“Is anyone going to speak out against violence?” The student, a bystander at an April rally for Palestinian solidarity in front of Columbia University’s Low Library in Manhattan, was red-faced with rage, and on the verge of tears. She took her question directly to the event’s organizers, who were nonplussed. “This is a call to end the violence,” said Annemarie Jacir, a Palestinian student who has family in Ramallah. The woman was unmollified. “A lot of people here are calling you Nazis and liars,” she said. “Rather than calling out in a violent manner, I’m coming over to talk. I’ve been here as a bystander for an hour and haven’t heard anyone condemn the suicide bombings.” In fact, some speakers had done this, but she hadn’t heard them. Jacir sighs, saying later, “People heckle us and say, ‘You support Hamas.’ That’s not what this is about.”
The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is a difficult subject on campus, just as it is everywhere in this country. Many students, horrified by Israel’s recent atrocities, are beginning to question their own government’s role in the Middle East. Increasingly, students critical of Israel, many of whom have never been politically active before, are emerging as a visible presence, protesting the Israeli occupation and its support by the United States. Within the emerging Palestinian solidarity organizations, students vary widely in their rhetoric and in their positions–on Palestinian resistance, for example, or the right of Israel to exist as a Jewish state–but they manage to work together. In April, reeling from the shock of Jenin and countering students celebrating Israeli Independence Day, pro-Palestine students held rallies and teach-ins across the country. At Berkeley, during a rally of 1,200 people, students occupied Wheeler Hall, an academic building, demanding that the University of California divest from companies doing business in Israel (seventy-nine people were arrested). And busloads of student protesters went to Washington for April 20, which, with a turnout of 50,000-80,000 people, turned out to be the largest pro-Palestinian demonstration in US history.
Many students are attempting to induce administrators to wield their institutions’ power to create political change, as the student antisweatshop movement has done. Following the model of 1980s antiapartheid activists, students at Columbia, Princeton, Harvard, MIT and the Universities of California, Illinois, Michigan and Wisconsin are urging their administrations to divest from companies that do business with Israel. There are many such companies, as one might guess: General Electric, Hewlett-Packard, AOL Time Warner, Nokia. All figure prominently in the University of California’s portfolio, while Harvard’s has more than $600 million in companies with significant investments in Israel. A petition from students, faculty and staff at Harvard and MIT, modeled after a nearly identical petition signed by Princeton faculty, calls for divestment until Israel, in compliance with the relevant UN resolutions and Geneva Conventions, ceases building new settlements, withdraws from the occupied territories and either allows refugees to return to confiscated lands or compensates them for their losses. Some Israeli academics who oppose the occupation, like Tel Aviv University’s Tanya Reinhart, have also signed the petitions, and some campus groups are also working closely with Palestinian activists in both Israel and Palestine.