What Newark Schools Need | The Nation


What Newark Schools Need

  • Share
  • Decrease text size Increase text size

Though Booker has no official control over his city's public schools, whose superintendent has reported directly to the state education commissioner since 1995, he is a longtime national advocate for a certain brand of school reform: mayoral control, opening new charter schools, providing vouchers for inner-city children to attend private schools, weakening teacher tenure and tying teacher evaluation and pay to student test scores. He sits on the advisory board of Democrats for Education Reform, which lobbies for such policies, and the $40 million raised so far to match Zuckerberg's $100 million grant comes from donors with a similar focus, including Bill Gates; NewSchools Venture Fund board member John Doerr, a Silicon Valley venture capitalist; and New York City banker Ravenel Curry and his wife, Elizabeth, who have a history of supporting school choice efforts and libertarian think tanks, including the Manhattan Institute and Cato Institute. Booker's older brother, Cary, is the co-founder of Omni Schools, a Memphis-based charter school operator.

About the Author

Dana Goldstein
Dana Goldstein
Dana Goldstein is a Puffin Foundation writing fellow at The Nation Institute and a Schwartz Fellow at...

Also by the Author

To building a lasting peace between teachers unions and communities of color, we can’t forget their most painful battle of all.

The outlook for Mayor de Blasio’s signature initiative just got a whole lot brighter.

It is widely acknowledged that Booker aspires to gain mayoral control of Newark's public school system, New Jersey's largest, with more than 40,000 students. According to state law, that can happen only if the state education department returns local control to the Newark school board. Then the city's voters must approve or reject a referendum on mayoral management. By reeling in a fish as big and rich as Zuckerberg, Booker is making the case to his constituents and to the Republican administration in Trenton that it's high time to return Newark to local control—and his own capable hands.

But on the ground in the city, there are competing visions for education reform. Booker and his allies in the charter school sector could be contrasted with a group of organizations that focus less on opening new schools and more on improving classroom curriculum and instruction in the neighborhood public schools, which educate 86 percent of Newark's children. Caryn Henning, who leads the Children's Literacy Initiative's teacher coaching program in the city, says, "We'd be very excited to have Cory Booker come in and see one of our model classrooms so he can see what is possible.... The neighborhood schools educate the majority of the city, and a lot of them are doing a good job. You need to look at whether what's going on can be replicated anywhere"—not just in charter schools, which tend to have more engaged parents and, in Newark, fewer special education students than in traditional public schools (5 percent versus 12 percent); charter schools also have a less mobile student population, with just 10 percent of their students moving during the school year, compared with 20 percent in the neighborhood schools.

Mayor Booker's critics say he has demonstrated little sustained interest in Newark's neighborhood schools. His defenders cite several projects Booker has worked on in tandem with traditional public schools, such as the Alternative High School Partnership, an effort to serve dropouts, and the YES Center, which connects at-risk public school students with job training. Lauren Wells, director of the Global Village Zone—a project based in part on the wraparound services of Geoffrey Canada's Harlem Children's Zone, except that it partners with neighborhood schools instead of charters—says, "Our work has been very broadly supported by Newark Public Schools and the mayor's office."

The Global Village Zone has raised about $300,000 from foundations, but its goal is to reorganize existing public school resources to serve kids better—proving along the way, hopefully, that education reform can be done without relying on oodles of private dollars: "to actually demonstrate that sustainable and comprehensive reform requires that you do it within the public system," says Wells.

But when Zuckerberg visited Newark on September 25, Booker chose to show him a charter school, the KIPP Newark Collegiate Academy, rather than any of the neighborhood public school programs his administration has supported. Almost every close observer expects the Zuckerberg funds to be devoted, at least in part, to opening new charters—and the mayor's office confirms that this is one likely outcome.

"Booker has not said to the people of Newark, 'Here is my plan,'" notes Junius Williams, director of the Abbott Leadership Institute and a veteran Newark civil rights and public education advocate. "But the circumstantial evidence is his love of charter schools and school choice. So, many of us think the plan has already been written and a good portion of that money will be spent to begin a new round of charter schools."

"I think it's a prepackaged agenda," says Wilhelmina Holder, a paralegal and parent activist who graduated from the city's Weequahic High School in 1969 and has put her three children through the Newark public schools. "No one is giving you money unless you have a design. Come on, let's keep it real here. I think [the Zuckerberg money will be used] not to support public schools but to minimize public schools and build up this whole charter network."

Booker insiders note that the city's charter schools are a popular, oversubscribed option, with more than 6,000 children on waiting lists. But "at the end of the day, the majority of our kids attend district schools, and we understand we need to show progress and significant advancement on the district side," says De'Shawn Wright, a former Booker education adviser and partner at the Newark Charter School Fund. "That's the priority and where we are going to focus the majority of our efforts."

Booker has undoubtedly observed with interest the public relations snafus that have plagued school reform efforts in New York and Washington under mayors Mike Bloomberg (with the Cathie Black fiasco) and Adrian Fenty (erstwhile patron of lightning rod Michelle Rhee). He knows he needs to tread carefully around community affection for and investment in even low-performing schools. To that end, he has chosen to use the first $1 million of the Zuckerberg matching grant to create the Partnership for Education in Newark (PENewark), a coalition of community groups that will conduct a two-month survey of as many Newarkers as possible, asking them how they would spend the Zuckerberg funds. The group is harvesting e-mail addresses, airing TV commercials, making T-shirts and organizing focus groups. But Wright says it will ultimately be up to Newark's incoming superintendent of schools—likely to be named in January by Christie, with input from Booker—to define the education reform agenda moving forward. The new superintendent must be a "coalition builder," Wright says, "somebody who is willing to hear from the community and can demonstrate that the community's voice has been heard, even if his or her final determination is not always 100 percent aligned with those views expressed."

Williams, of the Abbott Leadership Institute, is skeptical of PENewark's outreach efforts, which are led by two New York City consulting firms with ties to the Bloomberg administration, Tusk Strategies and SKDKnickerbocker, which also represents Rhee. "Those of us who've been in the community and involved in this whole question of school reform for years, not just months, I think we already know what people want," Williams says. "They want a good school, a safe school. They want to feel welcome in that school as parents, and they want a teacher who knows what he or she is doing and is culturally sensitive. I don't think you're going to find too much variation on that theme. So what are you going to do with that information once it comes in?"

A newly formed coalition of parents, teachers and civil rights activists called the Coalition for Effective Newark Public Schools is undertaking its own survey. Teams of volunteers are visiting every school in the district, asking principals and assistant principals how quickly maintenance repairs are performed, whether students have enough textbooks and other supplies, whether teachers are teaching outside their areas of expertise and whether there are enough social workers. It's a more practical, nuts-and-bolts effort, designed to get neighborhood schools the basic help they need in a climate of budget cuts and political hostility to public institutions.

Whatever happens to the Zuckerberg money, Lenore Furman, the Abington Avenue kindergarten teacher, hopes she won't have to buy her own classroom supplies anymore. "I spend an infinite amount of my own money," she sighs. "Whatever impact the donation has, I'm always hoping people are making decisions that directly impact learning and instruction."

  • Share
  • Decrease text size Increase text size

Before commenting, please read our Community Guidelines.