Why I’m Suing the New York State Democratic Party for Interfering in Its Own Primary

Why I’m Suing the New York State Democratic Party for Interfering in Its Own Primary

Why I’m Suing the New York State Democratic Party for Interfering in Its Own Primary

Under the direction of Andrew Cuomo, the party has spent a small fortune supporting my opponent’s campaign.

Copy Link
Facebook
X (Twitter)
Bluesky
Pocket
Email

I’m a Democrat, and this year I decided to run in the primary for lieutenant governor. My opponent, former Representative Kathy Hochul, is also a Democrat, but we differ on policy, particularly in areas like immigration policy, environmental protection and gun rights.

So far so good, but here’s the crazy part. The state Democratic Party that is running the primary (ostensibly to select the best candidate) is spending money—millions, by our estimates—to try to ensure that my opponent wins. Under the admitted direction of Governor Andrew Cuomo, New York’s Democratic Party has spent a small fortune supporting my opponent’s campaign, including spending on literature for voters, phonebanking, television ads and, most recently, robocalls performed by Hillary Clinton.

It is an obvious conflict of interest for the party to both run a primary and then provide aid to one side. That’s why, back in 1911, the New York legislature made it illegal for political parties to spend money to influence the outcomes of their own primaries. Yet despite the illegality and ethical question, the Democratic Party in New York State keeps at it.

My running mate Zephyr Teachout and I challenged the party’s illegal spending in court. Lawyers for Andrew Cuomo and the party have responded that their actions are protected by the First Amendment, based on a Citizens United theory. So even though the Democratic Party is running the primary, Cuomo’s lawyers maintain that the party retains a constitutional right to try to ensure that the Governor’s favorites will win it. As of this writing the case is pending—unfortunately, it will likely not get decided before the primary election.

But the party’s lawyers have overstated their case, for the First Amendment does not so clearly support such monkey business. Citizens United was about independent spending; here the relevant rule is from Buckley v. Valeo, the 1976 Supreme Court case, which ruled that coordinated expenditures have only limited First Amendment protection. In New York, the only state case to decide on the constitutionality of the rule has upheld the legislature’s long-standing ban on directed party involvement in its own primary.

Leaving the Constitution aside, it is also simply wrong for the party to both run a primary and spend money trying to make sure one side wins. Parties are free, of course, not to have a primary at all. But the very reason to have a primary is to try to make sure that the candidates really have the support of the voters. To promise the voters a democratic process, and then tilt the playing field, is ultimately a corruption of the democratic process.

Become a Sustaining Donor This September

Between the reemergence of right-wing red-baiting and Donald Trump’s use of the chilling National Security Presidential Memorandum–7 to criminalize left political organizing, we’re seeing McCarthyism reborn before our eyes.

This assault on democracy cannot be ignored or wished away. Resisting it requires bravery in the face of threats and repression, a steadfast commitment to the truth, and the unwavering belief that we can—and will—overcome this darkness.

We must have an independent media that sets the record straight, unearths corruption and abuses of power, and advances a politics of justice and dignity for all if we’re to win this fight.

That’s why I’m writing to you today. This September, The Nation needs to add 100 monthly donors to sustain our progressive journalism. Your contribution makes the next investigative report, the next truth-speaking column, and the next pathbreaking essay all possible. 

I hope you’ll support our work with a recurring donation today. If you donate $10 or more a month, we’ll send you a brand new “Hands Off the Free Press!” sticker to recognise your commitment to our cause. Please, donate today. 

Onward,

Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editor and Publisher, The Nation

Ad Policy
x