Black Votes Matter in Ferguson

Black Votes Matter in Ferguson

A federal trial challenging the city’s discriminatory election system begins today.

Copy Link
Facebook
X (Twitter)
Bluesky
Pocket
Email

At the time of Mike Brown’s shooting in Ferguson, Missouri, the city was two-thirds African-American, yet its mayor, city manager, five of six city council members, police chief and 50 of its 53 police officers were white.

In the wake of the Black Lives Matter protests, two black candidates were elected to the Ferguson City Council in April 2015, but African-Americans still have very little political power in the area.

For example, nearly 80 percent of the 12,000 students in the Ferguson-Florissant School District are black, but the seven-member school board includes only two African-American members. In 2013, the district’s first African-American superintendent was forced out by the board.

There are many reasons for black political underrepresentation in Ferguson: a long history of discrimination, segregation, poverty, economic disinvestment, low voter turnout and police harassment, as detailed by the Department of Justice.

The structure of Ferguson’s political institutions also contributes to the scarcity of black elected officials. The school board elects candidates on a district-wide basis, rather than from specific district—known as “at-large elections”—and because the district’s voting age population is 50 percent white and 47 black, with whites usually refusing to vote for a black candidate, the white majority is virtually assured of determining the winner.

The ACLU and Missouri NAACP have filed suit against the school board for violating Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act (VRA), calling for the creation of new political districts that will give African-American candidates a much better opportunity to be elected. The federal trial begins in St. Louis today.

“Under the current electoral system, [African-Americans] are systematically unable to elect candidates of their choice and are all but locked out of the political process,” the lawsuit contends.

The lawsuit details:

From 2011 to 2015, 13 Black candidates ran for Board seats, but only two (15.4%) were successful. During that period, 16 white candidates ran for Board seats, and ten (62.5%) were successful. There were no African-Americans elected to the Board in 2011, 2012, or 2013.

“There was all this coverage after Mike Brown’s shooting of why you had a majority black population but an all-white power structure,” says Dale Ho, director of the ACLU’s Voting Rights Project. “The lack of political representation perpetuates racial inequality.”

Ferguson is not an isolated case. At-large elections were adopted or maintained in many places to limit minority political power after passage of the VRA in 1965, as I reported in my book Give Us the Ballot:

At-large elections were the primary impediment to black representation nationwide, especially across the South. In 1978, the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights surveyed twenty-nine municipalities in the South that had black majorities and populations of more than twenty-five hundred but no black elected officials. Seventy-five percent of them used at-large elections. “At-large election systems appear to have a severe negative effect,” the commission found, “and they are extensively used.”

When jurisdictions switched from at-large to district elections, minority representation increased dramatically. “In Texas during the period 1970 to 1978, 29 at-large or multimember systems were changed voluntarily or through litigation to single-member districts or mixed plans,” reported the commission. “Immediately prior to these changes, the 29 systems elected 9 blacks and 8 Hispanics to office. Immediately after the respective changes, 26 blacks and 24 Hispanics were elected.”

This fight continues today. Pasadena, Texas, recently adopted at-large elections to limit Latino political power after the Supreme Court gutted the VRA. And when Yakima, Washington, switched from at-large to district elections after being sued by the ACLU, three Latinas were elected for the first time in the city’s history in November.

There’s been a vigorous debate among Black Lives Matter activists about the power of the vote. Certainly the ballot does not solve everything, but it is a prerequisite for social change. Ferguson shows what happens when voting rights are systematically limited.

Ad Policy
x