Activism / StudentNation / July 31, 2023

Ohio Republicans Want to Rewrite the Rules to Thwart Abortion and LGBTQ Rights

Conservative interest groups are pushing Issue 1, which would require a supermajority for any petition-based constitutional amendments to pass.

Zurie Pope
Ohio August Special Election Issue 1

A Republican candidate for US Senate in Ohio wearing a voting sticker.

(Drew Angerer / Getty Image)

Once synonymous with Midwestern placidity, Ohio has become the epicenter of an unprecedented assault on civil and reproductive rights. Bills banning gender affirming care for LGBTQ youth and trans athletes from participation in women’s sports have been introduced in the statehouse, and House Bill 245 would prohibit drag performances from being held in public.

Now, Republicans in the state are attempting to thwart voters’ ability to amend Ohio’s Constitution. A ballot measure in the August special election could impede a proposed amendment to preserve abortion rights by requiring petition-based amendments to pass with 60 percent of the vote, rather than a simple majority. The proposed measure is “abandoning a fundamental policy that has been part of the Ohio Constitution since 1912,” said Steven H. Steinglass, an expert in Ohio constitutional history. If the measure is approved, it will make passing the abortion rights amendment, introduced by Ohioans for Reproductive Freedom and Ohio Physicians for Reproductive Rights, much more difficult. “These politicians know that their radical views on abortion care can’t win a fair vote, so they’re rigging the system,” said Ohioans for Reproductive Freedom.

These initiatives have been primarily driven by conservative interest groups, with the Ohio-based Christian advocacy organization the Center for Christian Virtue playing an outsize role in shaping Republican policy. Right-wing billionaire Richard Ulhein has spent millions funding the “Save Our Constitution PAC,” which advocates for the ballot measure known as Issue 1. “Our Constitution has been hijacked by special interests and legislators have an opportunity—and duty—to stop it by voting to put the Constitution Protection Amendment on the August ballot,” reads the PAC’s website. Meanwhile, groups like Protect Women Ohio have attempted to connect abortion and trans rights with misleading ads. “If passed, this dangerous initiative would abolish parental notification and consent requirements which protect minor girls from undergoing an abortion or even sex change surgery without her parents’ knowledge or involvement.”

“It’s a horrible case study of how lawlessness builds on lawlessness,” said David Pepper, author of Laboratories of Autocracy and former chairman of the Ohio Democratic Party. As the right entrenches itself in the state, Ohioans have started creating support networks to protect themselves. The Ohio Student Activist Alliance was formed during the amendment debate to “talk to young people and raise awareness about harmful legislation like the gender affirming care ban or the don’t say gay bill,” according to Garrison Bowling, a cofounder. OSAA’s members also submitted testimony in opposition to House Bill 68, which would ban gender affirming care and limit access to puberty blockers.

For Bowling, the attack against the LGBTQ community is personal. Bowling is a gay man and works as a crisis counselor for the Trevor Project. He knows that anti-LGBTQ legislation has a dire impact on queer youth. “I don’t think a lot of people realize how difficult it is to live in a state where the government is trying to outlaw your existence,” said Bowling. According to the Trevor Project, 46 percent of LGBTQ youth and 54 percent of trans youth in Ohio seriously considered suicide in the past year. “Let’s be clear—HB 68 is extreme government overreach and state-sponsored bullying of trans and gender non-conforming Ohioans,” said the American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio.

Bowling wants to motivate young people in Ohio to oppose these far-right attacks. “Ohio has had a youth political gap for years,” Bowling explained. “We are far behind when it comes to youth organizing.” Referencing statewide walkouts in Florida against Governor Ron DeSantis, Bowling said he hopes to build a similar mass movement. The turnout in Ohio for last August’s primary was under 8 percent, but the secretary of state’s office has said that early voting numbers from this year already reflect a nearly fivefold increase. “Ohio deserves better than our current leadership, and it’s time for young people to start fighting back and empowering ourselves,” said Bowling.

Arienne Childrey shares Bowling’s mission of fighting for Ohio’s queer citizenry. A trans woman, Childrey spent her early life in the closet. “For 34 years, I was miserable,” Childrey admitted. “I was active in church, trying to make this secret part of me disappear.” Then, at 34, Childrey came out. Though she lost relatives and colleagues, Childrey said “I haven’t regretted it since.” Childrey now runs Northwest Ohio Trans Advocacy, advocating for “trans rights through allyship, activism and education.”

