Too Young to Die

The immediate outcome of the Supreme Court's 5-to-4 decision in Roper v. Simmons is reason enough to celebrate: With one stroke it set aside seventy-two death sentences imposed for crimes committed by teenagers and categorically banned capital punishment for offenders under 18. The Court's powerful majority opinion--all the more notable because it was written by Reagan appointee Anthony Kennedy--adds momentum to the narrowing of capital sentences and diminishing number of executions in the United States. Justice Kennedy's opinion explicitly acknowledges teenagers' universal "vulnerability and comparative lack of control over their immediate surroundings," elaborated with a humane and scientific recognition of developmental psychology, too long absent from the death penalty debate.

But the significance of Roper v. Simmons goes far beyond those seventy-two cases, thanks to Justice Kennedy's unapologetic embrace of international human rights standards. Noting that the United States was the only nation left routinely imposing capital punishment on teens, Kennedy invoked "the overwhelming weight of international public opinion": a judicial glove smacked across the faces of Antonin Scalia and the whole original-intent crowd, so full of disdain for the Court's recent embrace of evolving global standards in other death penalty cases and in gay rights cases. Considering the international context of human rights, Kennedy wrote pointedly, "does not lessen our fidelity to the Constitution or our pride in its origins."

Since only a handful of nations still maintain capital punishment under any circumstances, the implication of Kennedy's remark for future death penalty cases should not be underestimated. The Court's growing willingness to listen to briefs from the EU and retired American diplomats should cause the Bush Administration particular uneasiness as more and more cases from the "war on terror" make their way up the docket: "The overwhelming weight of international public opinion" applies as thoroughly to torture and imprisonment without charge.

Subscriber Login

User Name

Password

Subscribe Now!

The only way to read this article and the full contents of each week's issue of The Nation online is by subscribing to the magazine. Subscribe now and read this article -- and every article published since for the past five years -- right now.

There's no obligation -- try The Nation for four weeks free.

• Get The Nation at home (and online!) for 68 cents a week!
• If you like this article, consider making a donation to The Nation.
• Reprint this article. Click here for rights and information.