Web Letters: Misreading Gaza

Comment

By Roane Carey

This article appeared in the January 26, 2009 edition of The Nation.

January 7, 2009

Write a Web letter about this article.

What's a Web Letter?

Web Letters are continuously published e-mails from real people, signed with their real names. No registration is required. Each article page on The Nation includes a Web Letters link.

Read the best Web Letters on this page.

We're committed to publishing your comments as they are received. We place a red star () on the best submissions and may edit your e-mail for length or content. Your e-mail address will not be published or shared with any third party without your consent.

If you prefer, you may submit a letter to the print edition only.

We look forward to hearing from you.

  • I will quote Roane Cary's second-to-last sentence. "The alternative to that is not only more warfare but, sooner or later, world recognition that there should be only one state in Israel and the territories." This the only real satisfying and lasting alternative--one state (United Palestine)

    United Palestine--a challenge to the races and religions of Palestine. Great religions must practice tolerance, equality and sustainability. How great are the religions of Palestine? Let them rise to the challenge of the times by together authoring a constitution for a new United Palestine.

    We need a Israeli-Palestinian great experiment--United Palestine. The United States is a great experiment that flourishes today but is in need of renewal.

    Israelis and Palestinians must convene a constitutional convention. This new constitution must explicitly foster agreed-upon social values. Think of all the social values needed to fairly and sustainably integrate two "opposing" sides.

    One major social value that needs clarification is the idea of separation of church and state. We define religion as a set of beliefs and opinions concerning the existence, nature and worship of a deity or deities, and divine involvement in the universe and human life. We define church as a social organization of the followers of a same religion. The separation of church means that the state cannot favor one church over another and that the state cannot establish a religion. The state, however, does need to control a religion if its worship practices and other social manifestations become too extreme and counter to the values fostered by most people of the state.

    The way a state truly incorporates the values of its people is by continually giving its people the information and power to make well-informed decisions about the state's duties and purposes. The state must foster an educational and media system that fairly represents all sides of every issue. This responsible information-disseminating system must be better than all commercial propaganda combined. The state must also provide forums for input and debate of all the issues and limit the undue influence on the political system of money and special interests.

    The state must provide everyone a secure place in society according to their needs and abilities. This means education, shelter, food, healthcare and job-service opportunities. If a person has a secure, respected, responsible place in society they are not likely to jeopardize it with anti-state and anti-ethnic acts.

    The state must offer personal self-realization. With current technology there is no need for all to work all the time--all should work some of the time. The state must offer something better than TV for leisure hours. Services, education, religious, political and artistic pursuits are examples.

    As we see today the state must also offer a national banking and monetary system not base on debt and control of its international money flows and exchange rate.

    There are some who do not have the values of equality and sustainability and are thus "free" to be greedy and selfish businesspeople. The state must control business to be fair to the people and environment and not "free" to do whatever it wishes.

    The constitutional convention will flesh out many ideals for a modern ethical, fair and sustainable government.

    Let's bring Palestine's two great religions together with the common values they foster.

    Let's define democracy anew for this critical time.

    Let United Palestine be an example for the future.

    Russ Gustafson

    Redwood City, CA

    01/22/2009 @ 3:40pm


  • Permanent warfare is exactly what Israel wants. That way, it can not only own and ultimately acquire Greater Israel but it can "control" the Palestinians (or any other country that interferes) with its illegal nuclear arsenal. They don't see it as a threat to Zionism. How could it, if Israel controlled the world? It already controls America, so in effect it is Israel, not America, that is the most powerful nation on earth. It is out of control, like a mad Dr. Strangelove.

    stanley hersh

    New York, ny

    01/14/2009 @ 11:19am


  • It is so obvious that the cause of all this truly stems from colonialism, British and American imperialism on the world and the negative affects it creates. Just think about anywhere in the world where first British and then America has colonized and then left it in complete shambles for its native populations.

    Now with US-backed support, Israel is trying to do the same by occupying Palestine and literally creating a concentration camp around the people of GAZA.

    They don't seem to realize or care that Hamas is only doing what any occupied people would do and that is trying to win back their own freedoms. And that this is also, and rightfully so I believe, going to start an uprising of all Muslims and Arabs in the Middle East, in defense of Gaza, and then we are going to wrongfully label them terrorists and use our self righteousness to attack them.

    It amazes me how completely racist the American government is to the Arab and Muslim world, choosing to make these people enemies and "terrorists" because they do not buy into or want our imperial colonialism shoved down their throats and on their land.

    I find it a shame that the Israelites, after suffering at the hands of the Nazis and being put into concentration camps would turn around and do this to another set of human beings. You would think they would be more sympathetic and sensitive to life in general. Not to mention that if the Israelites would think about it for a moment, they would realize they have a lot more in common with the Arab world then they do with Americans. But I guess when the American government is giving you $15 million a day and supplying you with your military weapons and propping you up to feel like you can do whatever you want to the poor people of Palestine/Gaza, that must cut off the circulation to your brain causing you to not Think!

    And what disgusts me more than anything is the American governments backing of Israel's inhumane and horrendous actions towards Gaza. It's that whole colonial Christian American way of thinking that we are better than everyone else in the world and whoever we deem to be terrorists are evil, and that since they are evil, we or whomever we prop up has every right to basically do whatever they want to do to eliminate that nation's way of life. We are basically doing the same exact thing in Iraq.

    And what is even more sad is that by all previous evidence and by the lack of words coming from the incoming Obama administration, I don't believe there is going to be a positive change in this whole situation. We have seen Obama wear a Jewish yarmulke and spend way more time in Israel and AIPAC than in all of the Muslim world combined. And Hillary Clinton is another AIPAC supporter. Rahm Emanuel, and the list goes on. Sad, it really is a sad and disgusting situation.

    I only wish I had more power to do something about it personally and I can only hope that the outcries from the people all around the world will make a difference, before it is too late!

    kristofeR PASSAGGIO

    http://enemyartistkristofer.blogspot.com
    North Hollywood, CA

    01/09/2009 @ 5:39pm


Advertisement
Advertisement

Blogs

» The Beat

Obama's "Finish the Job" Talk Sets Stage for Afghan Troop Surge | But Appropriations Committee chair Obey warns the move would "wipe out every initiative we have to rebuild our own economy."
John Nichols
Posted at 10:45 PM ET

» The Notion

Bad Black Mothers | For African American women, reproduction has never been an entirely private matter.
Melissa Harris-Lacewell
12 Comments

» The Dreyfuss Report

A Kingdom of Bicycles No Longer | China's ambassador for climate change speaks on the eve of the Copenhagen summit meeting.
Robert Dreyfuss
40 Comments

» Act Now!

Coal Country | "This is a civil war."
Peter Rothberg
83 Comments

» Editor's Cut

Around the Nation | The week we went Rouge. Plus, Moyers on Afghanistan.
Katrina vanden Heuvel
114 Comments

» Altercation

Slacker Friday | The "Second Amendment" sale; the raving paranoids of the right.
Eric Alterman