Senator majority leader Mitch McConnell signs an oath book along with other Senators, swearing to provide “impartial justice” during the impeachment trial of President Donald Trump.(US Senate TV / Handout)
A crooked senator who admits to coordinating with an impeached president and his cabal of defenders to undermine the work of the Senate has acknowledged his engagement in wrongdoing of the highest order: conniving to upend the system of checks and balances he has sworn to maintain.
This is not a close call, Americans of every partisanship, and every ideological bent (aside, perhaps, from the monarchists), should recognize that Senator majority leader Mitch McConnell’s words were not just unacceptable but disqualifying.
Or, as Representative Val Demings explained in December, “Senator McConnell has promised to sabotage the impeachment trial and he must recuse himself.”
Demings, a member of the key House panels with regard to impeachment—the Intelligence and Judiciary panels—has now been named as one of seven House managers for the impeachment trial. To her credit, she refuses to back off on recusal. Asked this week about whether she still believes McConnell must step aside, the Florida representative said, “I certainly do.”
This comment from Demings on the heels of House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s declaration as she was preparing to send the articles of impeachment to the Senate: “Every Senator now faces a choice: to be loyal to the President or the Constitution.”
Unfortunately, there is good reason to believe that most members of the Republican majority in the chamber will err on the side of partisanship rather than the rule of law. That is shameful, if perhaps not remarkable at a point when Donald Trump has made the Republican Party his partisan plaything.
What is remarkable about this impeachment process as it moves to the Senate is the fact that the dominant figure in the chamber, majority leader Mitch McConnell, announced his choice before the trial began. Indeed, the Republican senator from Kentucky has signaled that he will conspire with the White House to avert accountability. McConnell told Fox News prior to the House’s December approval of two articles of impeachment against Trump, “We have no choice but to take it up, but we’ll be working through this process, hopefully in a fairly short period of time, in total coordination with White House counsel’s office and the people who are representing the President in the well of the Senate.”
That was a stunning statement, even by the standards of a Senate that McConnell’s disregard for ethical standards has turned into a political punch line. It drew rebukes from Democrats and from Republicans such as Alaska Senator Lisa Murkowski, who said she was “disturbed” by the majority leader’s announcement of a coordination scheme. “To me,” Murkowski said in December, “it means that we have to take that step back from being hand in glove with the defense, and so when I heard what leader McConnell had said, I happened to think that that has further confused the process.”
“Confused” is a euphemism.
The proper phrase is “further corrupted the process.”
McConnell has literally announced that “I’m not an impartial juror.”
I know that many important organizations are asking you to donate today, but this year especially, The Nation needs your support.
Over the course of 2025, the Trump administration has presided over a government designed to chill activism and dissent.
The Nation experienced its efforts to destroy press freedom firsthand in September, when Vice President JD Vance attacked our magazine. Vance was following Donald Trump’s lead—waging war on the media through a series of lawsuits against publications and broadcasters, all intended to intimidate those speaking truth to power.
The Nation will never yield to these menacing currents. We have survived for 160 years and we will continue challenging new forms of intimidation, just as we refused to bow to McCarthyism seven decades ago. But in this frightening media environment, we’re relying on you to help us fund journalism that effectively challenges Trump’s crude authoritarianism.
For today only, a generous donor is matching all gifts to The Nation up to $25,000. If we hit our goal this Giving Tuesday, that’s $50,000 for journalism with a sense of urgency.
With your support, we’ll continue to publish investigations that expose the administration’s corruption, analysis that sounds the alarm on AI’s unregulated capture of the military, and profiles of the inspiring stories of people who successfully take on the ICE terror machine.
We’ll also introduce you to the new faces and ideas in this progressive moment, just like we did with New York City Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani. We will always believe that a more just tomorrow is in our power today.
Please, don’t miss this chance to double your impact. Donate to The Nation today.
Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editor and publisher, The Nation
The necessary response to McConnell’s pronouncements came from Representative Val Demings, who stated after McConnell made his comment about coordination, “No court in the country would allow a member of the jury to also serve as the accused’s defense attorney. The moment Senator McConnell takes the oath of impartiality required by the Constitution, he will be in violation of that oath.”
Demings, a former police chief, was on point. The Constitution identifies the Senate as the chamber with the “sole Power to try all Impeachments” and stipulates that “when sitting for that Purpose, they shall be on Oath or Affirmation.” The oath is clear in its language and intent:
I solemnly swear (or affirm, as the case may be) that in all things appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of [Donald Trump , now pending], I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws: So help me God.
“As I said before,” Demings explained, “the senators and we have been given a tremendous responsibility, as well as the president. For the Senate Majority Leader to publicly announce that he has no intentions on being impartial and, as a matter of fact, he’s coordinating every step with the White House and there will be no difference between the White House and his views, is absolutely shameful. It’s hard to take that one back and put that toothpaste back in the tube.”
Now, some Republicans are griping that Demings has been too rough on McConnell.
That’s absurd.
When a wholly amoral officer of the Senate is publicly announcing that he will manipulate the procedures and processes of his chamber, as his colleagues undertake one of their most solemn duties, it would be even more wholly amoral for impeachment managers, senators, and the American people to look away. The call for Mitch McConnell to recuse himself must be amplified and extended. It should become a central theme in the permanent record of this awful moment in American history when oaths they swore have been openly disregarded by the unscrupulous servants of an imperial president.
John NicholsTwitterJohn Nichols is the executive editor of The Nation. He previously served as the magazine’s national affairs correspondent and Washington correspondent. Nichols has written, cowritten, or edited over a dozen books on topics ranging from histories of American socialism and the Democratic Party to analyses of US and global media systems. His latest, cowritten with Senator Bernie Sanders, is the New York Times bestseller It's OK to Be Angry About Capitalism.