Web Letters: Benazir Bhutto: A Death Foretold

By Graham Usher

December 28, 2007

Write a Web letter about this article.

What's a Web Letter?

Web Letters are continuously published e-mails from real people, signed with their real names. No registration is required. Each article page on The Nation includes a Web Letters link.

Read the best Web Letters on this page.

We're committed to publishing your comments as they are received. We place a red star () on the best submissions and may edit your e-mail for length or content. Your e-mail address will not be published or shared with any third party without your consent.

We look forward to hearing from you.

  • A very perceptive article. However, there are a few historical inaccuracies. Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was not as "secular" as Mr. Usher makes him out to be and Gen. Zia was far less of a true "Islamist" as well.

    First of all, Pakistan was once again declared an "Islamic Republic" in 1973, so in that sense, Bhutto would have to likewise be called an "Islamist" as well. Secondly, compulsory religious instruction was decreed under Bhutto and one of his slogans was "Islamic socialism." Hardly the description of a true secularist. On the other hand, like Bhutto, Gen. Zia also "courted cheap Islamic popularity" of an even harsher nature. In conclusion, both men were not much different in their politically expedient approach to true Islam. See G.H. Jansen, Militant Islam (Harper, 1979), pp. 137-9.

    John Molina

    Chula Vista, CA

    12/30/2007 @ 6:43pm


Advertisement
Advertisement

Blogs

» The Beat

Another Helping of FDR Please | Obama should follow the New Deal president's example and make his Thanksgiving Proclamation a call for economic justice.
John Nichols
5 Comments
Posted 14 minutes ago

» Editor's Cut

Filibuster Follies | "The filibuster has become a cancer growing inside the world's greatest deliberative body."
Katrina vanden Heuvel
66 Comments

» The Notion

Bad Black Mothers | For African American women, reproduction has never been an entirely private matter.
Melissa Harris-Lacewell
87 Comments

» Act Now!

Coal Country | Stunning film reveals new dimensions to the cost of America's over-reliance on coal.
Peter Rothberg
103 Comments

» The Dreyfuss Report

A Kingdom of Bicycles No Longer | China's ambassador for climate change speaks on the eve of the Copenhagen summit meeting.
Robert Dreyfuss
57 Comments