As the longest presidential campaign in American history finally concludes, polls tell us that Americans are hugely invested in the election that will be decided — they hope — today. A new Gallup survey suggests that 92 percent of likely voters think this is the most important election in years.
That level of engagement means that, necessarily, we are all looking for indications of how the presidential race between Democrat Barack Obama and Republican John McCain will finish. Here’s one:
In the tiny New Hampshire town of Dixville Notch where voters traditionally cast their ballots at midnight, which has not supported a Democrat for president in forty years, and which favored George Bush by overwhelming margins in 2000 and 2004, Obama secured a landslide victory.
The Democrat won 15 of 21 Dixville Notch votes.
In another New Hampshire town that casts and counts all its votes before dawn, Obama had 17 votes to 10 for Mr McCain and 2 for renegade Republican Ron Paul.
If the margin holds as the next 100 million or so votes are cast, Obama’s victory will not merely be historic. It will be epic in scope.
But for those who may doubt the predictive powers of the Dixville Notchers, here are a dozen indicators to watch for today, tonight and, maybe, tomorrow morning:
1. Figure out where the lines are long. Tens of millions of Americans — perhaps 25 percent of the total turnout — have already cast “early” votes. But most ballots will be marked today. And where the largest crowds of voters are lining up to cast them matters. Watch the college towns in battleground states – such as the aptly-named State College, Pennsylvania. Young people did not cast early votes in the numbers that the Obama camp had hoped to see. Will they crowd the polls on election day? Watch traditionally Republican suburbs, especially those with mega-churches, as well. Are the lines as long in these locations as they are at urban polling places? If so, then the McCain camp may, itself, benefit from a universal boost in turnout.
2. Keep a watch for evidence of breakdowns in the process. If people are waiting more than an hour in line, that’s a problem, as it makes voting harder for working people – especially young parents. If machines are breaking down, if polling places are opening late, look to see if the courts move quickly to extend voting hours. Are there patterns of intimidation at the polls – aggressive challenging of registrations, questions about residence and citizenship status – and what is being done to address them? Follow reports at the No More Stolen Elections website. If there are going to be contested results, you’ll see the crisis developing.
HOT SPOTS to watch: Missouri, where there always seem to be problems in St. Louis, as well as Pennsylvania (especially the Philadelphia area), Ohio, Florida, Virginia, North Carolina, Colorado and Nevada. These are states that have seen significant patterns of complaint and concern going into Election Day.
3. In the afternoon, watch CNN’s Bill Schneider and NBC’s Chuck Todd, both of whom will be in possession of the best exit-polling data. If they start saying things like “Obama seems to be doing very well” or “This could be a very good night for the Democrats,” recognize that the pundits are no longer merely speculating. The same will be true if they say “This could be a long night” or “Mr. McCain might have a surprise in store for the Obama people.”
4. When the actual results start coming in, don’t just pay attention to the battleground states. Early returns from the state of Kentucky, where the polls close in most of the state at 6 p.m. EST and where McCain is thought to be well ahead, will provide important indications. A projection won’t come immediately, as a portion of the state keeps polls open until 7 p.m. EST. But the count and projection should come more quickly in this state than any other. And it could be meaningful. For instance, if Kentucky is not quickly projected for the Republican, that means that Obama is running better than expected. If, when results become available, the Democrat is at 45 percent or better, bet that he will win states such as Indiana, Ohio and West Virginia. If Obama wins Kentucky, start thinking “landslide.”BONUS ROUND: If Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Kentucky, loses, then the Democrats are on track for a Senate super majority, which will allow them to block Republican delaying moves such as filibusters.
5. When all the polls are closed at 7:00 p.m. EST in Indiana and Virginia, we’ll begin to get a clear picture of whether Obama’s 50-state strategy is working. If either state declares quickly for the Democrat, that’s hugely significant. Obama is expected to win Virginia, but if his margin is wide enough to put the state in his column early in the evening, then he is making movement that could be significant not just in Virginia but in neighboring North Carolina. On the other hand, if McCain wins Virginia, then the Republican is beginning to put together the pieces of an upset.
If anything, Indiana, is even more significant than Virginia. Solidly Republican in presidential politics since 1964, Indiana wasn’t supposed to be competitive this year. But it is. And if Obama secures the state early in the evening, his chances of winning neighboring Ohio – as well as another battleground state, West Virginia – will look a whole lot better.
6. Another 7:00 p.m. EST closing is in South Carolina. Don’t look for an Obama win here. But watch a congressional race. Republican Congressman Henry Brown is in a tight contest with wealthy philanthropist Linda Ketner, an out-of-the-closet lesbian who has rewritten a lot of political rule books this year. If Ketner wins, which polls suggest is possible, the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee’s strategy on recruiting candidates and targeting resources in a wider range of districts is working. In the neighboring state of Georgia, where polls also close at 7 p.m. EST, watch the Senate race: incumbent Republican Saxby Chambliss is vulverable; if he loses outright or is forced into a run-off (required under state law if no one gets a majority), the Democratic Senate Campaign Committee will be popping champagne corks early.
