A Raid on the First Amendment: New York’s Assault on Press Freedom

A Raid on the First Amendment: New York’s Assault on Press Freedom

A Raid on the First Amendment: New York’s Assault on Press Freedom

Reporters covering the eviction of Occupy Wall Street were arrested and restrained from doing their jobs.

Copy Link
Facebook
X (Twitter)
Bluesky
Pocket
Email

The dark-of-night raid on New York City’s Zuccotti Park was not merely an assault on the Occupy Wall Street movement. It was an assault on the underpinnings of the First Amendment to the Constitution, an amendment that was outlined and approved by the First Congress of the United States at No. 26 Wall Street in 1789.

That amendment, which was written to empower citizens to challenge and prevent the rise of a totalitarian state, recognized basic freedoms that were essential to the defense of liberty. Among these are, of course, the right to speak freely and to embrace the religious ideals of one’s choice.

But from a standpoint of pushing back against power, however, the rights to assemble and to petition for the redress of grievances are fundamental. And those rights were clearly assaulted early Tuesday morning.

So, too, was another right: the right to a free press.

Why does the right to a free press matter so much? Because, as the founders knew, no experiment in democracy could ever be anything more than that—an experiment—if the people don’t know what is being done in their name by those in positions of authority. “A popular Government without popular information or the means of acquiring it,” observed James Madison, “is but a Prologue to a Farce or a Tragedy or perhaps both.”

Nothing is more necessary in a democracy than the informing of the people, not merely to assure that they can influence the direction of government but also to assure that government does not become a threat to their livelihoods, their rights, their freedoms. The playwright Tom Stoppard captured the reality of why a free press is so very necessary in his 1978 play, “Night and Day,” where a veteran journalist explained that “people do awful things to each other. But it’s worse in places where everybody is kept in the dark.”

When New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg ordered the dark-of-night clearance of Zuccotti Park, and police authorities barred journalists from the scene early Tuesday, the people were kept in the dark. Helicopters for television stations were grounded, most reporters were kept far from the scene in a “press pen,” a reporter for the New York Post and others who got close enough to the park to see what was happening were roughed up, and several journalists—included reporters for the New York Daily News, Associated Press and National Public Radio—were detained and arrested.

Congressman Jerrold Nadler, who represents much of Lower Manhattan and who is the senior Democrat on the Subcommittee on the Constitution of the House Judiciary Committee, said in a statement issued with state Senator Daniel Squadron, another Manhattan Democrat, that warned: “The City’s actions to shut down OWS last night raise a number of serious civil liberties questions that must be answered.  Moving forward, how will the City respect the protesters’ rights to speech and assembly? Why was press access limited, and why were some reporters’ credentials confiscated? How will reported incidents of excessive force used by the police be addressed?”

As lawyers for the movement pressed for injunctions against the city, Nadler and Squadron argued that: “Whatever the courts rule, the City’s actions here must not be a backdoor means of ending the free exercise of protesters’ rights.”

Responding to concerns about the battering that the Constitution has taken at “Occupy” protests around the country, the union that represents journalists, the Newspaper Guild, has launched an “Occupied Journalists” Facebook page. Designed to serve as an online forum for media workers to share survival strategies and anecdotes from the streets, the page was started when Guild-CWA organizer Sara Steffens says the union “started hearing a lot of reports from all over the country from journalists running into trouble covering the protests.”

Unions and press freedom groups need to step up, as do elected officials who swear oaths to defend the Constitution against all enemies “foreign and domestic.”

Referring to the clearing of the treatment of protesters and journalists in New York, Nadler and Squadron said: “Irrespective of this incident, OWS is now bigger than Zuccotti Park, and no one has the power to silence this national movement.”

Let’s hope they are right and that the people are no longer “kept in the dark” by officials who want the freedom to operate without the oversight and accountability that a free press must provide.

Become a Sustaining Donor This September

Between the reemergence of right-wing red-baiting and Donald Trump’s use of the chilling National Security Presidential Memorandum–7 to criminalize left political organizing, we’re seeing McCarthyism reborn before our eyes.

This assault on democracy cannot be ignored or wished away. Resisting it requires bravery in the face of threats and repression, a steadfast commitment to the truth, and the unwavering belief that we can—and will—overcome this darkness.

We must have an independent media that sets the record straight, unearths corruption and abuses of power, and advances a politics of justice and dignity for all if we’re to win this fight.

That’s why I’m writing to you today. This September, The Nation needs to add 100 monthly donors to sustain our progressive journalism. Your contribution makes the next investigative report, the next truth-speaking column, and the next pathbreaking essay all possible. 

I hope you’ll support our work with a recurring donation today. If you donate $10 or more a month, we’ll send you a brand new “Hands Off the Free Press!” sticker to recognise your commitment to our cause. Please, donate today. 

Onward,

Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editor and Publisher, The Nation

Ad Policy
x