A rally near the federal courthouse in New York, Monday, March 18, 2013. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)
In 2011 the number of young black men stopped by police in New York City exceeded the number of young black men actually living in the city. The vast majority of them had committed no crime.
Members of communities of color in New York City are also statistically more likely to be searched when stopped by the police, and more likely to be subjected to use of force than their white neighbors. This despite the fact that white people, when stopped, are twice as likely to be carrying a weapon.
Mayor Michael Bloomberg sees something wrong with this picture. Black people aren’t being stopped enough and white people are getting stopped too often, the mayor said today, arguing that given witness and victim descriptions in murder cases, “we disproportionately stop whites too much and minorities too little.”
The mayor’s comments, which also included the bold assertion that “nobody racially profiles,” were made during a radio interview in which he was discussing a recent city council vote on two bills aimed to curb discriminatory policing in New York City.
The package of legislation, known as the Community Safety Act (CSA), was voted on in a meeting that stretched from late Wednesday into the early hours of Thursday morning.
The lawmakers voted to create an inspector general for the largest police department in the country and paved the way for a broader range of New Yorkers to bring legal claims against the NYPD for discriminatory policing and profiling. Enough votes were cast in favor of the measures to override a veto promised by Mayor Michael Bloomberg.
In their call for increased accountability and transparency, the council members took a major swing at the shared law enforcement legacies of Mayor Bloomberg and NYPD commissioner Ray Kelly, who have argued the legislation amounts to an invitation for violence and possible terrorist attacks.
“This is going to affect everyone in the city; it’s not just going to affect just the Police Department,” Commissioner Kelly said at a news conference hours after the vote. “Shootings are at record lows. Some people apparently are not satisfied with that. We’re going to see what this all means if the mayor’s veto is not sustained.” Earlier in the week, Mayor Bloomberg called opposition to the bills a matter of “life or death.”
Spearheaded by city council members Jumaane Williams and Brad Lander, the CSA is comprised of four bills, two of which were voted on this week; the NYPD Oversight Act (Intro 1079) and the End NYPD Discriminatory Profiling Act (Intro 1080).
The NYPD Oversight Act seeks to create an independent inspector general monitor for the department and assigns responsibility for NYPD oversight to the commissioner of the Department of Investigation, which currently oversees roughly 300 other agencies in New York City, including the Fire Department, Department of Education and Human Resources Administration. The monitor would be responsible for reviewing NYPD operations, policies, programs and practices and would issue public reports. The monitor’s recommendations would be revisited annually.