The Alito Failure

By Bruce Shapiro

This article appeared in the February 6, 2006 edition of The Nation.

January 19, 2006

The Samuel Alito hearings demonstrate the price of one-party government. A Supreme Court nominee who is by expressed conviction opposed to Roe v. Wade and dodgy about privacy rights, whose radical jurisprudence undercuts Congressional authority and guts civil rights enforcement--a philosophy not long ago viewed as unconfirmable--now appears to be hurtling toward confirmation amid cheers from the right and resigned shrugs from too many Democrats.

Bruce Shapiro was director of The Nation Institute's Supreme Court Watch during the nominations of Justices Thomas, Breyer and Ginsburg.

» More

Confirmation hearings are supposed to inform the Senate and the public about a nominee--to put some meat on the bare bones of the Constitution's advise-and-consent clause. Alito's hearings did the opposite, obscuring his fifteen-year paper trail as a judge and his careerlong commitments. The Democratic failure to make Alito's far-right biography stick may invite Monday-morning quarterbacking, but it is also clear that no matter what Alito said, he would have retained the support of most of the Judiciary Committee Republicans--including, unfortunately, Arlen Specter, who traded in his record as a prochoice moderate to preserve his prerogatives as Judiciary chairman.

The real Democratic failure is long-term. For years Democratic leaders have avoided the work of strengthening a constituency for civil rights and civil liberties, keeping such issues at the periphery of their political strategy. In that sense, Alito's expected confirmation is payback. It's fine to say that a more balanced Supreme Court is impossible without Democratic victories in 2006 and '08, but such victories will gain little if they are not accompanied by a renewed Democratic commitment to privacy, equality and civil liberties as core values--and by Democratic politicians' determination to tell a persuasive story about why people should care.

There are still reasons to slow this nomination down and fight Alito as hard as possible. For one thing, Democrats have never gained by folding their cards on a judicial nominee; the tactical decision by some to vote for John Roberts, thinking that would lend credibility to opposing an even more conservative nominee like Alito, earned them chump change rather than political capital. (Roberts's vote against Oregon's Death With Dignity Act should end the fiction that he is a social pragmatist in the O'Connor mold. If Alito is confirmed, there will be a solid four-vote bloc of social conservatives.) Even more compelling--enough to warrant a filibuster--is the gathering constitutional crisis over presidential power and accountability. Given Alito's long devotion to expansive executive-branch power, his post-9/11 endorsement of the unitary-executive theory and his cagey responses to senators' questions about presidential lawbreaking in wartime, his nomination deepens that constitutional crisis--an extreme circumstance without historical parallel.

About Bruce Shapiro

Bruce Shapiro, a contributing editor to The Nation, is an investigative reporter, political essayist and journalism reformer. He is executive director of the Dart Center for Journalism and Trauma, a global resource center and think tank for journalists covering violence, conflict and tragedy. more...
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Blogs

» The Beat

House Passes Health Reform, But Without Reproductive Rights | Pelosi secures necessary votes, but only after allowing anti-choice Dems to bar access to abortion in new programs.
John Nichols
149 Comments

» Editor's Cut

Around The Nation | Obama, one year on. Plus: Jeremy Scahill takes your questions, and a new video series from The Nation.
Katrina vanden Heuvel
9 Comments

» The Notion

Injustice in Illinois | Prosecutors in Illinois should be more concerned with an innocent man behind bars than journalism students' grades.
Ari Berman
28 Comments

» The Dreyfuss Report

Obama Fails in Middle East | Clinton delivers the ultimate diss to Abbas.
Robert Dreyfuss
139 Comments

» Act Now!

Equality Across America | This week, young LBGT activists are staging a National Week of Initiative.
Peter Rothberg
16 Comments

» Altercation

Slacker Thursday | Dying laptops, recapping the election, the Dow, and the Yankees with the World Series.
Eric Alterman