The Nation.



Londonistan Calling

By Gary Younge

This article appeared in the September 25, 2006 edition of The Nation.

September 7, 2006

In the days immediately following the July 2005 terrorist attacks in London, the American press described the city as a hub of Islamic fundamentalism and terrorist cells. With headlines like "For a Decade London Thrived as a Busy Crossroads of Terror" (New York Times) and "Continent's Issues Include Geography and Open Borders--Bombers Travel Freely, Police Cannot" (Wall Street Journal), the city was characterized as a "breeding ground for hate" and a "crossroads for would-be terrorists" where Muslims exploit civil liberties and "openly preached violence." Like Kandahar, only with bowler hats.

» More

This was a shock to most Londoners, including myself. True, London does have its fair share of radical Islamist clerics. There is Abu Hamza at the Finsbury Park Mosque, recently convicted of incitement to murder and racial hatred for his anti-Semitic rants; and there was the Brixton Mosque, spiritual nurturing ground of would-be shoe bomber Richard Reid. But nothing on the apocalyptic scale described by American journalists. Indeed, before the week was out it would transpire that none of the bombers actually came from London.

Nonetheless, so entrenched was the notion that the British capital had become a mutinous outpost of the Islamist diaspora that American reporters were determined to rename the capital Londonistan. The word, which I had never heard used in England before, was employed at least nine times in different American papers in the six days following the attacks.

In a bid to give it legitimacy each writer would strain to explain its provenance. And with each contradictory explanation it became increasingly clear that the source lay in the ethnic and religious template they themselves had designed for the city. In the New York Times Peter Bergen claimed: "Arab militants living in London sometimes jokingly refer to their hometown as Londonistan." The San Jose Mercury News argued that "for years, those in diplomatic and security circles have referred to England's capital as Londonistan." According to the Pittsburgh Tribune Review the French were responsible: "Frustration over extradition delays has led some to dub their neighbor Londonistan."

Quite who these "some" referred to was conveniently unreported, but such claims have since found their echo in Londonistan, a shrill broadside against multiculturalism by right-wing British columnist Melanie Phillips. Phillips claims Britain "is currently locked into such a spiral of decadence, self-loathing and sentimentality that it is incapable of seeing that it is setting itself up for cultural immolation." Such views were given succor--but little substance--in August when British security services uncovered an alleged plot to blow up planes bound for America. This time a large number of those believed to be involved did come from London's East End borough of Walthamstow. Whatever else ushered the most recent terror suspects into the trade, it was clearly not a desire to self-segregate. These were young men who played soccer, delivered pizzas and supported Liverpool. At least two were white converts. One waits for the first appearance of "Walthamstan" in the American media lexicon.

With the release of Gautam Malkani's novel Londonstani, the term is now ready for public consumption in a manner far less contrived and far more in keeping with the context of Britain's particular racial and ethnic reality--a post-colonial hub to which the four corners of the globe descended after World War II and the collapse of the British Empire. Immigrants from the Caribbean, Africa, Pakistan, Bangladesh and India have made more than a quarter of the city nonwhite.

Londonstani tells the story of Jas, a teenager living in Hounslow, near Heathrow Airport, who has fallen in with a crowd of South Asian toughs, all of whom are retaking their university entrance exams after failing the first time around. There is Hardjit, the hard man with a Sikh Khanda symbol tattooed on his bulging right bicep; Ravi, a self-styled ladies' man with a BMW decked out to match the color of the underwear belonging to the women he seduces inside; and Amit, overwhelmed by the family rows over his brother's impending wedding.

About Gary Younge

Gary Younge, the Alfred Knobler Journalism Fellow at The Nation Institute, is the New York correspondent for the Guardian and the author of No Place Like Home: A Black Briton's Journey Through the Deep South (Mississippi) and Stranger in a Strange Land: Travels in the Disunited States (New Press). He is also a contributor to The Notion. more...

Popular Topics
Most Searched

Issues »

Most Emailed

Issues »

Blogs

» Campaign 08

Of Course, Edwards Voted for Obama | The former candidate voted for "him," not "her."
John Nichols

» J Street

Friday Capitol Letter | This week's legislative run-down from Washington.
Te-Ping Chen

» ActNow!

Cluster Bombs Kill Kids | The US is working to undermine an international cluster bomb treaty.
Peter Rothberg

» Passing Through

America 2.3 (Million) | Modern America through the lens of one number.
Zephyr Teachout

» The Beat

One in Four Republicans Reject McCain | In Indiana & North Carolina, GOP candidate had a bigger problem with his base than Obama did with wavering Dems.
John Nichols

» Editor's Cut

Newt Gingrich to GOP--Wake Up or Perish | The architect of the Contract ON America warns his party of looming disaster.
Katrina vanden Heuvel

» The Notion

Who Really Lost the Cold War? | Is the US finished as a superpower just as Russia rides a wave of energy back to great power status?
Tom Engelhardt

» And Another Thing

Preachers and Politics | Secularism looks better and better.
Katha Pollitt