Since Spike Lee begins his new picture, Bamboozled, by giving a dictionary definition of satire, the least a reviewer can do is to open with a proper critical definition. Strictly speaking, Bamboozled is a Menippean satire; and because I’m unqualified to describe that form, I will defer to Northrop Frye. A few lines from his Anatomy of Criticism:
The Menippean satire deals less with people as such than with mental attitudes. Pedants, bigots, cranks, parvenus, virtuosi, enthusiasts, rapacious and incompetent professional men of all kinds, are handled in terms of their occupational approach to life as distinct from their social behavior. The Menippean satire thus…differs from the novel in its characterization, which is stylized rather than naturalistic, and presents people as mouthpieces of the ideas they represent.
Frye’s catalogue of Menippean personages will serve nicely as a roll call for the characters in Bamboozled. “Rapacious and incompetent professional men”–those would be Dunwitty (Michael Rapaport), a full-throatedly boorish program executive at the CNS television network, and his underling Pierre Delacroix (Damon Wayans), the network’s only African-American staff writer. The story’s “virtuosi” are a pair of starving, scuffling street performers, Manray (Savion Glover) and Womack (Tommy Davidson), who at first want nothing more than a chance to do their act and get paid. In them, Delacroix sees a vehicle for escaping his job, while at the same time exacting revenge on Dunwitty for endless slights and slurs.
“Enthusiasts” are the American people, God bless them, who fall in love with the variety show that Delacroix dreams up. Manray, now called Mantan, and Womack, renamed Sleep ‘n’ Eat, become the stars of Mantan: The New Millennium Minstrel Show, a variety program set in an Alabama watermelon patch, featuring a full cast of coons, Toms, mammies, pickaninnies and chain-gang prisoners. To Delacroix’s horror, viewers do not rise up in fury against this spectacle. Instead, they adopt blackface as the nation’s latest fad.
“Cranks”–these are the members of a would-be-revolutionary hip-hop collective called the Mau Maus, led by a man who has named himself Big Blak African (Mos Def). The Mau Maus conform to the most noxious stereotypes–they’re unlettered, inarticulate, unemployed, slovenly and very fond of malt liquor–so of course they declare war on the minstrel show for perpetuating such images.
“Parvenus”–a term that applies to most of the major characters. Once the minstrel show turns into a huge success, misbehavior becomes general. “Pedant”–that would be Sloan (Jada Pinkett-Smith), Delacroix’s young assistant and his uneasy but ineffective conscience. She’s the one who insists that if Manray and Womack are to wear blackface, they must use authentic burnt cork. She’s also the one who protests against the show by collecting hundreds of antique coon figures, with which she fills Delacroix’s office and home. To these, Spike Lee adds a collection of his own, appending to the movie an entire gallery’s worth of film clips of Toms, mammies, pickaninnies, etc. In such a manner, writes Frye, does the Menippean satirist demonstrate exuberance, “piling up an enormous mass of erudition about his theme.”