Lena Dunham and her generation enter midlife
The New York premiere of Girls, 2012.(Dimitrios Kambouris / Getty)
When Lena Dunham first met her future husband, she told him two things: “I was sick, and people did not like me. If he could be comfortable with those two immutable truths, then we could be together.”
These are two of the central themes that the writer, actor, and director explores in her new memoir, Famesick. An account of making the hit HBO series Girls, the book also considers the time that Dunham spent in rehab and hospitals shortly after wrapping the show’s final season. Notoriety and illness are the through lines in Dunham’s life, and in Famesick they are the perils that often accompanied her rewards. “Getting sick is not that different than getting more famous,” she writes. “It has a maddening circularity, and it’s also very hard to explain, even to the people closest to you. When you’re sick, one medication causes side effects that must be treated by another, more drastic drug.”
Lena Dunham is the Nora Ephron of the millennial generation: vulnerable, brash, and brassy. She’s a grand romantic living in a world of post-sincerity. Her first film, Tiny Furniture, mined the foibles and travails of being a young girl in search of love and experience. Her era-defining Girls expanded on the frustrations of millennial women trying to find love in a world of deadbeat men and to find stable work in an economy that was increasingly rigged against them. A grungier, trashier, bawdier version of Ephron’s rom-coms, Girls captured life in a New York City with more financial and economic and emotional pressures.
Famesick is Dunham’s latest effort to mine her early adult experiences for knowledge and humor, to look bracingly at her friendships, her loves, and her work and see what life lessons can be gleaned from them. If Dunham’s gift has always been to tenderly expose the underbelly of loneliness, of growing up and growing apart, Famesick is about what happens when you get older—when you stop being the youthful provocateur and become instead the grande dame for a generation struggling with midlife crises.
Each chapter of Famesick is named for an episode of Girls. The first, “I Get Ideas,” tells the story of Dunham’s early attempts at filmmaking shortly before she landed the HBO deal. After feverishly writing the script for Tiny Furniture, we are told, Dunham slammed it down in front of her mother, Laurie Simmons, a sculptor who’s an accomplished artist in her own right, and claimed it was a gift: something for the two of them to do together. The film proved to be a blurring of the lines between family members and colleagues, friends and coworkers, fiction and reality. Examining the painful dynamics of a young woman’s attempts to distinguish herself from parents with strong personalities, Tiny Furniture ended up featuring Dunham’s brother as well as a retinue of actors who were also her friends in real life, such as Jemima Kirke.
Praised for its razor-sharp wit and raw desperation, Tiny Furniture helped launch Dunham’s career. Soon she was meeting various producers in Hollywood to sell a TV series. Paired with the producer Jenni Konner, who quickly became her best friend, and the charismatic director Judd Apatow, Dunham found her transition from indie filmmaking to show-running an HBO series to be surprisingly smooth, at least at first: “I remember the boundless creativity that television seemed to allow…. If you wrote an abstract painting or a Bundt cake or a sports car into an episode, it would appear, like everything Harold drew with his magical purple crayon.”
When it premiered in 2012, Girls was an immediate success. The story of four recent college graduates living in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, partying in nearby Bushwick, and attempting to live out their aspirational Sex and the City fantasies, the show satirized as much as lionized its millennial protagonists. Girls was often criticized for its blunt depictions of sex and its often very white, very upper-middle-class perspective on New York City. The four women struggle to remain friends as they deal with the ups and downs of young adulthood—getting jobs, falling in and out of love, moving from one apartment to the next, and eventually being forced to grow up.
By the end of the series’ first season, Dunham was the talk of the town. Attending movie premieres, flying back and forth between the coasts, and doing photo shoots for the cover of Vogue, she was embraced as one of the great representatives of her up-and-coming generation. Unfortunately, Dunham soon discovered that the seeming magic of the industry also had a “corrosive” effect. Her friendship and creative partnership with Konner, while “cozy” and tight-knit, sometimes came with unexpected turbulence. Konner “especially loved me when I was on my game,” Dunham writes acerbically. At times, her colleague was “everything [she] needed—a best friend, a mother, a mentor all rolled into one.” At other times, she was mostly a boss: Konner told Dunham at one point that the network wanted her character to gain weight, under the assumption that women who are too skinny aren’t funny. As the pressures mounted, their relationship turned icy; while family and friends had helped her make Tiny Furniture, Dunham realized that the people involved in making Girls with her were ultimately neither.
This pattern of conflating her professional and personal life also crept into her other relationships. Apart from Konner, Dunham’s primary confidant during the period she was working on Girls was her boyfriend, the singer-songwriter Jack Antonoff. A power couple of sorts, the two lived with a “sense of doom” that things would not last. As readers of Famesick, we already know they won’t. Dunham started dealing with the complications from endometriosis and Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, which sometimes stalled production on Girls toward the end of its six-year run. Soon enough, Dunham’s illness and Antonoff’s touring schedule wound up pushing them apart. “He spent a lot of time telling me about the kind of person I was, and it wasn’t the good kind,” Dunham writes. Antonoff began spending more time away from her, even as Dunham got sicker and sicker. When he was home, Dunham writes, Antonoff was often “locked in the back room with the teen pop star” (a person who goes unnamed in the book but is widely believed to be the singer-songwriter Lorde), “whose needs seemed as massive and complex as my own, and who called me ‘Aunt Lena’ when I hobbled into the kitchen with my walker to grab another bottle of green tea.” By now it was clear that Dunham’s body—like her life—was not what it once was.
