Shelf Life

Shelf Life

Ayana Mathis’s The Twelve Tribes of Hattie; Andrey Platonov’s Happy Moscow


In the first decades of the twentieth century, vast numbers of black Americans left the rural South and settled in the cities of the North. A response to the appalling racial violence and political repression that followed the collapse of Reconstruction governments, the Great Migration is one reason that Northern cities look the way they do today, and its social and cultural ramifications are the subject of Ayana Mathis’s beautiful debut novel, The Twelve Tribes of Hattie (Knopf; $24.95), which follows one black family through five and a half painful decades in Philadelphia.

The biblical note of the title is no accident, nor is it an accident that the novel ends in church with the Book of Job; this is a story of Old Testament brutality. Hattie comes to Philadelphia with her mother and sisters after her father is murdered by white men in Georgia, and although she is at first astonished to see that black people aren’t expected to step into the gutters when white people pass, the blessings of the North prove illusory, and soon God starts taking things away. Hattie loses her first two children to pneumonia. Her relationship with her husband is never the same afterward, but their attraction to each other is sufficient to produce many more children, all of them beset by calamity: Franklin is an alcoholic, Six is horribly burned in the bathtub, Cassie is mad, Bell tries to commit suicide by refusing treatment for tuberculosis, Billups is molested as a child, Alice’s wealthy husband gives her tranquilizers and keeps her shut up in the house.

Hattie keeps “them all alive with sheer will and collard greens and some old southern remedies.” But even though she bears a superficial resemblance to that tough black woman with the heart of gold who is so persistent an archetype in American culture, Hattie is surprisingly, unrelentingly mean. Mathis is intent on rendering the brutal truth behind the archetype, and her persistence makes the novel a marvelous work of art. As Hattie reflects at the end, her children “didn’t understand that all the love she had was taken up with feeding them and clothing them and preparing them to meet the world. The world would not love them; the world would not be kind.”

There is no excess of sentiment here, no sentimentality whatsoever. Hattie, degraded by circumstance, is not a person one longs to meet or emulate. But the paradox of this novel is the paradox of all the best sad stories: the details are hard, but the grace and elegance of Mathis’s writing lift the soul.

* * *

Andrey Platonov’s Happy Moscow (New York Review Books; Paper $14.95) is astonishingly chaotic. The language twitches and jerks and sickens itself like an addict in withdrawal. But Platonov’s characters, like Mathis’s, begin with utopian dreams; they too discover that the blessings of their new world—the Soviet Union in the mid-1930s—are illusory, and they too are degraded by circumstances beyond their control. When we meet Moscow Chestnova, who is named for her city and whose allegorical importance is plain, she’s in a fever of revolutionary energy—but then she loses her way, loses one of her legs, and subsides into listlessness and poverty.

Included with the title novella are two stories, a screenplay and a short essay. They are in themselves minor works, but they make it clear that Platonov probably did not intend the novella as a condemnation of the Soviet experiment, which is how American readers are likely to read it. Written in the 1930s, published in Russian only in 1991, and now available in English for the first time in a translation by Robert and Elizabeth Chandler and Nadya Bourova, Happy Moscow expresses an eerie ambivalence: the revolution was not a mistake, nor was it necessarily doomed, but Platonov could see that it had begun to slip its moorings and needed to be secured. As he writes in the essay, “man himself changes more slowly than he changes the world. This is the center of the tragedy. This is why we need creative engineers of human souls. They must prevent the danger of the human soul being left far behind by technology.”

The fanatical optimism of Platonov’s young revolutionaries breeds a kind of absent-mindedness—there’s the sense that they have all misplaced some crucial part of themselves—and as they set about constructing their workers’ paradise, they seem to forget that they’re building it for human beings. Like their city, like their nation, they are transfixed by visions of transformation. One scientist speaks wildly of “an altitude…where the light, temperature, and electromagnetic conditions were such that any living organism will neither tire nor die but be capable of eternal existence amid violet space.” Another believes there is a “mysterious sluice” in the human body from which a “special moisture” flows at the moment of death. He means to isolate this liquid and inject it into living people as an elixir of immortality. Later he withdraws some fluids from the body of a dead boy and injects them into Moscow herself.

Happy Moscow comprehends a vast 
territory—the story of Moscow Chestnova, the story of Moscow the city, the stories of functionaries and scientists—but at its heart is Platonov’s bizarre language. In its fusion of Soviet propaganda and nineteenth-century Romantic cliché, it tiptoes to the edge of nonsense. One has the unsettling feeling that the Stalinist terror begins here; as if it were first of all a matter of talking too much and too wildly, a matter of forgetting things. The chilling end of Moscow and her story is that there is no end at all. The novella forgets about her; she disappears from view.

In “Motives and Apprehensions" (Nov. 20),  Aaron Thier surveyed the fiction of Edward P. Jones.

Thank you for reading The Nation!

We hope you enjoyed the story you just read. It takes a dedicated team to publish timely, deeply researched pieces like this one. For over 150 years, The Nation has stood for truth, justice, and democracy. Today, in a time of media austerity, articles like the one you just read are vital ways to speak truth to power and cover issues that are often overlooked by the mainstream media.

This month, we are calling on those who value us to support our Spring Fundraising Campaign and make the work we do possible. The Nation is not beholden to advertisers or corporate owners—we answer only to you, our readers.

Can you help us reach our $20,000 goal this month? Donate today to ensure we can continue to publish journalism on the most important issues of the day, from climate change and abortion access to the Supreme Court and the peace movement. The Nation can help you make sense of this moment, and much more.

Thank you for being a supporter of independent journalism.

Ad Policy