Howard Dean’s supporters think he has gotten a raw deal from the media. And their candidate does not disagree.
Even before the former frontrunner started to stumble at the polling places in primary and caucus states, Dean says he started taking hits from media insiders who he says feared handing the Democratic presidential nomination to an outsider.
“I think I scared them. I think it goes back to when Al Gore endorsed me, and AFSCME and the SEIU; people in the establishment began to think I could win,” Dean says, recalling the heady days last fall when he accumulated endorsements from top Democrats and labor unions. “That scared the hell out of them because they knew I didn’t owe anybody. I didn’t owe them a dime. Eighty-nine percent of our money comes from small donors. That’s certainly not true of anybody else running for president on either side.”
The “them” Dean is referring to are the Washington-based political pundits, reporters and commentators who shape so much of the discussion of presidential politics on television and on the pages of America’s elite newspapers. “I think the media is part of the established group in Washington. They have a little club there,” says Dean. “If you don’t go down to kiss the ring, they get upset by that. I don’t play the game. I pretty much say what I think. That makes a lot of people uncomfortable.”
Initially, Dean says, he felt he could take the hits. After all, media outlets that once dismissed him as the “asterisk” candidate from the small state of Vermont made him a national figure when they featured him on magazine covers and news shows.
But, after what he refers to as a “pep talk” given to backers after his defeat in the Iowa caucuses began airing around-the-clock on cable news programs as the “I Have a Scream” speech, Dean says he began to fully understand how events can be warped by the media. “ABC actually did a fairly sound retraction on that one,” Dean says of a report by ABC News that showed the “scream” in Des Moines was dramatically amplified in television and cable reports. “But that’s one network, and one report. Most of the networks failed to offer any perspective.”
Dean does not suggest that he has run an error-free campaign. He admits to plenty of mistakes. But his complaint that he has not gotten fair coverage is echoed by a report from the Center for Media and Public Affairs. The center’s study of 187 CBS, NBC and ABC evening news reports found that only 49 percent of all on-air evaluations of Dean in 2003 were positive. The other Democratic contenders collectively received 78 percent favorable coverage during the same period.