The Nation.

The Mitchell Report Is a Fraud

southpaw

By Dave Zirin

December 14, 2007

Write a Web letter about this article.

What's a Web Letter?

Web Letters are continuously published e-mails from real people, signed with their real names. No registration is required. Each article page on The Nation includes a Web Letters link.

Read the best Web Letters on this page.

We're committed to publishing your comments as they are received. We place a red star () on the best submissions and may edit your e-mail for length or content. Your e-mail address will not be published or shared with any third party without your consent.

If you prefer, you may submit a letter to the print edition only.

We look forward to hearing from you.

  • Leave it once again to Dave Zirin, a rapidly developing world-class muckraker and wordsmith, to pull down the pants of the MLB corporate machine, embodied this time in the empty suit of George Mitchell and his monumentally disingenuous, foul-smelling "report."

    Mitchell's whitewash carries on the grand tradition of such documents as the Warren, Kerner and Kent State commissions, and a few NASA accident reports, where each in its own specific purpose flew in the face of openness, fact-based candor and enlightenment, in favor of subterfuge, doublespeak, driving responsibility intentionally downward and planned obscurity of the truth.

    One can only hope that the controversy over this document will continue, and eventually lead to the real story behind this mess.

    Stewart Braunstein

    Deerfield Beach, FL

    12/15/2007 @ 4:55pm


  • While it's true that owners clearly benefited from all of the long- hitting, juiced-up baseball players, Zirin overlooks the role the players' union and the conduct of the players themselves played in this debacle. Much as I sympathize with the union and its historical fight against the tyranny of the owners (one of baseball's best books is by Marvin Miller on his role in helping establish the players union), the fact is that players realized they could get bigger salaries by hitting more and longer homeruns, and pitchers could strike out more people and have longer careers, by taking steroids. And the union was the enabler in this reality, because the union's job was always to get the best salaries for the players, and should that occur because players were juiced, well, so be it. So it was clearly not in their best interests to push for more stringent drug testing.

    Yet anyone familiar with the damage done to the human body and mind by steroids suggests that the union and the players were playing with people's lives here in a deadly fashion. Think of Ken Caminiti. While his death in 2004 is blamed on a drug overdose, chances are he would still be alive today were it not for steroids and the damage they did to him (he allegedly ODed, but who knows how much of his depression and the fact his heart gave out was due to the consequences of steroids).

    I have always been a big support of the MLBPA in its fight with the owners, and admired the skill of Miller and Fehr, but on the steroid issue, the players and their union have to take responsibility for sullying what is left of baseball's reputation.

    Bruce Livesey

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada

    12/15/2007 @ 11:02am


Popular Topics
Most Searched

Issues »

Most Emailed

Issues »

Blogs

» Campaign 08

McCain Campaign Bans Bush Librarian (Video) | The McCain Campaign drops the hammer on a librarian who dared suggest the supposed "maverick" is like Bush.
Ari Melber

» Capitolism

Can't Keep Brian Beutler Down | Beutler talks to Feingold about FISA
Christopher Hayes

» The Beat

What Obama Should Be Saying About FISA | The Democratic candidate for president could have struck a blow for civil liberties and corporate responsibility today.
John Nichols

» The Dreyfuss Report

The Problem with Power | Samantha, that is. Her Zimbabwe solution is a dangerous step on a slippery slope.
Robert Dreyfuss

» Editor's Cut

Iraq Reconstruction Corruption, Part 7 | The Commission on Wartime Contracting should be a critical curb to the systemic waste, fraud and abuse associated with the wartime-support and reconstruction in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Katrina vanden Heuvel

» The Notion

The Afghan Pipeline You Don't Know About | It was in the planning stages in 2001; now the U.S.-backed Afghan pipeline has returned, but nobody in the mainstream media is writing about it.
Tom Engelhardt

» ActNow!

Of House and Home | Urge Congress to fight back against the subprime swindle.
Peter Rothberg

» Passing Through

Leveraging the Power of Celebrities | With the help of Web 2.0 tools, celebrities can contribute more than just hype to this election cycle.
Michael Connery

» And Another Thing

Preachers and Politics | Secularism looks better and better.
Katha Pollitt