Toggle Menu

We Can Defeat Trump’s Lawlessness. We’ve Done It Before.

Donald Trump’s intimidation tactics are not new. At the height of the civil rights movement, segregationists harassed our civil rights lawyers.

Janai Nelson

April 17, 2025

People take part in a massive anti-Trump “Hands Off” protest and march in New York City, New York, April 5, 2025.(Mostafa Bassim / Anadolu via Getty Images)

Bluesky

In our collective imagination, there’s a common nightmare about how democracies fall. Tanks rolling in. War breaking out. Blood spilled.

But history tells a different story—less dramatic, but no less devastating. Most democracies don’t die by gunfire. They die gradually. Quietly. Passively. A right revoked. A freedom restricted. A norm shattered. A collective silence. Before long, you look around and realize that the scaffolding of democracy has been dismantled in plain sight.

It’s why the rule of law must be protected at all costs. Encroachments on it are not mere policy disputes. They are the canaries in the coal mine. And today, those canaries are gasping for air.

Since returning to the White House less than three months ago, Donald Trump has trampled constitutional norms, civil rights, and the rule of law. He’s ordered the arrest of peaceful protesters, gutted LGBTQ+ protections, undermined voting rights, deported lawful residents, fomented the unbridled hate that fuels antisemitism, and resurrected a level of anti-Black racism not seen in the modern era. The proverbial tanks are here—but instead of carrying rifles and soldiers, they’re armed with executive orders, presidential fiats, and white nationalist codespeak.

Current Issue

View our current issue

Subscribe today and Save up to $129.

One of the most alarming instances of Trump’s disregard for the rule of law came last month in a series of executive actions naming and punishing various law firms and attorneys that have represented clients whom the president perceives to be political enemies. On March 6, Trump targeted Perkins Coie for representing his political rivals during the 2016 election and allegedly unlawful diversity, equity, and inclusion practices. On March 25, he targeted Jenner & Block for its past employment of a prosecutor who was involved in special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation into Trump for election interference. Two days later, on March 27, he targeted Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr for its past employment of Mueller himself. And on March 23, Trump issued a broader memorandum directing the Justice Department—in theory an impartial arbiter of the law, but under this administration a tool for implementing the president’s vendettas —to seek sanctions against attorneys or firms that challenge him in court with purported “frivolous” claims despite his steady record of court losses.

These are not policy disagreements or differences of opinion; they are direct assaults on the independence of the legal profession. And, to paraphrase US District Judge Beryl Howell in describing the executive order punishing Perkins Coie, the scope and scale of the attacks on the legal profession should send chills down every American’s spine.

At the Legal Defense Fund, we know this tactic better than any other legal organization in the country, sadly—we’ve lived it before. At the height of the civil rights movement, segregationists across the South weaponized state power to harass and intimidate our civil rights lawyers in an effort to prevent us from engaging in advocacy. Alabama demanded that the NAACP, of which we were a part until 1957, disclose its membership lists. Texas falsely accused and sued the NAACP and LDF over a “medley of charges,” including allegedly generating profit while claiming nonprofit status. Georgia tax authorities jailed the NAACP’s Atlanta chapter president. And Arkansas dissolved the state NAACP by executive order.

Then, as now, the goal was simple: Destroy the lawyers and you weaken the prospect of opposition. Thankfully, that is not how the story ended then, and it is not how it is destined to end now. We, the American people, have the wherewithal to chart a different course.

The president’s actions aren’t just authoritarian; they’re also deeply un-American. They threaten the constitutional principle that every individual and institution deserves legal representation, and that lawyers must be free to do their jobs without fear of reprisal. That principle is foundational—not just to our profession, but to American democracy.

That’s why LDF filed an amicus brief last week in Perkins Coie LLP v. U.S. Department of Justice, as well as on behalf of law firms Wilmer Hale and Jenner & Block, urging the court to reject this blatant abuse of executive power. If lawyers are forced to choose their clients based on fear of retaliation, the rule of law and the constitutional order it undergirds will crumble. And without an independent bar and judiciary, there will be no check on Trump’s lawlessness.

The Nation Weekly
Fridays. A weekly digest of the best of our coverage.
By signing up, you confirm that you are over the age of 16 and agree to receive occasional promotional offers for programs that support The Nation’s journalism. You may unsubscribe or adjust your preferences at any time. You can read our Privacy Policy here.

Indeed, we are seeing only the beginning of Trump’s radical agenda, including these intimidation tactics and the normalization of ideas once considered unthinkable. In recent weeks, after sending hundreds of migrants the administration has deemed violent gang members to El Salvador’s Terrorism Confinement Center, without providing evidence of such membership (beyond wrongly identified tattoos), President Trump casually and repeatedly floated the idea of exiling American inmates to the notorious maximum security prison. This notion—what would be a massive violation of the civil and human rights and civil liberties of American citizens—is among the most atrocious threats Trump has issued. He won’t stop there.

An urgent message from the Editors

As the editors of The Nation, it’s not usually our role to fundraise. Today, however, we’re putting out a special appeal to our readers, because there are only hours left in 2025 and we’re still $20,000 away from our goal of $75,000. We need you to help close this gap. 

Your gift to The Nation directly supports the rigorous, confrontational, and truly independent journalism that our country desperately needs in these dark times.

2025 was a terrible year for press freedom in the United States. Trump launched personal attack after personal attack against journalists, newspapers, and broadcasters across the country, including multiple billion-dollar lawsuits. The White House even created a government website to name and shame outlets that report on the administration with anti-Trump bias—an exercise in pure intimidation.

The Nation will never give in to these threats and will never be silenced. In fact, we’re ramping up for a year of even more urgent and powerful dissent. 

With the 2026 elections on the horizon, and knowing Trump’s history of false claims of fraud when he loses, we’re going to be working overtime with writers like Elie Mystal, John Nichols, Joan Walsh, Jeet Heer, Kali Holloway, Katha Pollitt, and Chris Lehmann to cut through the right’s spin, lies, and cover-ups as the year develops.

If you donate before midnight, your gift will be matched dollar for dollar by a generous donor. We hope you’ll make our work possible with a donation. Please, don’t wait any longer.

In solidarity,

The Nation Editors

So where do we go from here?

Defend. Disrupt. Dream. That is LDF’s prescription.

We must defend the rule of law. Defending against autocracy—whether foreign or domestic—is central to the history of this country. Defense is itself both a demonstration of strength and norms and a testament to the enduring power of the rule of law and fairness, even under relentless attacks.

Second, we must disrupt the machinery of authoritarianism. That means challenging illegal executive actions, using every procedural, technical, and structural lever within the bounds of the law. It’s why LDF is standing with and supporting law firms who are challenging Trump’s executive orders and why we are challenging this administration’s overreach in other cases. This is not a moment for moderation.

And finally, we must dream. To dream in this moment is itself an act of resistance. Our ancestors dreamed of freedom even though their hands were shackled; they conceived of justice while enduring systemic cruelty; they believed in a multiracial democracy even though it defied the only reality they had ever known. Their dreams changed this country. Ours must too.

This is not a battle for lawyers alone. It is a fight that demands the full attention and participation of every American—liberal and conservative, skeptic and idealogue. If democracy is to endure, it will do so only if we all rise to meet this moment with unwavering fidelity to the law and undying conviction to deliver justice.

Janai NelsonJanai Nelson is president and director-counsel of the Legal Defense Fund (LDF), the nation’s premier civil rights law organization advancing racial justice and equality, where she leads its strategic vision, program, and operations.


Latest from the nation