Trump Says “Republicans Have Never Been So United.” He’s Delusional.
As the party’s immediate former president, a virtual incumbent, he’s losing over a third of the vote in the primaries and caucuses.
Donald Trump speaks during an election-night watch party at the South Carolina State Fairgrounds in Columbia on Saturday, February 24, 2024.
(Victor J. Blue / Bloomberg via Getty Images)After losing 40 percent of the vote in South Carolina’s presidential primary on Saturday, Donald Trump claimed, with his usual combination of bravado and delusion, “I have never seen the Republican Party so unified as it is right now.”
That’s a lie that Trump likes to tell himself. But none of the rest of us have to believe it.
The fact is that the base of potential Republican voters is deeply divided about Trump, and that’s very good news for Joe Biden and the Democrats.
Trump is all but certain to be the Republican nominee in 2024. But he will run as a wounded candidate who is far more vulnerable to losing a substantial portion of his base than past GOP nominees who were in similar circumstances.
Trump’s circumstance is this: He’s not running for reelection from the White House, as he did in 2020. But he is his party’s most recent president, and less than four years ago he secured the second-highest level of support ever in a November presidential election. He has Taylor Swift–level name recognition. He’s supported by almost every prominent Republican who has made an endorsement this year, including scads of governors, senators, and House members.
In other words, he’s as close as Republicans will get this year to running an incumbent.
Yet Trump is not gaining anywhere near the sort of support that incumbent Republicans—or even prominent front-runners—received in the past.
After five primary and caucus contests, he’s winning under 59.5 percent of the overall total of votes cast. Most of the remaining votes have gone to the hapless candidacy of Trump’s last remaining “name” rival, former South Carolina governor Nikki Haley.
The 36.8 percent of the overall vote that Haley has secured following contests in Iowa, New Hampshire, Nevada, the Virgin Islands, and South Carolina is not a measure of her personal popularity. It’s a measure of the opposition to Trump within his own party.
A very high measure, when seen in the perspective of past Republican nomination contests.
In 1980, when Ronald Reagan was mounting his third bid for the presidency, as a nonincumbent running in a multicandidate field for the GOP nod, he won roughly 60 percent of the overall primary and caucus vote.
In 1984, as an incumbent seeking reelection, Reagan won 98.8 percent.
In 1988, when Reagan’s vice president, George H. W. Bush, was running as a a nonincumbent in a crowded contest for the Republican nomination that included senators, cabinet members, and religious broadcaster Pat Robertson, he won 67.9 percent of the overall primary and caucus vote.
In 1992, when Bush was running for reelection, he won 78.2 percent of the overall primary and caucus vote. The fact that 23 percent of the vote went to syndicated columnist Pat Buchanan was seen as a serious problem for Bush, who felt compelled to try to unite the party by offering Buchanan a speaking slot at that summer’s Republican National Convention. That went horribly, as Buchanan delivered a divisive “culture wars” speech that contributed to Bush’s loss in November.
Haley has already run considerably better than Buchanan and could continue to do so for as long as she can maintain a candidacy that took a hit over the weekend when the circle of billionaire donors associated with Charles Koch signaled that it would stop funding her bid.
Haley, whose delegate count stands at 20, versus 110 for Trump, never had a realistic chance of being the Republican nominee. She’s likely to suspend her bid before the primary season is done. And, in the unlikely event that Trump is forced to stand down—presumably, with the right combination of convictions from his 91 criminal indictments—there’s little chance that MAGA delegates to the Republican National Convention would turn to the former governor of South Carolina, whom Trump has been slurring for months with an openly racist, sexist, and xenophobic campaign that seems to delight his base.
Haley has maintained her bid in order to claim a role in defining the future of the party, and South Carolina gave her a credible argument for her continued candidacy. She was winning two-fifths of the total in her home state, where the Republican governor and both US senators, as well as the rest of the party establishment. backed Trump.
Popular
“swipe left below to view more authors”Swipe →Haley observed, “I know 40 percent is not 50 percent. But I also know 40 percent is not some tiny group.”
That’s exactly right. It is not a small group.
Haley’s primary numbers have confirmed that the GOP is divided over Trump.
He’s losing a higher percentage of the vote than Republican presidential contenders in similar positions to his own. And exit polls show that Republican primary voters who are rejecting him are doing so for a reason: They’ve got qualms about his fitness for the office. Those concerns would be confirmed by a criminal conviction.
In South Carolina, a conservative Republican stronghold, 36 percent of GOP primary voters said they’d consider Trump unfit for office if he were to be convicted of a crime—a very real prospect, as several of the former president’s many trials are likely to be scheduled for before the 2024 election.
