in revenue from Biden’s proposal, based on my analysis of federal contracting data.

Military spending always entails a redistribution of wealth from the public to private sector, but some parts of the military budget produce more contract dollars for private companies than others. Much of the military aid in Biden’s proposal falls under the standard divisions or “functional titles” of the Pentagon budget: personnel, operation, and maintenance; research and development; military construction, and procurement.

The estimate above is based on the share of funding under each title that has gone to contracts in the past. Personnel expenses mostly go to troop pay and entail virtually no contracting, while procurement means buying matériel from private contractors. The three other titles fall somewhere in between. On average, I found that nearly 40 percent of operation and maintenance funding in a given year is obligated to contracts, 60 percent of research and development funding, and over 70 percent for military construction. Data is scarce at this level of analysis, but several previous studies arrive at similar numbers.

Weapons companies would also capitalize directly off of the military aid programs included in Biden’s request that are run by the State Department. The Foreign Military Financing (FMF) program, for example, functions as a multibillion-dollar gift card for non-US countries to buy weapons from US firms. Biden’s request has $1.7 billion in FMF money for Ukraine, $3.5 billion for Israel (on top of the $3.3 billion it receives annually), and $2 billion for countries in the Indo-Pacific region as part of the administration’s aggressive China policy.

What makes this spending request resemble corporate welfare rather than an investment in security? For one, it’s questionable whether this funding will actually produce security. If that is in fact the desired outcome, it doesn’t seem wise to eschew diplomatic approaches and commit billions more to what looks like an endless war in Ukraine, an Israeli military offensive that killed more than 4,000 children in just one month, and a strategy that promotes a new cold war with China.

Second is that this “emergency” request isn’t funded by the record-setting Pentagon budget but adds to it. The budget deal Biden negotiated with then–House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) capped Pentagon spending in 2024 at $886 billion, but a loophole allows for more so long as it’s designated as “emergency” spending. This workaround allows Biden to cite Russia’s war in Ukraine as justification for increasing the base Pentagon budget, but secure Ukraine military aid funding from a supplemental spending bill. This unwillingness to make trade-offs alongside its explicitly non-urgent priorities like shipbuilding, makes Biden’s “emergency” request look an awful lot like a corporate handout.

Over the last five years, 56 percent of the annual Pentagon budget has gone to contracts. So even without the $60 billion from Biden’s supplemental spending request, 2024 was already going to be an excellent year for military contractors, thanks to the $886 billion base budget. Between Biden’s foreign aid request and proposed Pentagon budget, military contractors can expect $559 billion in revenue. By comparison, Biden’s flagship five-year infrastructure bill contains a total of $548 billion in funding. These military investments only guarantee private profit, not public security.

Stephen Semler

Stephen Semler is cofounder of Security Policy Reform Institute, a grassroots-funded US foreign policy think tank.

More from The Nation

Fire breaks out at the Shahran oil depot after US and Israeli attacks in Tehran, Iran, on March 8, 2026.

America’s Iran Failure Is Bigger Than Trump America’s Iran Failure Is Bigger Than Trump

Trump’s personalization of foreign policy is ultimately a symptom of a deeper institutional problem rather than its source.

Sina Toossi and Nancy Okail

People look at their phones as they travel on a U-Bahn train at Alexanderplatz station in the Mitte area of Berlin, Germany, on August 26, 2024.

The Bitter Paradox of German Racism The Bitter Paradox of German Racism

I left America in 2017 to flee an authoritarian government and the culture it facilitated. What I found in Berlin was not all that different.

Edna Bonhomme

A billboard in Tehran asserts that despite the threats of President Donald Trump, Iran will retain control over the Strait of Hormuz.

America’s Imperial Wars, Then and Now America’s Imperial Wars, Then and Now

From Korea to the Strait of Hormuz.

Tom Engelhardt

A monument to Orlando Letelier and Ronni Karpen Moffitt, who were killed by agents of the Chilean secret police in 1976, in Washington, DC.

A Modicum of Justice for Ronni Karpen Moffitt A Modicum of Justice for Ronni Karpen Moffitt

Fifty years after Pinochet’s henchmen assassinated her and Orlando Letelier, finally a judicial reckoning.

Peter Kornbluh

President Donald Trump arrives at the White House in Washington, DC, US, on Sunday, July 5, 2026.

Trump Can’t Admit That He Lost the Iran War Trump Can’t Admit That He Lost the Iran War

An expensive, ruinous conflict resumes for no other reason than one octogenarian narcissist’s inability to face reality.

David Faris

First responders inspect the wreckage of a car reportedly targeted by an Israeli strike in Nabatieh, in the south of Lebanon, on July 6, 2026, which Lebanese state media said killed four people, including three women.

The Genocide of South Lebanon The Genocide of South Lebanon

Israel is carrying out its Gaza strategy in yet another war.

Ahmad Ibsais