Politics / February 9, 2024

Biden Can No Longer Avoid Questions About His Fitness for a Second Term

A long-simmering debate has boiled to the surface with the special counsel’s report. How the president responds will determine whether he is reelected.

John Nichols
Joe Biden answers questions about Israel after speaking about the Special Counsel report in the Diplomatic Reception Room of the White House in Washington, DC, on February 8, 2024

Joe Biden speaking about the Special Counsel report in the Diplomatic Reception Room of the White House in Washington, D.C., on February 8, 2024.

(Mandel Ngan / AFP via Getty Images)

Joe Biden is furious at special counsel Robert Hur, and rightly so. In a gratuitous swipe at the president, Hur made an issue of the president’s age on Thursday when he issued a long-awaited report that, while it concluded that Biden should not face criminal charges for mishandling classified documents, still cast the president’s cognitive state in a brutal light.

Biden let that fury show in a combative nighttime press conference where, in a riff on the report’s most instantly notorious phrase, he declared, “I’m well-meaning and I’m an elderly man, and I know what the hell I’m doing.”

Feisty and pugnacious, Biden sparred with reporters who peppered him with unusually personal and aggressive questions. When Fox News reporter Peter Doocy, who often gives the president a hard time, asked, “How bad is your memory?” Biden shot back, “My memory is so bad I let you speak.”

The point of the press conference, which was hastily organized after the release of Hur’s report prompted an immediate frenzy of speculation about Biden’s age and mental fitness, was to shut down a snowballing debate about the president’s capacity to even seek—let alone serve—a second term.

Current Issue

Cover of May 2024 Issue

That didn’t happen. A long-simmering argument over the president’s abilities has boiled to the surface, shaking up a campaign that will only get more bitter and contentious as 2024 progresses. What transpired gives us a rough outline of what is to come, just as it leaves no doubt of what Biden must do if he hopes to win a second term.

Republicans were quick to dismiss the president as “weak and sad,” while the cadre of Democrats who have never been particularly enthusiastic about the president suggested that he step aside so that the party could make a late-stage substitution in a race that is already well underway. And the Democrats who expect Biden will be their candidate were fretting about the reality that, as veteran Democratic strategist David Axelrod explained immediately after the Thursday night press conference, “This is a stubborn problem for the campaign going forward.”

Axelrod’s right. This is a challenge the president and his team must rise to if they are going to prevail in 2024. How they do that will go a long way toward determining whether Biden, who remains the all-but-certain Democratic nominee, wins or loses in a November race against Donald Trump, who is equally certain to be his Republican rival—despite a burgeoning discussion, urged on by Nikki Haley, about the former president’s own “declining” mental fitness.

The Nation Weekly

Fridays. A weekly digest of the best of our coverage.
By signing up, you confirm that you are over the age of 16 and agree to receive occasional promotional offers for programs that support The Nation’s journalism. You may unsubscribe or adjust your preferences at any time. You can read our Privacy Policy here.

In reality, the debate about Biden’s age was a stubborn problem before Hur released the report, in which he wrote, “We conclude that no criminal charges are warranted in this matter,” but then damningly described the president as “a sympathetic, well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory” and asserted that, during interviews with the special counsel, Biden had failed to remember the dates of his tenure as vice president and, most painfully, couldn’t recall when his beloved son Beau had died. Biden pointedly, and at times emotionally, rejected Hur’s claims, but they reinforced an impression that has been a lingering challenge for the president.

In an NBC News poll released Tuesday, before Hur released the report, before Biden responded, and before media chaos ensued, 62 percent of Americans indicated that they had “major concerns” about “Joe Biden not having the necessary mental and physical health to be president for a second term.” Another 14 percent said they had minor concerns about whether the 81-year-old president is up to serving four more years. “By party,” NBC noted, “95 percent of Republican voters, 81 percent of independents and 54 percent of Democrats say they have major or moderate concerns about Biden’s fitness for a second term.”

That compared to 48 percent of Americans who said they had major or minor concerns about the prospect that 77-year-old Donald Trump might be too mentally or physically impaired to serve a second term. Notably, a lot more Americans, 71 percent, said they had concerns (61 percent major, 10 percent minor) about “Donald Trump facing four different criminal and civil trials for alleged wrongdoing, including multiple felony charges related to attempts to overturn the 2020 election.”

The Hur report turned the volume up on the age debate, leading Axelrod to say on Thursday evening, “This has become a real thing.”

How real remains to be seen. Republicans were immediately on the attack, with House Republican Conference chair Elise Stefanik (R-N.Y.) labeling Biden a “feeble” man who presided over a “horrific press conference” on Thursday night. Congressional Democrats rallied to the president’s defense, with US Representative Jamie Raskin (D-Md.) announcing, “I just spent an hour with President Biden where he regaled the entire Democratic caucus. All these age-based cheap shots at President Biden show you how desperate they are, while Donald Trump is fumbling around every day.”

Raskin’s response was on point. Hur, who served four years as the Trump-appointed United States Attorney for Maryland and was then named by Attorney General Merrick Garland to oversee the Justice Department’s inquiry into Biden’s handling of classified documents during his time as vice president, played a nasty political game with the report on the inquiry. In a letter to the special counsel, White House counsel Richard Sauber and Biden’s personal lawyer Robert Bauer ripped Hur’s report:

“We do not believe that the report’s treatment of President Biden’s memory is accurate or appropriate. The report uses highly prejudicial language to describe a commonplace occurrence among witnesses: a lack of recall of years-old events.

“Such comments have no place in a Department of Justice report, particularly one that in the first paragraph announces that no criminal charges are ‘warranted’ and that ‘the evidence does not establish Mr. Biden’s guilt.’”