In New Hampshire, an actual battleground state, the “Trump would be unfit” number among Republican primary voters was 47 percent.
“The GOP primary has laid bare the stark and indisputable reality that while Trump has the united support of his MAGA base, he is struggling to make himself palatable to these key constituencies that will ultimately decide the election this November,” explained Quentin Fulks, Biden’s deputy campaign manager, after a review of the New Hampshire numbers.
Nothing about that calculus has changed in the month since New Hampshire voted. In fact, while Trump and his aides talked about finishing off Haley in her home state, she actually ran better than many pollsters and pundits had anticipated.
The Haley vote can be seen as a base of discontented Republicans and Republican-leaning independents. Many of them may stand down and simply not vote in November, or perhaps back a third-party candidate. Some could cross over and vote for Biden—especially in battleground states such as New Hampshire, Nevada, Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania.
That explains why MSNBC host Lawrence O’Donnell, a veteran political aide with considerable experience observing questions of party unity, remarked as the South Carolina votes were being counted, “These numbers are disastrous for Donald Trump.” Noting that Biden, running as the Democratic incumbent, won 96 percent of the vote against an actively campaigning Democratic congressman and a best-selling author and 2020 presidential contender, O’Donnell said Saturday night, “That’s what you’re supposed to get, and Donald Trump’s not going to come close to that.”
O’Donnell is no fan of Trump. But no matter his political persuasion, his point is well-taken. As is his argument that “all you need is 5 percent of [Haley’s total]—we’re talking about a sliver—that’s all you need to not vote for Donald Trump in Michigan, in Pennsylvania, in Arizona, in Georgia,” in order for Biden to win those battleground states in November.
Trump can talk all he wants about a “unified” Republican Party. He’s wrong. It’s deeply divided, and Joe Biden’s reelection bid will benefit from that division.
Thank you for reading The Nation!
We hope you enjoyed the story you just read. It’s just one of many examples of incisive, deeply-reported journalism we publish—journalism that shifts the needle on important issues, uncovers malfeasance and corruption, and uplifts voices and perspectives that often go unheard in mainstream media. For nearly 160 years, The Nation has spoken truth to power and shone a light on issues that would otherwise be swept under the rug.
In a critical election year as well as a time of media austerity, independent journalism needs your continued support. The best way to do this is with a recurring donation. This month, we are asking readers like you who value truth and democracy to step up and support The Nation with a monthly contribution. We call these monthly donors Sustainers, a small but mighty group of supporters who ensure our team of writers, editors, and fact-checkers have the resources they need to report on breaking news, investigative feature stories that often take weeks or months to report, and much more.
There’s a lot to talk about in the coming months, from the presidential election and Supreme Court battles to the fight for bodily autonomy. We’ll cover all these issues and more, but this is only made possible with support from sustaining donors. Donate today—any amount you can spare each month is appreciated, even just the price of a cup of coffee.
The Nation does not bow to the interests of a corporate owner or advertisers—we answer only to readers like you who make our work possible. Set up a recurring donation today and ensure we can continue to hold the powerful accountable.
Thank you for your generosity.
More from The Nation
Republicans Are in Damage Control Mode Over Abortion Republicans Are in Damage Control Mode Over Abortion
Arizona’s 1864 abortion law has local party leaders flailing to avoid alienating voters.
Pecker Exposes Lengths Taken to Please Trump Pecker Exposes Lengths Taken to Please Trump
Testimony by the former National Enquirer publisher detailed the Trump campaign’s involvement in directing the tabloid's coverage of the 2016 election.
Summer Lee Proves That “Opposing Genocide Is Good Politics and Good Policy” Summer Lee Proves That “Opposing Genocide Is Good Politics and Good Policy”
Last week, the Pennsylvania representative voted against unconditional military aid for Israel. This week, she won what was supposed to be a tough primary by an overwhelming margi...
Without Expanded DACA Protections, Undocumented Students Are Being Left Behind Without Expanded DACA Protections, Undocumented Students Are Being Left Behind
Around 80 percent of the nearly 120,000 undocumented students who graduated high school in 2023 don’t qualify for DACA.
Here’s What a 21st-Century Rural New Deal Looks Like Here’s What a 21st-Century Rural New Deal Looks Like
A strategy for building a rural-urban working-class coalition.
The House Foreign Aid Bills Have Put a Target on Mike Johnson’s Back The House Foreign Aid Bills Have Put a Target on Mike Johnson’s Back
After a vote in favor of sending $95 billion to Ukraine, Israel, and Taiwan passed, far right Republicans are threatening a motion to vacate the speaker of the house.