Childrey, who calls HB 68 “disastrous,” began her career in the local Democratic Party, but left after learning the “vast difference between politics and activism.” Childrey hopes the renewed outrage against LGBTQ people will lead to a new, more militant age of queer activism, hearkening back to Stonewall as a source of inspiration. “I’m not going to play nice with people who want me dead.”

Dr. Anita Somani is an ob-gyn and cochair of the Physician Action Network. The network is a coalition of physicians and medical students who support reproductive rights and gender affirming care for their patients. Though the network was founded in 2017, “access to health care is no better, maybe a little worse than it was,” according to Somani. In some rural areas they’ve “closed practices, denied access to those services.”

Even if these restrictions pass, Somani believes her colleagues will find ways to support their patients. “The people I know who are providing this care will do the best they can to provide the wrap-around care that is permitted,” said Somani.

The Nation Weekly

Fridays. A weekly digest of the best of our coverage.
By signing up, you confirm that you are over the age of 16 and agree to receive occasional promotional offers for programs that support The Nation’s journalism. You may unsubscribe or adjust your preferences at any time. You can read our Privacy Policy here.

Despite the preponderance of anti-abortion and anti-trans bills, the demonization isn’t actually popular with Ohio voters. As the August election approaches, it’s clear that Republicans’ plans could backfire. According to a Marist Poll from March, 54 percent of American voters oppose criminalizing gender affirming care for minors, while 58 percent reject drag show restrictions. In Ohio specifically, Suffolk University interviewed 500 voters, and found that 57 percent disagreed with Issue 1. A majority of Ohio voters also support enshrining abortion rights into the state Constitution, according to a poll from Baldwin Wallace University. Turnout this year will be significant. “More than 155,000 Ohioans have already voted in the August 8 special election, with less than three weeks remaining until Election Day,” said Frank LaRose, Ohio secretary of state. 

“All of the scientific evidence shows that gender-affirming care is life-affirming care,” said Bowling. Even if the anti-LGBTQ bills pass, Bowling was adamant that his organization will “continue to raise awareness about these issues and give a voice to LGBT youth across Ohio.” The alliance has started confronting lawmakers, asking them about policies and posting the interactions on social media. “They don’t like us very much,” said Bowling, “and that’s a fact we’re very proud of.”

Zurie Pope

Zurie Pope is a sophomore at the University of Cincinnati, pursuing a bachelor's degree in journalism. His work has appeared in Youth Journalism International, Unpublished Magazine, and The News Record, the University of Cincinnati’s student newspaper.

More from The Nation

Joe Biden addresses striking members of the United Auto Workers (UAW) union at a picket line outside a General Motors Service Parts Operations plant in Belleville, Michigan, on September 26, 2023.

My President Joined a Picket Line My President Joined a Picket Line

No matter what you think of Joe Biden, his decision to stand with UAW workers is historic. And it might just get him reelected.

John Nichols

Donald Trump poses for a picture at a South Carolina gun store.

The Supreme Court Could Soon Let Trump Buy All the Guns He Wants The Supreme Court Could Soon Let Trump Buy All the Guns He Wants

Trump is currently prohibited from buying guns because he’s under criminal indictment. But two big court cases could change that.

Elie Mystal

A Federal Judge Declares DACA Illegal Again

A Federal Judge Declares DACA Illegal Again A Federal Judge Declares DACA Illegal Again

Deferred action for childhood arrivals. The fate of hundreds of thousands of immigrants is caught in an endless court fight (DACA recipients in the program will continue to have so...

OppArt / Felipe Galindo

Trump on his phone

Donald Trump Calls Reporting the News a Capital Offense Donald Trump Calls Reporting the News a Capital Offense

In recent social media posts, he accused both a cable TV network and a serving military general of treason.

Chris Lehmann

JD Vance, a Republican from Ohio, during the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) in National Harbor, Maryland, US, on Thursday, March 2, 2023.

How J.D. Vance’s Bad Tweets Explain Modern Conservatism How J.D. Vance’s Bad Tweets Explain Modern Conservatism

His very cringe posts contain everything you need to know about the hate-filled emptiness at the heart of the supposed “intellectual” wing of the GOP.

Ginny Hogan

An image of President Donald Trump looms over crowds of supporters before his speech from the Ellipse at the White House on Wednesday, January 6, 2021.

Will the UAW Picket Trump’s Rally in Detroit? Will the UAW Picket Trump’s Rally in Detroit?

Trump’s speeches are terrifying echoes of those heard in Europe in the 1930s. They are appeals to labor by a candidate supported by heavily armed, fascist political formations.

Dave Zirin