A Moderate Wouldn't Make Appointments Like These

Column Left

By Robert Scheer

February 20, 2000

It may be legal, but it's still a coup d'état. The nomination of Theodore B. Olson to be solicitor general, a position of such influence that it is often referred to as "the 10th member of the Supreme Court," affirms that President Bush has turned the US judiciary over to the far right.

» More

Most Read

Issues »

We can't say we weren't warned when Bush, during the campaign, named Clarence Thomas and Antonin Scalia as his role models for future judicial appointments. They returned the compliment by obediently bowing to the arguments of Bush's lawyer, Olson, that abruptly stopped the vote counting in Florida, thus handing the election to Bush.

Once in office, Bush quickly appointed three of Thomas's closest personal and ideological buddies to head the judicial branch of the US government. Newly minted Atty. Gen. John Ashcroft made that point when he rushed off to Thomas's chambers to be sworn in out of the public eye. Then came the appointment of Larry Thompson, who had defended Thomas in his stormy confirmation hearings, as deputy attorney general. Then the pièce de résistance: Olson.

While newspaper editorials praised the Bush Administration for its moderate style, the often mute Thomas emerged from the shadows to celebrate the far right's triumph. At a conservative dinner soiree, Thomas issued a militant call to arms decrying "an overemphasis on civility." Indeed, instead of being civil to those with whom he disagrees, we had the unseemly spectacle of a Supreme Court Justice calling for ideological war: "The war in which we are engaged is cultural, not civil." He chided moderates in his own party saying he was "deeply concerned because too many [conservatives] show timidity today precisely when courage is demanded."

Surely he wasn't referring to the President, who has given the GOP right wing the prize it really wanted: control of the judiciary. Clearly, the intention is to use the powers of the state to pursue the right's social agenda while virtually dismantling the federal government as a force for social justice.

The choice of Olson as solicitor general seals the right wing's seizure of power. But it could not have happened without the denigration of the Clinton Administration and its threat to marginalize the right by moving politics back to the center. Key to the effort to destroy Clinton was this same Olson, who will now represent the US government in cases involving affirmative action, the environment and women's rights. Guess what side of those issues Olson has represented in the past? Olson, a member of the board of directors and legal counsel for the extreme right American Spectator magazine, was a principal figure in smearing Clinton even before the man was elected to his first term. The magazine used $2.4 million provided by far-right billionaire Richard Mellon Scaife to dig up dirt on Clinton in what started as Troopergate and ended up propelling the Paula Jones case to the status of an impeachable offense. It was this same Olson, a close friend of Kenneth Starr, who coached Jones' attorneys before their successful request to the Supreme Court to allow a civil suit to be heard against a sitting President.

Olson is one of those family values conservatives who evidently believes that only wealthy women like his lawyer-talk show pundit third wife should work. He argued unsuccessfully before the Supreme Court against a California law that protected the jobs of women who took four months of unpaid disability leave for pregnancy, terming it "destructive to women."

Olson had another major failure when in 1996 he argued against women being admitted to the publicly financed all-male Virginia Military Institute on the grounds that the school's character would be fundamentally altered. To which Justice Stephen Breyer tartly replied, "So what?"

One of Olson's unsavory victories came when he got a federal appeals court to rule that the affirmative action program for admissions at the University of Texas was unconstitutional. An opponent of environmental protection, Olson has gone to court to get sections of the Endangered Species Act declared unconstitutional.

Now Olson and the other friends of Thomas are in a position to weigh in heavily on future nominations to the Court, and their own names will surely head the list. These are lawyers who have devoted not only their professional lives but their personal political activity to reshaping the Court as an activist vehicle to turn back the clock on the rights of women, minorities and working people as well as to leave the environment open to corporate exploitation.

By selecting this triumvirate to head the Justice Department, Bush has sent the strongest of signals as to his intent to use the Court to advance the far right's agenda. So much for moderation.

About Robert Scheer

Robert Scheer, a contributing editor to The Nation, is editor of Truthdig.com and author of The Pornography of Power: How Defense Hawks Hijacked 9/11 and Weakened America (Twelve) and Playing President (Akashic Books). He is author, with Christopher Scheer and Lakshmi Chaudhry, of The Five Biggest Lies Bush Told Us About Iraq (Akashic Books and Seven Stories Press.) His weekly column, distributed by Creators Syndicate, appears in the San Francisco Chronicle. more...
Most Read

Issues »

Most Emailed

Issues »

Popular Topics

Blogs

» Campaign 08

Free-basing McPalin | MoveOn feeds your head with the funniest ad of the race.
Leslie Savan
Posted at 2:56 PM ET

» Act Now!

Send the Next President to Poland | It's only the future.
Peter Rothberg

» The Beat

How to Fix the Debates: Better Moderators | The candidates need to be pushed and prodded. Who can do it? How about Amy Goodman? Pat Buchanan? Or Ralph Nader?
John Nichols

» The Dreyfuss Report

Iran Readies Its End-Game Iraq Strategy | Is it meddling? Or pursuit of national interests? We report, you decide.
Robert Dreyfuss

» Capitolism

A Well-Deserved Prize for An Outspoken Liberal | Paul Krugman, Nobel laureate. It has a nice ring to it.
Christopher Hayes

» Editor's Cut

Nation to New Yorkers: Vote Change Like You Mean It. | By voting on the Working Families Party ballot line, progressives can vote both for Obama and for the movement needed to push him.
Katrina vanden Heuvel

» The Notion

Is the Second Superpower of the Cold War Going Down? | The Soviets were bankrupted by an Afghan War that wouldn’t end. Now, is it our turn?
Tom Engelhardt

» And Another Thing

Are You the Very Model of a Modern Vice-President? | Sarah's not the only one with a special skill.
Katha Pollitt