Quantcast

That Seventies Show | The Nation

  •  

That Seventies Show

  • Share
  • Decrease text size Increase text size

The continuous readjustment of expectations—downward: that was a key experience of the 1970s. An expectation can be wrenchingly hard to readjust because there is an awful existential lag involved. As historians go, Jefferson Cowie is that awful existential lag's bard.

It Seemed Like Nothing Happened
America in the 1970s.
By Peter Carroll.
Buy this book

The Seventies
The Great Shift in American Culture, Society, and Politics.
By Bruce J. Schulman.
Buy this book

Something Happened
A Political and Cultural Overview of the Seventies.
By Edward D. Berkowitz.
Buy this book

How We Got Here
The 70's: The Decade That Brought You Modern Life—for Better or Worse.
By David Frum.
Buy this book

Right Star Rising

A New Politics, 1974-1980.
By Laura Kalman.
Buy this book

Rightward Bound
Making America Conservative in the 1970s.
Edited by Bruce J. Schulman and Julian E. Zelizer.
Buy this book

America in the Seventies
Edited by Beth Bailey and David Farber.
Buy this book

No Direction Home
The American Family and the Fear of National Decline, 1968-1980.
By Natasha Zaretsky.
Buy this book

Until the Last Man Comes Home
POWs, MIAs, and the Unending Vietnam War.
By Michael Allen.
Buy this book

Roots Too
White Ethnic Revival in Post-Civil Rights America.
By Matthew Jacobson.
Buy this book

Pivotal Decade
How the United States Traded Factories for Finance in the Seventies.
By Judith Stein.
Buy this book

1973 Nervous Breakdown
Watergate, Warhol, and the Birth of Post-Sixties America.
By Andreas Killen.
Buy this book

Decade of Nightmares
The End of the Sixties and the Making of Eighties America.
By Philip Jenkins.
Buy this book

The Shock of the Global
The 1970s in Perspective.
Edited by Niall Ferguson, Charles S. Maier, Erez Manela and Daniel J. Sargent.
Buy this book

Stayin' Alive
The 1970s and the Last Days of the Working Class.
By Jefferson Cowie.
Buy this book

Media

About the Author

Rick Perlstein
Rick Perlstein
Rick Perlstein is the author of Before the Storm: Barry Goldwater and the Unmaking of the American Consensus, winner of...

Also by the Author

The mainstream and liberal press’s quixotic search for a ‘good’ conservative merely reinforces the soft bigotry of low expectations.

Failing upward at the Democratic Leadership Council with Al From.

Cowie is a younger historian at Cornell, whose book Capital Moves: RCA's Seventy-Year Quest for Cheap Labor received a prize for the best book in labor history in 2000. In 2008, with Nick Salvatore, he published a major essay in International Labor and Working Class History, which argued that "while liberals of the seventies and eighties waited for a return to what they regarded as the normality of the New Deal order, they were actually living in the final days of what Paul Krugman later called the 'interregnum between Gilded Ages.'"

I've struggled so long trying to figure out a way to summarize Cowie's new book, Stayin' Alive: The 1970s and the Last Days of the Working Class, that I started worrying I was losing my critical mojo. I've summarized dozens of books in my literary career; it's become rather second nature. Some books, however, are not easy to encapsulate. Often that means the author doesn't know what he or she is doing. Other times, though—much more rarely—the summary is difficult because the work is so fresh, fertile and real that the only thing it resembles is itself. I can't summarize my favorite movie, Jacques Tati's Play Time. You just have to see it. And I can't summarize Stayin' Alive. You just have to read it. It establishes its author as one our most commanding interpreters of recent American experience. It corrals all the generational energies coursing through the centrifuge of post–baby boomer '70s scholarship and churns them into the first compelling, coherent statement I've read of what happened in the '70s.

Laura Kalman expresses well the consequences for a liberalism that formed its operative assumptions in an age of plenty and could not but run into tragedy when it carried forward those assumptions into an era of scarcity. "Inflation made desegregation more costly," she points out. "Democrats had assumed that a pluralistic, interest group–oriented liberalism would benefit all society." Instead of sharing in a cornucopia of abundance, working-class whites and minorities ended up competing "for a very limited piece of pie instead of joining forces to fight for a larger slice." Stein quotes a Nixon economic adviser explaining why that administration decided to repeal a 7 percent investment tax credit designed by the Kennedy/Johnson White House to encourage companies to expand their factories: "There were more important things at this juncture in history to do...than to make even more rapid a rate of growth that is already very rapid or making larger a gross national product in 1975 or 1980 which already in any case is going to be a staggering size." The American Century was supposed to be a century; no one thought it would last only thirty-two years. Cowie's accomplishment is to convey what this epic cheat felt like from the inside. The fact that he is able to do so from the perspective of working people does no less than revivify the moribund genre of labor history.

Here is a taste. It is August 1974, the month of Nixon's resignation. An old-fashioned labor-liberal refuses to cross a picket line at his workplace, single-handedly shutting down production for a month. "It's a matter of principle for me," he says. "I simply refuse to work with anybody who takes money to do a union man's job while that man is on strike.... I could no more go into a building and work with scabs than I could play handball in church." His co-workers were liberals too, but of a newer type. "I don't think he has any support anywhere," one of them says. "It was very noble-sounding, but not, uh, wise." The holdout is a man named Carroll O'Connor, and the workplace is the set of All in the Family at CBS studios, where he plays Archie Bunker.

"Ironically," Cowie discovers, "the real-life labor dispute at CBS prevented O'Connor from taping a four-part set of shows centered on another strike—this one down at Archie's plant.... The four installments of All in the Family, finally made once the strike was settled, centered on Archie's union going on strike over wages and cost-of-living adjustments—exactly the reason that the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW) was striking CBS." As usual, Archie is scripted by the show's creators—liberals too, of that newer type—into being the butt of the joke. "At the end of the made-for-TV dispute—during the entirety of which Archie could not grasp the difference between a flat raise and a cost-of-living adjustment—Archie boasts of winning a 15 percent raise," Cowie writes. "Let's have a toast to the good old US of A, where everybody gets his slice of the pie. All you gotta do is do your work, and in the end ya get it," Archie declares as he is humiliated by the laugh track. The joke—conveyed by the long-haired son-in-law, Mike—is that when the settlement is adjusted for inflation, the bamboozled lunks at Archie's plant make 5 percent less than before. "Archie, and his union (seemingly incapable of bargaining for real wage gains), are the fools as the show ends with everyone knowing that Archie really lost the strike—everyone, that is, except Archie."

In hindsight the joke was on all of us. As Cowie explains, "In a 1976 episode, Archie, brooding over the Democrat Jimmy Carter's White House victory, may not have had the last laugh when he warned that liberals would not be so happy when Ronald Reagan won in 1980. The prophesy was supposed to be an attempt at absurdly dark humor."n

  • Share
  • Decrease text size Increase text size

Before commenting, please read our Community Guidelines.