BONUS ROUND: In the results from South Carolina and Georgia, we’ll begin to get a clearer read on the role a dramatic increase in African-American turnout might play in presidential and congressional contests — especially in states that were not expected to be competitive.
7. At 8 p.m. EST, the flood begins, with polls closing in 20 states. Don’t expect quick results from Pennsylvania. The Keystone State does not “do” early voting, so the lines will be long and tens of thousands of voters may still be in line (and eligible to vote) when the official closing time comes. The same goes for Missouri, which closes as 8. Best hope for early indicators: New Hampshire. Did McCain take it back for the Republicans? He probably has to do so in order to win. Keep an eye, as well, on South Dakota, the Central Time half of which reports at 8 (while the Mountain Time half reports at 9). The state moved into “toss up” status at the close of race. A small state that counts quickly, South Dakota could give one of the first signals about whether Obama’s western strategy is succeeding in repainting traditionally red states blue.
8. At 8:30 p.m. EST, polls in North Carolina close. Did the state go Democratic in a presidential race for the first time since 1976? Obama does not, necessarily, need it. McCain really can’t afford to lose it. Equally significant: Did Republican Senator Elizabeth Dole, who closed her campaign on a particularly vicious note of religious intolerance, lose? If Democrat Kay Hagan beats Dole, a President Obama is all but certain to have an overwhelmingly Democratic Senate – perhaps even the filibuster-proof one that he barely dared imagine just weeks ago.
9. At 9 p.m. EST, 15 more states finish voting. More than 430 of the 538 electoral votes will be accounted for. As results become available from Colorado, New Mexico and newly-competitive Arizona, and if votes are being counted quickly, it will now be possible to declare a national winner. If Obama takes Colorado and New Mexico on top of a solid pattern of east-of-the-Mississippi wins, he’ll be president. If he takes McCain’s home state of Arizona, his victory will be capped with delicious irony.
10. The 9 p.m. EST batch of states will also provide key indications regarding Democratic prospects in Congress. Did McCarthyite Republican Congresswoman Michele Bachmann lose her Minnesota district to challenger Elwyn Tinklenberg, whose campaign took off after Bachmann started ranting on MSNBC’s “Hardball” in late October? Did Democrats pick up the open Minnesota House seat being sought by Iraq War vet Ashwin Madia? Wins in those districts would point to major pick-ups – perhaps more than thirty seats overall for Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s House Democrats. Similarly, if Democrat Al Franken displaces Republican incumbent Norm Coleman in Minnesota’s intense U.S. Senate race, Democrats will be on track to dominate the upper chamber. (And Franken-hater-in-chief Bill O’Reilly might explode – not figuratively, but literally.)
11. In the states with 10 p.m. EST closing times, watch Iowa and Nevada. The campaigns put last-minute time and resources into both states, although Iowa appeared to be safely in the Democratic column. If Obama wins Iowa and turns Nevada from red to blue, one of these states might put him over the top. But that is only because the big-ticket state of California, which also reports at 10 p.m. EST, will take longer to count. When the numbers are known, however, we will be reminded why Republican Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger made his big campaign stop for McCain in Ohio, not California. The Golden State is solid blue.
BONUS ROUND: Will Ron Paul’s votes on the Constitution Party ballot line in Montana cost McCain a state that has long leaned Republican in presidential contests but has been trending Democratic. Paul’s signs are everywhere in Montana, and if he takes 4 or 5 percent of the vote, it could be just enough to tip the state to Obama.
12. At 11 p.m. EST, when Washington state is finished voting and all the precincts in neighboring Oregon are shuttered, watch for a pair of congressional results. Did Democrat Jeff Merkley defeat Republican Senator Gordon Smith, who tried to run as a moderate (going so far as to link himself with Obama in GOP television ads)? Did Darcy Burner, a progressive Democrat who ran on a strong anti-war platform, grab a Republican-held seat outside Seattle. Both wins would signal not just that Democrats are winning congressional races but that the next Democratic caucuses will tilt to the left of the old ones.
Finally, if you can’t get enough of Election 2008, the last polls remain open in Alaska until 1 a.m. EST on Wednesday. You can stay up and see whether convicted Senator Ted Stevens loses. (Best bet: Democrat Nick Begich beats him.) And you see exactly how much Sarah Palin contributed to the Republican ticket in a state where Obama was once thought to be competitive. If the Republicans don’t win more than 60 percent in Alaska, Palin’s got troubles at home Is that possible? You betcha!