Sarah Beth Alcabes (L) kisses girlfriend Meghan Cleary, both of California, after the US Supreme Court’s ruling on cases against the federal Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) and California’s gay marriage ban known as Prop 8, outside the court in Washington, June 26, 2013. (REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst)
There are 1,110 federal benefits, rights and obligations that, until last week, could only be claimed by heterosexual couples. That was clear until the Supreme Court struck down the Defense of Marriage Act in Windsor v. United States.
What’s not as clear is how many of those benefits can be quickly extended to same-sex couples. In particular, the Social Security Administration and the Department of Veterans Affairs have some thorny rules that may leave elderly couples and gay veterans in a legal no-man’s land for years to come.
“These two areas are of quite a bit of significance,” said Susan Sommer, the director of constitutional litigation at Lambda Legal, the country’s oldest gay-rights firm. Sommer noted that it’s too early to say exactly what options the executive branch has for extending VA and Social Security benefits to all same-sex spouses in spite of the statutes. “It may well be a different process and higher hurdles.”
The key problem is that gay marriages are legal in only thirteen states, and complicated residency rules vary from federal agency to federal agency.
For some agencies, the transition to post-DOMA benefits will be fairly straightforward: at the Defense Department, for example, there is a “place of celebration” rule, meaning that if a couple has a legal marriage license from any state, their union is valid regardless of the law where they live. Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel already announced that the Pentagon “intends to make the same benefits available to all military spouses—regardless of sexual orientation—as soon as possible.”
Other federal agencies have a “place of residence” rule, which considers a marriage valid—and thus, spousal benefits valid—only if the union is recognized in the state where a couple lives.
For most agencies with a “place of residence” rule, same-sex benefits might take a little longer—but not by much. The administration has the authority to simply update or change agency rules independently, and President Obama has already directed the Justice Department to “ensure this decision, including its implications for Federal benefits and obligations, is implemented swiftly and smoothly.”