As her workaholic tendencies gave way to the stubborn demands of illness and the toll of bad relationships, Dunham’s family took her in, ready to buy heating pads and brew hot tea. Her parents, in particular, became her tether to the real world: Lena’s father, the artist Carroll Dunham, often served as a force of sharp reason. “Don’t you get it?” he once asked her. “You’ve won. You’re only twenty-eight, and you’ve been called a racist, a fat whore, an ignorant rich girl, and a child molester. What else is left?” When Antonoff missed a surgery that Dunham had scheduled—he showed up at the hospital several hours late and blamed it on the traffic—her father noted: “Surgery is like a train, not a tour bus. You either make it, or you don’t.” Dunham’s mother offered her own witticisms and rapport but also struggled with the cost of her daughter’s fame. The family was unable to maintain any sense of normalcy and frequently clashed over Dunham’s public persona. “When an image of my father’s work was highlighted in an article as clear evidence of the kind of left-wing perverts who produce a sex-obsessed narcissist,” Dunham writes, “it stopped being charming and started to undo every narrative thread that had kept us intact.”
As a result of the different diagnoses and surgeries that she endured during those years—including cysts, a hysterectomy, and failed egg-harvesting—Dunham came to realize that, for her, illness wasn’t a temporary destination but a city she “was going to pay taxes in.” As her primary relationships with Antonoff and Konner foundered, she was left to puzzle out a new life for herself. She became, in her own words, a “shipwreck”; writer’s block set in. This was when her drug use began in earnest, “that exquisite, fluffy cotton-candy high.”
With the midterm elections now firmly upon us, the question is whether Democratic candidates will do more than merely occupy ballot lines as mild alternatives to the red-hot crisis that is Donald Trump.
As Trump spends over $1 billion a day on a globally destabilizing war on Iran and admits that he doesn’t “think about Americans’ financial situation,” millions across the country are struggling with the surging costs of essentials. Democrats must seize this moment and advance bold, small-“d” populist ideas—not settle for cynical caution that once again snatches defeat from the jaws of victory.
The Nation elevates progressive ideas, movements, and elected officials achieving real change across the country into the national conversation. At the same time, our journalists are exposing how crypto and AI-funded super PACs are spending hundreds of millions of dollars to knock out candidates they oppose, reporting on the devastating impact of the Supreme Court’s evisceration of the Voting Rights Act, and sounding the alarm on attempts by red states to quickly redraw electoral maps, disenfranchising Southern Black voters.
We can play this critical role because of support from readers like you. This June, we’re raising $20,000 to power The Nation’s independent journalism in the run-up to November’s immensely consequential elections.
It’s in our power to build a more just society, and your support at this critical moment brings us closer to that bold vision. I hope you’ll donate today.
Onward,
Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editor and Publisher, The Nation
To combat her debilitating health problems, Dunham’s doctors prescribed a hefty cocktail of Klonopin and pain meds, eventually leading her to develop a pill addiction that threatened to swallow her and her creative spark whole. After breaking up with Antonoff and wrapping the final season of Girls, Dunham was listless. She dated a string of men who had similar struggles with substance abuse. She also ended up defending a fellow Girls writer who was accused of rape in 2017—an episode that still plunges Dunham into feelings of shame.
The dysfunction of her personal life eventually forced Dunham to admit that she had a pill problem and needed help. “Rehab doesn’t happen to you,” she notes. “You happen to rehab.” Soon her appetite returned, and she learned a form of “messy empathy” from the addicts she encountered. This was when her redemption tour began in earnest. Becoming sober and moving to London “were like a lantern, lighting new paths.” It was this break from her former life, both in terms of relationships and geography, that allowed her to start over.
With the gift of time and deep reflection, Dunham offers a compelling story that dramatizes the relationship between illness and fame. Success is not a cure for the problems in someone’s life, and in fact, at such a young age, it often comes with a cost. The spotlight reveals not just our talents but our flaws.
Toward the end of Famesick, Dunham describes learning the concept of “living amends”: the idea that even without the promise of forgiveness, you should strive to live in a way that demonstrates your contrition. Life itself is your atonement, Dunham explains, “not only for yourself, but as a consistent measure of apology to those you have harmed.”
This idea is not dissimilar to one found in disability theory: that illness and impairment—“dis-abling”—are not temporary, onetime, fixed “events” but rather an alternative, ongoing way of acknowledging our bodies. Sickness is not something to be ashamed of but simply a set of facts that leads to a different orientation toward the world.
When Dunham is able to let go of the stories the world tells about her, she discovers that the narrative strands of her life have come loose. And perhaps that’s a good thing. At the beginning of Famesick, she wonders how others see her: “Little whore or Jack’s baby girl. Needy slut or loving wife. Grateful fat girl or feminist boss”—or even a “barren hag” after her eggs won’t freeze. Only later is she able to move through and then past these dichotomies. She rejects the binary choices: “I have loved being a woman, but I have hated operating the equipment,” she notes. Eventually, Dunham is able to complete the 12 steps of Narcotics Anonymous and kick her addiction, discovering in the process that she is more than any nickname or misnomer she may have once clung to.
While filming Girls, Dunham got news that a workaholic uncle was sick. Dunham asked if he felt that his life was over, since he could no longer work and do the things he had oriented so much of his life around. His answer surprised her: “I would never have stopped, and I would never have known just how much all of you love me.” Famesick is Dunham’s effort to slow down, to redirect and reorient her life away from work, and to finally see just how much life there is around her. At once moving and witty, the book is clear proof that our generation’s Nora Ephron has finally grown up.
Grace ByronGrace Byron is a writer from Indianapolis based in Queens, New York City. Her writing has appeared in The Baffler, The Believer, and The Cut, among other outlets. She’s working on a novel about conversion therapy.