October 9, 2025

Reporting the Truth When Politicians Lie

With the global rise of organized misinformation campaigns, outlets should embrace “the truth sandwich” and place a false claim between the actual facts.

Mark Hertsgaard

President Donald Trump speaks during the United Nations General Assembly at the United Nations headquarters on September 23, 2025, in New York City.


(Michael M. Santiago / Getty Images

When President Donald Trump delivered a barrage of false statements about climate change during his September 23 speech to the UN General Assembly, he made headlines around the world. Mocking climate change as a “con job” promoted by “stupid people,” Trump’s remarks also illustrated a dilemma facing journalism’s traditional approach to covering politics, where not appearing to take sides has long been a cardinal rule. As more and more political leaders and movements mirror Trump’s habit of making factually inaccurate claims, a new report from the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism offers a fresh way to think about this dilemma, along with a host of practical tools for tackling it.

“Populist politicians are rewriting the rules, and we [journalists] keep giving them oxygen,” writes Michael Hauser Tov, a correspondent for the Israeli newspaper Haaretz, in the report, called “Reporting populism: the harm-reduction playbook.” Parker Molloy, an American journalist whose Substack The Present Age covered the report shortly after its release, praised Tov for recognizing that “the normal rules of political coverage don’t work anymore. Ignoring provocative statements lets them spread unchecked. Covering them neutrally amplifies them and creates a false sense of legitimate debate.”

Some of the coverage of Trump’s UN speech had exactly the latter effect. In a nine-minute video package, the BBC did not include a sentence correcting Trump’s climate inaccuracies. The broadcaster’s only hint about the overwhelming scientific consensus on climate change and its devastating impacts on people and economies was to note that Trump’s remark was “met with gasps across the assembly floor.”

The Associated Press and The New York Times, however, avoided such pitfalls. Both news organizations employed a journalistic technique known as “a truth sandwich.” A concept developed by the linguist George Lakoff and backed by media critics including Margaret Sullivan and Brian Stelter, a truth sandwich starts by stating the factual truth, then reports the false claim, then restates what’s true. The AP story began by reporting that some of the world leaders gathered at the UN “are watching their citizens die in floods, hurricanes and heat waves, all exacerbated by climate change.” Trump’s remarks “didn’t match” that reality, the AP continued, “nor did it align with what scientists have long been observing.” AP’s story did quote Trump at length, but it put his statements in context, citing data and quoting experts making it clear that Trump, knowingly or not, was spreading misinformation.

The Reuters playbook endorses the same approach, but uses a different term for it, FWEF, which stands for: “State the Fact. Warn the audience they’re about to hear a lie. Explain how the lie misleads. Restate the Fact.” Adopting this approach won’t “cost money, needn’t hurt ratings…and is something newsrooms can start doing tomorrow,” Tov writes. The same holds for other techniques Tov’s report recommends, including one he applies to Brexit coverage but that also addresses a long-standing shortcoming in climate reporting: “Avoid false balance. If you platform two sides, show the real distribution of expertise or public support (e.g., ‘60 economists against, one for’).”

Perhaps anticipating concerns from some fellow journalists, Tov emphasizes that his reforms are “not about abandoning objectivity.” But objectivity, he argues, “is a tool, not the goal.” The global rise of politicians and movements that routinely lie, mislead, or otherwise try to misinform the public calls for “reinterpreting” objectivity, he writes, so “it aligns with other journalistic values that are no less important—foremost among them, providing the audience with the truth, and only the truth.”

Mark Hertsgaard

Mark Hertsgaard is the author of eight books that have been translated into a total of 16 languages, including Big Red’s Mercy: The Shooting of Deborah Cotton and a Story of Race in America and A Day In the Life: The Music and Artistry of the Beatles. He is executive director of the global journalism collaboration Covering Climate Now and the environment correspondent for The Nation.

More from Mark Hertsgaard Mark Hertsgaard Illustration

President Donald Trump stands alongside Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Dan Caine at an April press conference on the Iran War.

Trump Is Making Deals With Big Oil Trump Is Making Deals With Big Oil

Democrats and the press should be paying attention to how this pay-to-play behavior relates to the midterms

Mark Hertsgaard

Hundreds of climate activists take part in a protest in the run up to the German elections in Bonn, Germany, on February 14, 2025.

Germany and California Make Up an Environmental Superpower Germany and California Make Up an Environmental Superpower

The world’s third- and fourth-largest economies have pledged to environmental protections. Will others follow suit?

Mark Hertsgaard

California Governor Gavin Newsom speaks alongside German Federal Minister for the Environment, Climate Action, Nature Conservation, and Nuclear Safety Carsten Schneider during a press briefing following a meeting on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly at the United Nations on September 22, 2026.

Gavin Newsom Comments on Climate Gavin Newsom Comments on Climate

On the sidelines of the UN General Assembly meeting and New York Climate Week, the California governor called AOC “the real damn deal.”

Mark Hertsgaard

Big Oil’s Origin Story

Big Oil’s Origin Story Big Oil’s Origin Story

Amy Westervelt’s new book, Brought to You By, exposes the deep history of today’s “information pollution.”

Mark Hertsgaard

A shelf of Oatly drinks in a London supermarket.

Oatly Says Climate Action Now Oatly Says Climate Action Now

The world’s largest oat drink company is printing summaries of what it calls “the ultimate climate solution” on every carton it produces.

Mark Hertsgaard

A patient rests in a corridor waiting for a room at Providence Cedars–Sinai Tarzana Medical Center in California on January 3, 2021.

Have We Forgotten Covid’s Lessons? Have We Forgotten Covid’s Lessons?

This summer’s deadly heat calls for news coverage based on science, not ideology.

Mark Hertsgaard