Early Tuesday evening, hundreds of Providence workers, activists and city officials gathered in Rhode Island’s capitol rotunda to protest four lines of text added to the state budget at the very last minute by Democrats on the House Finance Committee.
The amendment, which passed through the finance committee last Thursday, would prohibit municipalities in Rhode Island from establishing their own minimum-wage laws. The Providence city council is currently considering an ordinance that would raise the minimum wage to $15 an hour for employees at large hotels. Other cities around the country like Seattle, San Francisco, and Santa Fe have passed or are considering minimum-wage hikes.
Among those assembled to protest the measure was Carmen Castillo, a hotel worker, union leader and Providence city councilwoman, who has been organizing for months to pass the minimum-wage ordinance. “This proposal attacks all Rhode Island cities and towns,” she said. “It would strip us of our power to represent our communities. What power will they try to take from us next?”
City Councilman Luis Aponte, who emceed the statehouse rally, blamed “rich hotel owners who have deaf ears for those shoveling and cleaning” to keep their businesses running.
Though supported by a majority of Providence voters, the wage ordinance had met well-heeled opposition from the Chamber of Commerce and the Rhode Island Hospitality Association (RIHA), who testified against the bill at a City Council hearing in May. Providence mayor and gubernatorial candidate Angel Taveras had called for a study to determine the economic impact of raising hotel worker wages.
For the opposition, the budget measure was a blessing, averting the wage increase regardless of what plays out in the city council.
This sort of legislative “pre-emption,” has become a popular tool for conservative legislatures seeking to rein in more progressive cities. In April, Oklahoma joined ten other states in passing a pre-emptive labor law, blocking efforts in Oklahoma City to raise the minimum wage to $10.10. Lawmakers in Washington have proposed a similar measure to undermine the $15 minimum wage recently passed in Seattle. In many of these cases, the American Legislative Exchange Council has provided guidance, funding and even model legislation.