All true.

But this particular debate won’t be resolved with sharp comments from Democratic pundits or letters from lawyers, especially when a special counsel that Biden’s own Justice Department chose—however unwisely—has opted to salt his report with destructive allegations about the president’s mental state. The only person who can assuage the public’s concern is Biden himself.

While there has been plenty of second-guessing about whether he should have faced the press on Thursday night, history will record that the president and his team made the right call. There is no time to waste if Biden wants to put this issue behind him, retain the nomination, and take the fight to Trump in what is sure to be a visceral fall race. The voters will decide whether the president is fit to be the Democratic nominee and to be the president, and Biden should write the narrative of the campaign now, rather than later.

If there were ever a chance that this election wouldn’t feature an open debate about Biden’s age, that prospect has been preempted. Biden can’t hide from this debate. He can’t avoid it. His only choice is to get in front of the American people as much as possible, with more press conferences, more speeches, and more meetings with voters on the campaign trail—telling them, as he did reporters on Thursday night, “My memory’s fine. Take a look at what I’ve done since I became president.” Then he can talk about his accomplishments, to the delight of Democrats and the frustration of Republicans.

“The more he’s out showcasing what he’s fighting for, what he’s achieved…the more they see his vigor and his passion for what he’s working on, the better,” says former Biden White House communications director Kate Bedingfield, who argues that the president must now “put himself out more, not less.”

Of course, Biden will stumble—as he did Thursday night, when, amid the rapid give-and-take with reporters, he referred to Egyptian leader Abdel Fattah El-Sisi as the “president of Mexico.”

But Biden has always been known for his gaffes. Historically, Americans have put his misstatements in perspective and, despite Republican efforts to paint him as inept, or worse, voters have trusted him—as they did in 2020. Biden’s job now, as he seeks a second term, is to be a fully present, fully engaged, and highly active candidate who is prepared to talk himself up and talk his scandal-plagued and 91-times indicted opponent down. That means less time in the White House and more time on the hustings. No avoidance. No excuses. If Joe Biden is going to be the Democratic nominee, and as such the last best alternative to Donald Trump, he owes his party and his country nothing less.

Thank you for reading The Nation!

We hope you enjoyed the story you just read, just one of the many incisive, deeply reported articles we publish daily. Now more than ever, we need fearless journalism that moves the needle on important issues, uncovers malfeasance and corruption, and uplifts voices and perspectives that often go unheard in mainstream media.

Donate right now and help us hold the powerful accountable, shine a light on issues that would otherwise be swept under the rug, and build a more just and equitable future.

For nearly 160 years, The Nation has stood for truth, justice, and moral clarity. As a reader-supported publication, we are not beholden to the whims of advertisers or a corporate owner. But it does take financial resources to report on stories that may take weeks or months to investigate, thoroughly edit and fact-check articles, and get our stories to readers like you.

Donate today and stand with us for a better future. Thank you for being a supporter of independent journalism.

Thank you for your generosity.

John Nichols

John Nichols is a national affairs correspondent for The Nation. He has written, cowritten, or edited over a dozen books on topics ranging from histories of American socialism and the Democratic Party to analyses of US and global media systems. His latest, cowritten with Senator Bernie Sanders, is the New York Times bestseller It's OK to Be Angry About Capitalism.

More from The Nation

President Joe Biden at a podium in front of a banner reading

Biden Touts His Student Debt Relief, but the Crisis Demands Much More Biden Touts His Student Debt Relief, but the Crisis Demands Much More

The president is canceling student loan debt in batches of thousands, but the need is in the millions. It’s costing him the voters he needs most.

Eleni Schirmer

Representative Thomas Massie (R-KY) speaks during a news conference with Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) outside the US Capitol on May 1, announcing that they will move forward on the motion to vacate Speaker Mike Johnson.

Meet the Kentucky Republican Who Beat AIPAC Meet the Kentucky Republican Who Beat AIPAC

So many Democrats are afraid to stand up to the powerful pro-Israel group. But a Republican congressman has done so, and he just scored a big primary win.

John Nichols

Supporters of former president Donald Trump watch as he holds a rally in the South Bronx on May 23, 2024, in New York City. The Bronx, home to a large Latino community, has been a Democratic base for generations of voters and the rally comes as Trump looks to attract more non-white voters.

Trump Takes the Bronx Trump Takes the Bronx

45 who wants to be 47 got what he came for.

D.D. Guttenplan

A worker hangs an election campaign billboard of the Likud party showing former US President Donald Trump, left, and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in Tel Aviv on September 8, 2019.

Will Vladimir Putin and Benjamin Netanyahu Bless Donald Trump With an October Surprise? Will Vladimir Putin and Benjamin Netanyahu Bless Donald Trump With an October Surprise?

Unlike Joe Biden, the former president benefits from international turmoil. 

Jeet Heer

House Campus Antisemitism Hearing

Inside the Latest Congressional Hearing on Campus Antisemitism Inside the Latest Congressional Hearing on Campus Antisemitism

Students for Justice in Palestine called the hearing “a manufactured attack on higher education” as Republicans criticized universities for negotiating with protesters.

StudentNation / Owen Dahlkamp

Former UN ambassador Nikki Haley announced that she would vote for former president Donald Trump during an event at the Hudson Institute on May 22, 2024 in Washington, D.C.

The Soulless Hypocrisy of Nikki Haley The Soulless Hypocrisy of Nikki Haley

Haley has abandoned her opposition to Trump for political expediency. Joe Biden should use Haley’s words against her—and Trump.

John Nichols