Patriotic Dissent

Patriotic Dissent

It just got a little harder to ignore the dissenters in America’s War on Terrorism.


It just got a little harder to ignore the dissenters in America’s War on Terrorism.

Family members of victims, about seventeen so far, have joined under the banner “Sept. 11 Families for Peaceful Tomorrows” to encourage discussion of alternatives to war and to bring aid to families affected by the US bombing campaign in Afghanistan.

A smooth Valentine’s Day press conference in New York announcing the organization’s formation illustrated the group’s strengths and the challenges ahead. The packed room, at the Church Center for the United Nations, across from the UN, included several reporters. The event saw no ink in the next day’s papers–except in El Diario, a Spanish-language daily–but this group should have an edge over other antiwar activists in getting mainstream media attention. After all, they speak the same simple language of grief as the thousands of others who have lost loved ones in the attacks, and who have garnered ample coverage in both print and electronic media.

Even before they formally launched their joint effort, the members of Peaceful Tomorrows–called unexpectedly to this work from roles as varied as nurse practitioner, TV writer, retired small businesswoman and political science professor–have shown a knack for getting their message across. They’ve gotten local press in their hometowns, and several have written powerful essays that have circulated widely on the Internet. In perhaps their most compelling gesture so far, some even traveled to Afghanistan to meet with families devastated by the bombing. CNN covered their call for the US government to provide aid for the war victims they encountered on their trip, both people like themselves and grape farmers forced to abandon their land for fear of harvesting unexploded cluster bombs, as well as new Afghan widows who send their children to beg.

Peaceful Tomorrows wants the US government to appropriate $20 million–less, they say, than the cost of one day’s bombing, and far below the sum raised to help September 11 victims’ families–for a study of the bombing campaign’s impact on Afghan civilians and for a fund to to help the victims’ families.

They’ve met with receptive lawmakers like New York Senator Charles Schumer and Florida Representative Carrie Meeks, but they were advised that only President Bush could create the fund quickly. So the group sent Bush a giant Valentine requesting an audience.

Fortunately, the group members have compelling personal stories and areas of expertise well suited to the task at hand.

Robin Theurkauf, a mother of three boys who lost her husband, Tom, a financial analyst, at the World Trade Center, also happens to be a newly minted PhD and lecturer on international relations at Yale who wrote her dissertation on international criminal law.

“It’s a huge irony for me,” Theurkauf said. “My husband is the victim of [one of the] biggest crimes against humanity ever, and this is my field of interest.”

She considers the attack an international crime and believes military retaliation is only going to exacerbate US insecurity. “We’re making recruiting for the next wave of terrorists easier, I think,” Theurkauf said. She suggests that Americans press their government to recognize and participate in the new International Criminal Court, which it so far has refused to do.

And like the others in Peaceful Tomorrows–named for Martin Luther King Jr.’s quote, “Wars are poor chisels for carving out peaceful tomorrows”–she resents being invoked as an excuse for war. “It seemed like such a horrific thing, the idea that someone would do this for me to someone else.”

Peaceful Tomorrows is not yet funded, but three of the family members have already signed on as full-time regional coordinators. David Potorti, who will run the East Coast office, says their primary goal is to make Americans aware of their options.

“We just want to give the American people a dialogue that they’ve been denied in this rush to war,” said Potorti, a former writer of TV promotions whose brother, Jim, died at the Trade Center, “because we really haven’t had a chance to explore alternatives and other ways of speaking to each other aside from dropping bombs.”

Potorti has already found that people in unlikely places are ready to listen. Not too long after the attacks, he was a guest on The O’Reilly Factor, a right-wing talk show. As soon as Potorti hung up, he received two calls from men in nearby North Carolina towns. The first said he agreed with Potorti and could not, as a Christian, support the taking of innocent life. The second, who also lost a relative, said he disagreed with Potorti’s position but appreciated his standing up for his beliefs.

“Just the fact that two of those people [O’Reilly’s listeners] could be so reasonable and nice makes me feel that there’s hope,” Potorti said.

Dear reader,

I hope you enjoyed the article you just read. It’s just one of the many deeply reported and boundary-pushing stories we publish every day at The Nation. In a time of continued erosion of our fundamental rights and urgent global struggles for peace, independent journalism is now more vital than ever.

As a Nation reader, you are likely an engaged progressive who is passionate about bold ideas. I know I can count on you to help sustain our mission-driven journalism.

This month, we’re kicking off an ambitious Summer Fundraising Campaign with the goal of raising $15,000. With your support, we can continue to produce the hard-hitting journalism you rely on to cut through the noise of conservative, corporate media. Please, donate today.

A better world is out there—and we need your support to reach it.


Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editorial Director and Publisher, The Nation

Ad Policy