Freedom of Speech for Students?

Freedom of Speech for Students?

Philadelphia court asked to decide if schools can punish students for derisive online communications from home computers.

Copy Link
Facebook
X (Twitter)
Bluesky
Pocket
Email

Interesting story from AP recently regarding the question of whether public school officials can discipline students for posting lewd, harassing or juvenile comments from off-campus computers.

A US appeals court heard arguments last Thursday in Philadelphia, where two students from two different Pennsylvania school districts are fighting suspensions they received for posting derisive profiles of their principals on MySpace from home computers.

The American Civil Liberties Union joined the case and argued that school officials infringe on student’s free speech rights when they reach beyond school grounds in such cases to impose discipline.

A lawyer for the Hermitage School District in western Pennsylvania, though, offered a different view. "It’s not a matter of where you throw the grenade, it’s where the grenade lands," Anthony Sanchez said.

As MaryClaire Dale reported for AP, legal experts hope the Supreme Court will soon clarify the limits of school discipline for online speech that is posted offsite.

What do you think? Let us know in the comments field below.

Don’t let JD Vance silence our independent journalism

On September 15, Vice President JD Vance attacked The Nation while hosting The Charlie Kirk Show.

In a clip seen millions of times, Vance singled out The Nation in a dog whistle to his far-right followers. Predictably, a torrent of abuse followed.

Throughout our 160 years of publishing fierce, independent journalism, we’ve operated with the belief that dissent is the highest form of patriotism. We’ve been criticized by both Democratic and Republican officeholders—and we’re pleased that the White House is reading The Nation. As long as Vance is free to criticize us and we are free to criticize him, the American experiment will continue as it should.

To correct the record on Vance’s false claims about the source of our funding: The Nation is proudly reader-supported by progressives like you who support independent journalism and won’t be intimidated by those in power.

Vance and Trump administration officials also laid out their plans for widespread repression against progressive groups. Instead of calling for national healing, the administration is using Kirk’s death as pretext for a concerted attack on Trump’s enemies on the left.

Now we know The Nation is front and center on their minds.

Your support today will make our critical work possible in the months and years ahead. If you believe in the First Amendment right to maintain a free and independent press, please donate today.

With gratitude,

Bhaskar Sunkara
President, The Nation

Ad Policy
x